New American Restaurants near Anna Maria, FL

“Honestly the best meal I’ve had on AMI and we’ve been coming to the beach ten years. Love this new restaurant!“

“Good people, food and vibes!“

“We saw this was very close to where we’re staying when checking out the area before our trip and looked forward to giving it a try - it did not disappoint in any way! The food was fresh and delicious and the owner and staff were friendly. It’s not a huge menu which we appreciated as they focus on what they do great. Good beer selection and great vibe.“

“One of our favorite spots for food .. always go to St Armand’s and decided to check out the Longboat location, it did not disappoint! Views, service, easy docking 💗💗💗“

“Over the top delicious food !!!!every single thing I tasted was so so tasty ,great service, wonderful atmosphere, very personable owner. I would highly recommend it, I’m looking forward to going back .“

“Cute place, first glance walking in, it was very clean looking and feeling. All of our food came out in a timely manor, server was on top of the drinks and checked on us frequently. The owner came over and checked on us and was very friendly as well.“

“We went last night for my sister and brother in laws anniversary. The fish and shrimp were delicious and so fresh. The best I’ve ever had! I highly recommend the Blue Marlin. You won’t be disappointed. Excellent service also. 👍👍👍“

“It was a stormy day that ended with a rainbow at Mar Vista. The food was perfect!!“

“This is THE SPOT. Wow! Their famous Chicken and biscuit was so delicious, juicy and flavorful. Home fries….yes! Kids had Mickey Mouse pancakes and yes, I snuck a few bites. Also one of the few places with a good coffee menu…thank goodness! Espresso Freddo (cold) hit the spot on a hot day. Service was 100%.“

“Totally worth the wait for their re-opening! Absolutely amazing food and cocktails and not as pricey as one would think! Amazing, knowledgeable staff…listen to what they say and you won’t be disappointed.“

“We had a fantastic experience at Compass Bar & Chill -- thanks to our wonderful server, Cindy. She was incredibly friendly and hospitable, making us feel right at home from the moment we sat down at the pool area. Cindy promptly took our drink orders and brought them with a smile, then followed up to take our food order. Everything—from the delicious fish tacos to the perfectly cooked quesadillas—was spot on. She checked in to make sure everything was to our liking, and her attentive service truly stood out. Five stars all the way!“

“This place NEVER😋 let's me down. Delicious breakfast sandwiches.“

“A very pleasant surprise that we stumbled upon. We decided to drive back into IMG at the 53rd Street entrance. We found the Legacy hotel. That’s where we found the cozy Icon grill. It happened to be happy hour an appetizers were half off along with drink specials. The food was excellent and we have shared this special place with many friends. The atmosphere was a bit loud since it sits almost in the hotel lobby. The outside is quiet and beautiful, sitting on a small lagoon.“

“An Exquisite Culinary Gem — Worth Every Bite and Every Moment! Euphemia Haye is nothing short of a culinary treasure on Longboat Key — a rare combination of world-class cuisine, romantic ambiance, and impeccable service that turns a meal into a memory. Extraordinary doesn’t begin to cover it. 😊Every dish was prepared with intentionality, artistry, and flavors that sing. The peppered steak was cooked to perfection, bursting with bold seasoning and succulent texture. Even the salads were elevated: fresh, inventive, and beautifully plated. But wait until you ascend to the Haye Loft — a magical dessert and after-dinner cocktail lounge unlike anything we’ve experienced. We were dazzled by the live music, the cozy, retro-cool vibe, and of course… the legendary dessert bar. From the banana cream pie to the flourless chocolate torte, every sweet was handcrafted, decadent, and delightful. Service was flawless throughout. The staff were knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely passionate about the food and experience. They anticipated our needs before we even realized we had them — the mark of true hospitality excellence. Whether you’re celebrating something special or simply want to enjoy one of the finest dining experiences in Florida, Euphemia Haye is unmissable. It’s more than a restaurant — it’s a destination. And we’ll be returning every chance we get. Bravo to the entire team!🌟“

“Wonderful dinner experience as usual. The food, drinks and service was terrific. There were 6 of us...2 had the Chateaubriand, 2 had the Chicken Francais and 2 had the short ribs. All of our meals were amazing including the salads and desserts. The ambience is chic, warm and so inviting. And unlike so many other restaurants on the island, this one takes reservations! Definitely one of the best dining experiences on the island!“

“Well what can i say.....since am super active 5 days of gym and 2 days of cardio,you really want some real protein.
This chicken provides all the protein i need and not only that.......it taste soooooo good 😋
This is a great healthy meal and the service is so good“

“Had another fantastic breakfast at Peach's on Manatee today. It's my go-to whenever I'm here and it was great to be back a year after the storms. Had the veggie omelet with wheat toast and grits. Can I also say I appreciate grits made the way they should be, thick and savory. I always add cheese to top them off. I'll definitely be back 😋“

“Very friendly wait staff, good food at the right price. A place where locals and visitors are all welcome. I had a big ole burger, side of fries and unsweet fresh ice tea…yummy.“

“Great service from Holly last night! We were recommended to come into Sharky’s and we were very very satisfied. The prime rib was amazing and I loved their creamy seafood soup. Holly was so attentive, refreshing, and funny. We are definitely coming back! 5 Stars ⭐️ check it out folks.“

“This place had THE BEST bagel breakfast sandwiches! Fresh and REAL ingredients and the owner and staff were amazing! We will definitely frequent this place a few times whenever we’re blessed to be on the island. They made you feel like old friends, like we were locals. We talked about it the whole way to the airport. Thanks Jackie for the wonderful send off! Curious George and Jenn.“

“I just provided DJ services there for a recent wedding and it was great. The room is small but is perfect for smaller size weddings and the staff is wonderful.“