50 Best Italian Restaurants near Cutler Bay

“Restaurant was on the busy side, but it closer to closing time. Restaurant was clean, restrooms were clean. Staff was great. Friendly & polite
Our server was Oliver, he was great. Our food was great as well. Hot & fresh. Our portions were large.“

“Delicious pizza! Loved the pear and fig. Yummy. Thank you for coming out to Calusa and treating us to such a delicious lunch. Will definitely go with my family soon.“

“Everyone in my family order different dishes, everything was amazing!! Great ambiance.“

“This place has a great atmosphere! Staff is on point and the service is too! And the food? It doesn’t get any better than this😊 Do yourself a favor and stop in!“

“If you’re looking for amazing pizza, this is the place! The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for family dinners or a night out with friends. The staff is friendly, attentive, and quick, making the whole experience even better. Definitely one of the best pizza Italian spots around—I’ll be coming back again and again!“

“J C gives personal service and the food was exquisite!“

“Food great...beer cold....prices great....staff awesome. ....5 stars for good local Italian meal....If you want Olive Garden....then go there that means i will have a table to sit at at Enzos!“

“Amazing extrasensory experience:
From the moment we entered to the moment we left they treat and cuddle us as Family.
What to say about Chef Marco Giuliano : Michelin star coming soon!
Thanks a lot to you and all your professional staff for the HOSPITALITY!
Best Restaurant in Miami !!!“

“Everything is delicious The Pasta, Pizza garlic rolls. Sangria is amazing!!!“

“This is such a delightful place. The food is superb. For starters we have carpacho arugula salad, stuffed braised beef mushroom, pear raviolis, (because we needed to try as much as we could) lol. The service resembled a white glove affair. The salmon was smothered in a dark sugar sauce. The sangria was sooooo refreshing. Our waiter Gussepi was so eager to please that how can we not write a review, and order almost everything from the specials for this night, (because it just sounded so delicious). I recommend this place with closed eyes. Your experience will be a memorable one, and your pallet will be filled with delightful taste resembling a food Ecstasy. The crowd was a reasonably middle to upper class crowd. They open at 6pm for dinner on weekdays and a reservation is advised, but they do not look as if they turn anyone away. The entire staff is so happy and pleasant as well as equally eager to please. Enrique is so attentive to details. The entire staff serves everyone. You are not isolated to one server, they all pitch in to make the customers experience a uniquely enjoyable one. The restrooms are immaculate. I also noticed the LACK of mold, mildew, and cobwebs in the dining area. This restaurant is as clean and neat as the food is superb. Hats off to you all. We appreciate you.“

“The best pizza I have ever had in my life. Authentic and Our new favorite restaurant. This us all imported from Italy not the the temu version of Italian. Thank You“

“This Olive Garden is the best I've ever visited. The layout and brightness of the restaurant make it very inviting. The food was good and the service was outstanding. Muriel was a great server. Would recommend and would consider again if in the area.“

“I was just in Italy and Capri the food here is as good as on the Island and they have a great birthday gift at birthdaycomp, $25 off your dinner! Celebrate your next birthday there its awesome and Italian!“

“Súper rico y muy amables excelentes Uno de mis lugares favoritos“

“Very good services everyone united & helping out at Hoans & Jason baby shower. Will definitely go back for dinner when in area.“

“A Hidden Italian Gem in Miami ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I stumbled upon this restaurant by chance one day, and it quickly became my absolute favorite. Without a doubt, it’s one of the best Italian restaurants in Miami. Every visit feels like a five-star experience — the service is flawless, the atmosphere is warm and elegant, and the food is simply outstanding. Congratulations to the chef and the entire team for maintaining such a high standard of excellence. Highly recommended!“

“This is without a doubt the best lomo saltado in Miami and the smoked salmon, cream cheese and avocado lumpia from another planet. They have different sauces, some better than others. My husband brought it home and I was eager to try more of his creations. Super recommended, the food is excellent, the portions large, the quality of the ingredients A+. Don't forget to try it 305 Foodie is incredibly EXQUISITE!“

“Good Food and nice people“

“Best secret in Kendall. Love this place. The service is superb, great food and beautiful ambience“

“Delicious big portions homemade authentically Italian food.“

“The food is outstanding in its quality, preparation, presentation, and taste. We would eat there weekly rather than yearly if it were not for the kind of music they play. It undermines all the other outstanding aspects of the experience. They need to discover calm, romantic classical, or opera.“

“Everything they prepare there is absolutely delicious. You have to try. It's in the food court of Florida City Outlets. Many shops to buy very cheap and later La Churrasqueria !!“

“This is a great local and family owned place. Delicious pizza!“

“Excellent food! Exceptional staff!!“

“Excellent Service from Erick
Erick took care of us today, and his service was absolutely outstanding! He was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. His positive attitude and professionalism truly made our dining experience special. Thank you, Erick, for your excellent service — we’ll definitely be coming back! 👏✨“

“Is my first time eating here I was passing by with my niece after a Broadway show and we really enjoy it. The lemonade was from the house and it was delicious. And everything that we ate there was delicious made fresh. I really recommend this place. I'm coming again with my family.“

“My first pick whenever I'm craving pasta. The attention, the environment, the music and of course the food is amazing. Olive Garden has a perfect balance between being fancy and not expensive at all, and we all love that. I highly recommend this Italian restaurant!“

“We hosted a Cancer fundraiser at Pummarlo. It was such a great time for a good cause. We loved having a pizza class, making the dough to take home and then eating a personal size pizza. The staff was amazing and so much fun. Will definitely be back. Great night out with delicious food.“

“I am Italian and we are here on Holiday. We feel like eating in Italy. Very Very Good Foods. Cordiality Top“

“Love this place, awesome food and great service.“

“I got Ravioli's with chicken parm. Wow! This food was really, really, good! They use their own sauce which is also really good (they sell the sauce too all natural ingredients). I took it to-go and it was really, really hot. The packaging is a little flimsy and hard to reuse so I just ate everything lol! I'll try the pizza next time. Looks like ya got yourself a new customer.“

“Fantastic Pizza !!! Do not miss the Pizza Class !!! outstanding !!!!“

“Very good every time we go“

“The food is good and the menu is varied. The staff is helpful and it’s a fun experience.“

“Great local center with eatery variety and much more“

“Excellent customer service. They are aimed to please their customers. From the welcoming host to the kitchen staff, they make your dining experience memorable. Food is excellently prepared and presented, and moderately priced. Saturday is our weekly date night, and Amici is the steady place to go. If you’re lucky to have DIEGO as your server, you will never stop going there. He’s friendly, pleasing, knowledgeable about the menu, all his plate recommendations are great! You walk in and he makes you feel like family 😊🇮🇹🍝🍷. I can’t stop saying good things about this restaurant‼️ I highly recommend eating at Amici, you’ll thank me later 👍“

“Very good food And service….“

“Great food 🍱 great service, love the location also .my favorite so far is the pizza .“

“I want to start off saying that I have eaten at most restaurants in Miami, including many places during Miami Spice, and not one single restaurant compares to the amazing experience I had at Papa Riccos. This is truly the first restaurant I would consider the Michelin Star rating system needs to review. I walked in to have dinner with my wife and newborn. The place is very small and clearly not fancy, but instantly the server was at our side to make us comfortable and to help us get situated with our newborn. Service was extremely quick and the manners of the gentleman serving us had us feeling as if we were royalty. We quickly ordered the mussels Marinara, and oh boy the meal started off incredible. It was clear from the first bite that every single ingredient was made from scratch. The mussels were steamed perfectly, and the red sauce was divine. I could taste all the separate ingredients, while also admiring how they all came together. We ordered a pasta manticone (sure that is spelled wrong) and it was hands down the single best pasta I have eaten in my entire life. Every cheese was fresh, pasta perfectly soft, and a sensation of creaminess filling my mouth with every bite. I am currently salivating just thinking about it. The pasta came with a small lentil soup, which came out in 1 minute, which was another amazing part of this meal. We also had garlic rolls which were crunchy on the outside, yet so fluffy and flavorful on the inside. Mixing these rolls with the red sauce from the mussels marinara was truly orgasmic. Finally we shared the pizza Fiorentina, adding garlic as we love garlic, and man did the pizza pass every test. Multiple cheeses, extremely fresh leafy greens and tomatoes, and the dough itself was exceptional. The pizza did not flop, again the crust was crunchy and fluffy at the same time, and the cheese was stretchy from the first slice to the last. Somehow an Iranian owned Italian restaurant has become my absolute best eating experience in all of Miami, and for a great price as well. If it is a quiet date night, or an outing with the family, I will always recommend Papa Riccos moving forward. 15 out of 10 stars.

On a side note, I am also a home inspector and mold inspector, and it was apparent that they treat their restaurant building with the same care they treat their food. Amazing ownership and cleanliness!“

“New for me. Called. Automated system texted me a link to order online. Easy to order and checkout. I live fairly close so I immediately left to pick it up. I got there 10-12 minutes later, drove up, pizza was ready and waiting. Cheery lady gave me my pizza and off I went! I'm so happy with this experience. I'll be ordering other pizzas (I got Hawaiian) in the future and seeing it becomes my "go to" local pizza place.“

“Excelente comida muy rica y una atencion muy buena me encanta el lugar muy limpio y los tragos exquisitos super bueno para Pasar en familia o con los amigos super ? ?“

“Great place! Service is exceptional!! The best place for deli sandwiches!“

“Excellent pizza!!! highly recommended 👍👍👍👍“

“Great food together with great service!!!! Love Mike's Pizza. Awesome family restaurant!!!!“

“Excellent service! Delicious food and amazing atmosphere! 100% recommended“

“I hear alot of cool things about u guys Ferraris way better than Mamma Mias Big Cheese Steve's and Marco's. more Italian flavor I'll there Monday for lunch for my birthday.“

“Just had lunch at Vesuvio Pizzeria and it was great! The pizza was fresh, cheesy, and had a perfectly crispy crust. The atmosphere felt cozy and welcoming, and the staff were friendly and quick. Definitely worth stopping by if you’re in the area!“

“came here for the first time to the restaurant with my family two weeks ago on a Friday the restaurant was full of people, the pizza was great but I have to compliment the waiter, he had a lot to do and in any case he managed to do all the work…. we will be back again I hope to see the waiter again who served us we can see that he has experience in restaurants and also compliments to the pizza chef for the excellent pizzas“

“Everything!…you can’t go wrong…“

“Outstanding, most helpful customer service; dependable, fast delivery (ordered from out of state) !!! Thank you Carlo !“