50 Best Italian Restaurants near Key Biscayne

“This was our favorite restaurant in Key Biscayne. The owners are incredible. The food is top notch and influenced from Northern Italy. I loved the chicken parmigiana. However, believe it or not my favorite item was the key lime pie. I ate probably 20 pieces of key lime all through the Keys and they simply had the best.“

“Delicious food. The grilled octopus was amazing!“

“Went on a Tuesday evening and there were only a few patrons inside. Waitress gave me a few recommendations which I took. The slow cooked vacio was tender & delicious. Was like your grandmother did the cooking. The a jus it was served with was full of flavor. If you enjoy meat & potatoes this is your dish. They serve it with a butter knife:)
The limoncello cake for desert was unique and delicious as well. Thoroughly enjoyed my meal and I look forward to a return trip.“

“Wonderful place! We had lunch here on a Saturday evening and everything was perfect. The portions of the dishes were great for the prices, and just as tasty. Our server, Gisela, was very friendly and explained the menu of the day. The coffee was also just as good as the entrees. And the music was the cherry on top--tranquil italian jazz.“

“Recomiendo todo porque lo hacen muy rico todo sus platos“

“I wanted my wedding to be beautiful and perfect, so I went with this shop to inquire about lovely flowers that fitted for the occasion. Also, this shop has a big space to walk around and look for different pets to buy. It was very nice to visit here, and I was glad that I finally had my dreamed pet. Thank you!“

“The hard part is entrance. You go through a gate, to the end to a guest parking then enter the building and turn right then left. After a confusing entrance there is a very quiet restaurant with nice spacing, great for having conversations. Server was great and helpful with choosing appetizers, entrees and wine. Pasta was on-point and very balanced. All in all, a great place for both a romantic date or a business dinner. Will return.“

“Excelente todo. Atención rápida y cálida. Platos exquisitos . hoy probé dos menúes diferentes y fueron excelentes. Ademas buen precio“

“Best Italian restaurant in Miami“

“I had a fantastic experience last night! The service is top tier--Marco and the rest of the staff are kind, knowledgeable, and attentive. I had the best beef carpaccio ever--try it, they put a unique spin on the traditional dish--followed by the baby artichoke hearts and accompanied by an amazing Swiss Pinot Noir from Lucas Madonia. One of the best dinners I've had in a while and I'm frequently out. Highly recommend this quirky and cool restaurant!“

“If you love thin crust pizza, this is your place! They bring creativity to pizza which I love. Can’t wait to taste each and every one! Would love to see cannoli’s offered with dessert coffees.“

“I first had the pleasure of dining here nearly two years ago, and it instantly became one of my favorite restaurants. From the warm atmosphere to the unforgettable flavors, everything about the experience was exceptional. The plate of pasta I had on that first visit was so memorable, it’s still the background on my phone — and I’ve made multiple trips to Miami just to come back and enjoy it again. The quality has never wavered. I can’t recommend this place highly enough.“

“I came for happy hour and I had an amazing experience. From 4 to 7 they do buy one get one free drinks, I got two margaritas and they were delicious! My friend got lychee martinis and they were also amazing. For appetizer to snack on we got salmon tartar, which was unbelievable for the price. Our server, Barbara was amazing, super friendly, and super helpful. I could not recommend this place more to anybody else.“

“Great experience and delicious food World class service“

“Melania amazing server, she recommended the most amazing pasta for me and my girlfriend loved.“

“I really enjoyed this place, my server alejando went above and beyond to take care of us. Even turned many fans on since it’s very hot in Miami so my baby wouldn’t be hot. I loved food and ambiance I will for sure be back and hopefully I get the same experience and server. Just one thing make sure you make a reservation it’s a hidden gem and it gets booked.“

“Our orders were delicious and fresh. Will definitely visit again.“

“Great pasta, great wine, amazing vibe!!“

“One of our favorite restaurants!“

“I had heard about this hot restaurant from New York that I must try, but was reticent to do so because Carbone was the name of a character from Goodfellas that Robert Deniro's Jimmy Conway whacked when tying up loose ends after the Lufthansa job! Poor sap was hanging frozen in a meat locker. I'm glad I put that imagery aside because this place was amazing! Platitudes like wonderful ambience, fine service, flavorful food, great family style dining, are all applicable but just don't capture the full spirit of the evening. From the pickled cauliflower, to the signature spicy rigatoni ala vodka (which pairs nicely with their pinot noir offering Presqu'ile), to the Caesar salad (you must have those croutons!), and their delicious Italian petit-fours, everything burst with flavor and was resplendent of the authenticity of old Venice. And since you will be spending more than a few pennies here, one must luxuriate in the mid century environs replete with Murano glass chandeliers while being serenaded with a sound track of Italian crooners like Mel Torme and Frank Sinatra in the full bela canta tradition. If you have a special occasion, Carbones Miami Beach will make for a memorable evening.“

“Valentina is absolutely wonderful! She is so kind, friendly, and always has a smile on her face. Sheis incredibly helpful and always happy to answer our questions and offer recommendations. Thank you so much, Valentina, for making our experience so pleasant! We truly appreciate your excellent service.“

“We had such a wonderful experience! The food was absolutely delicious, and full of flavor. Every dish we ordered was excellent, and the atmosphere was warm and welcoming.

A special thank you to Chantale, who made our visit truly memorable. She was incredibly friendly, attentive, and professional, always checking in at just the right time and making sure we had everything we needed. Her genuine kindness and outstanding service made us feel so well taken care of.

We'll definitely be back and highly recommend Piola to anyone looking for a fantastic meal paired with exceptional hospitality. Thank you, Chantale, for making our evening so enjoyable!“

“Food was great, Italian atmosphere and great service. Special thanks to our server Mirko“

“they were out of main dishes which sucked. but its always delicious (:

in my opinion they have the best desserts. their tiramisu is so unique and delicious. would keep going back just for that. highly recommend ordering it when you go wat there. definitely make a reservation, the chances of you being able to get a seat without one during the weekend is slim. its worth going to!“

“Cena a base di ostriche buonissime. Great service from Tony !“

“We stayed in Miami for a couple of nights and tried different places for dinner , but this one was on a whole different level. The food , Service and the staff was sooo good. Authentic and a must go.
Shot out goes to the chef for giving personalised service and making us feel so special. He is the kindest and made food personally which was very delicious.
MUST GO“

“Agusto & Ronaldo were amazing!! Very attentive, kind, and amazing service. Came here for the first time with family to celebrate my birthday and it was unforgettable. Would definitely come back. Food was delicious as well, highly recommend coming here!“

“Friendly service, great place for a date“

“Family friendly restaurant best tasting pasta plates and ricotta chocolate dessert. A must try if in Miami area. Vincenzo was our waiter and we couldn’t have asked for a better service! Definitely a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ very good place!!!!“

“Awesome food ! Incredible atmosphere!!!“

“We will be back. outstanding service. The food was incredible. We started with a small charcuterie board. One of the best we have had. The arugula salad was very fresh. Can't wait to come back and try more pasta dishes. Truly our favorite restaurant we found during our trip.“

“We celebrated my birthday at Sofia and had great experience. Our sitting was very comfortable under the pink umbrella, the food and drink were great and our server Patrizio was amazing, he made us feel very welcome. Definitely recommend to take a break from shopping at the Design District at Sofia Miami.“

“Great staff, amazing food and awesome views!“

“Best salad … shrimp beets avocado OMG … 10 out of 10“

“Best authentic Napoletana pizza you can find in Miami. Thought I was back home. Food is fire people. Need to try this place. Love pasta? They do not disappoint. So good. Acacia provided amazing service this last visit. She was very attentive and prompt. The entire staff is great. Many of them speak Italian and make you feel at home.“

“Mamo is a must if you like sensational food, impeccable service and a stunning setting. The Chef Salvatore, is without a doubt Oscar winning in the Restaurant world. I recommend this restaurant very highly. You will not be disappointed, trust me.“

“Everything was great the pizza salad wine“

“The drinks were perfect, the wine list extensive and the food delicious. The rack of lamb was done to perfection and the pastas divine. Highly recommend going. Can’t wait to go back“

“Me and my husband Came to Torno Subito to ran away from the rain and Claudia and Victor gave us the best service. We had a reservation at another restaurant but we ended up being late because the ambience and the service is the best and people are so lovely and attentive we wanted to stay here for the rest of the night! Thank you“

“There delicious Italian food made fresh and there great service ! And it's family friendly“

“what a great restaurant great service, very friendly and professional. the food delicious, causy place for couple and groups“

“We had lunch at Felice in Brickell today and it was AMAZING. We drove from Fort Lauderdale and its location is so easy to reach from I-95 and we loved the valet parking so prompt. The restaurant has a wonderful outside dining area, made private by luscious plants, fans, heaters, modern furniture and decor, but we opted to dine inside due to the bad weather. The dining room is quite elegant but contemporary, the tablecloths and silverware on point, which is important for us. The overall service quality was superb, from hostess Manuela's warm reception, to Flavio the manager's exquisite charm, to the skilled waiter's attentiveness, and we even got to meet Chef Luigi to compliment him on each of the dishes we enjoyed. Most importantly, everyone was really Italian and spoke Italian, which was so refreshing, since we are also Italian from the actual Country ! We loved the refined ambiance and relaxed atmosphere which made the authentic Northern Italian dishes taste even better ! Food and drink wise: the Mojito we started with was most delicious ! A Bubbly Prosecco DOC was our choice to enjoy the meal. For appetizers we had Tuna Carpaccio with capers, but it was as fancy as a Tuna Tartar, and scrumptious shrimps in pink sauce with a touch of Jalapeno. For the entrees, we went with the New York strip with Truffle and Mushroom which came inside a fancy copper pan; we were impressed by the very generous portion boasting an aroma and flavor we hardly tasted anywhere else other than Italy, and a classic Branzino al Cartoccio, which came inside the actual "cartoccio" it was baked within, and its freshness and flavor were amazing. Side dishes were delicious too: we ordered char-grilled asparagus and the best home made French Fries EVER! All the food was "clean", fresh, cooked to perfection, with no heavy sauce or seasoning covering/altering the actual flavor of the main ingredients like most "Italian" restaurants do here in Sfla. We appreciated that immensely! We "tried" to end with a nice espresso only.....but they insisted we had a bite of their Tiramisu dessert and we obliged. Obviously, it was delicious too. Hence, as far as REAL Italian restaurants in South Florida are concerned, we recommend this place wholeheartedly, and we will be back very soon to taste more of their dishes. OVERALL : 10 STARS!!!!!“

“Sapore Di Mare in Coconut Grove offers an enchanting dining experience that harmonizes exquisite cuisine with impeccable service and a warm, inviting ambiance. The evening began with a bottle of Montepulciano D'Abruzzo, Gran Sasso. This wine, with its rich, full-bodied flavor and subtle hints of dark fruit, set a perfect tone for the meal. For the main course, the Lasagna al Brasato di Short Ribs e Tartufo was an absolute delight. The layers of tender short ribs, perfectly cooked pasta, and a generous amount of truffle made every bite an orgasmic experience. This dish is a true testament to the chef's skill and creativity. The Ravioli di Ossobuco was another highlight. The ravioli, filled with succulent ossobuco, was served in a delicate sauce that complemented the richness of the filling. The balance of flavors and textures in this dish was impeccable. To conclude the meal, we indulged in the Pastiera Napoletana for dessert. This traditional Neapolitan cake, with its sweet and creamy ricotta filling, was the perfect ending to an exceptional dining experience. The service at Sapore Di Mare was outstanding. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about ensuring a memorable dining experience. The ambiance of the restaurant, with its elegant decor and cozy atmosphere, further enhanced the overall enjoyment of the evening. In summary, Sapore Di Mare in Coconut Grove is a must-visit for anyone seeking a top-tier Italian dining experience. From the exquisite food to the exceptional service and delightful ambiance, every aspect of the restaurant exceeds expectations.“

“Very good food, and they were all very attentive, I will recommend dining there 100%.“

“Lunch at Bellini’s at Mr. C’s: An Italian Escape in Coconut Grove. Friday afternoon lunch for girlfriends to catch up. From the moment we arrived at Bellini’s, with a warm welcome from Beni and his staff, the restaurant’s elegant ambiance and breathtaking views of Biscayne Bay set the stage for an enjoyable afternoon. Service was impeccable—attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely warm. We were quickly seated and offered a selection of fine Italian wines. Choosing a crisp Gavi de Gavi to compliment, the Tagliolini with white Alba truffles was truly the highlight of our meal. This dish was a true celebration of Italian culinary artistry: the pasta was perfectly al dente, and the generous shavings of white truffle added an earthy, aromatic richness that elevated every bite. The chef’s restraint allowed the delicate flavors to shine, making each mouthful both decadent and refined. Thank you Bellini, we will be back.“

“Ten out of ten. Mother Wolf Miami delivered one of the best Italian meals I’ve had outside of Italy, honestly, I’d imagine this is close to the real thing.

We started with the panzanella salad, which was fresh and perfectly balanced. The lamb chops were cooked beautifully, and the gnocchi were pillowy soft with incredible flavor. We finished with the tiramisu, which was the perfect ending to the meal.

Our server, Ryan, made the night even better , attentive, knowledgeable, and just genuinely great to have at our table.

Can’t recommend this place enough. Already thinking about when we can go back.“

“Great food and very nice 🍺“

“My experience at Donatella was amazing. I reserved a seat for one and upon arrival I was quickly seated. I was served by a server named Nana. He was very attentive & caring for my experience at the restaurant. The food and drinks were great. My favorite dish was the salad of grilled pears and goat cheese. Alongside that, I ordered the prime ribeye & roasted potatoes. It was a ton of delicious food, great portions. I will return again and the price is very well worth it.“