10 Best American Restaurants in Dade City

“Another great meal at the Black Eyed Pea! Sandy took our order quickly and gave us great service. All the staff of the Black Eyed Pea are always friendly and engaging. We noticed that Taylor L gave really good service to her table too. Thank you for making us feel like family. We love you guys!“

“Always yummy food & Friendly staff!!!“

“Chloe was our server and she is probably one of the best servers we've ever had going out to eat anywhere. She was friendly and attentive to our every need without being overbearing. She even knew we wanted dessert, even though we said we didn't. She saw us looking at the desert menu and came back to take our order. We had the shrimp scampi, and she suggested not having it over the noodles if we were liking a different option so I had mine over the broccolini which saved me a whole bunch of calories which I then used for a amazing! crème brûlée for dessert my husband ordered the pork chops which were cooked too perfection. He had the Brandy bread pudding and I got to sneak a taste, and it was wonderful as well. The restaurant is so authentic and fun. You just never know what your eye will land on next from the staghorn hanging over the bar to the black and white photos on the wall showing the Ford garage that stood there before. One of our favorite places and we have to drive almost two hours to get to it. Bonus the prices are so reasonable. We go out a lot and sometimes the price just takes the fun out of the meal. My shrimp scampi was $20 and had 10 quite large shrimp. My Husband's meal was $32. We left feeling we had had a wonderful experience as well as a delicious meal for a more than reasonable price again accolades to Chloe who was a delight and just made all the above so much sweeter.“

“I had the American cheeseburger with fries for lunch today and it was so delicious, even as takeout! DEFINITELY recommend. This was one of the best cheeseburgers I’ve EVER had! Green Door Brooksville 🫶🏼“

“I met Dawn when I chose her to cater my wedding. She’s a genuine woman who knows how to cook! (Reminds me of my mamas cookin’). She & her team did a phenomenal job at my wedding, from the apps to the dinner. Outstanding. I also stop by Dinner’s Ready in Dade City for a home cooked meal when I don’t feel like cooking and it’s always delicious.“

“Love the Bingo nights and they help out local schools, not for profit clubs and more!!“

“the bbq was the best I have had in a very long time..and I love the Bubbaques Moonshine spicy vinegar sauce..“

“Tonight, we came in around 6:30pm and were pleasantly greeted by Michelle. The restaurant was completely empty except our family of 3, when within 5 minutes of seating us, two sets of couples and a 15 person party came in. Michelle handled everything with such grace and professionalism. She even hopped in the kitchen to help the cook prepare food for the larger party.

You have a gem, and I hope you know this and appreciate her.“

“My husband and I come here frequently but today I had the most helpful young man named Joshua who told me about the senior specials and because of that we will be able to dine here more often 😁 not very many places still have senior discount day anymore. Captain D's is the best!“

“I hadn’t eaten at Beef O’Brady’s in years, so this was my first visit to this location—and what a great surprise! The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a familiar face I hadn’t seen in a long time, complete with a warm hug that instantly made the visit special.

I ordered the BBQ Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese Burger with seasoned curly fries, and let me tell you—this burger was a beast and absolutely delicious. Everything was cooked to perfection. The fries were tasty, just a bit cold, so I didn’t eat many of them.

Our waitress was fantastic and provided top-notch service from start to finish. Overall, a great experience, and I’ll definitely be back. Highly recommend stopping by if you’re ever in the area!“