Mystic Ice Cream

Name: Mystic Ice Cream
Address: 38 E. Magnolia Ave. in, Eustis, Florida, 32726, US
Telephone: (352) 812-1366
Rating: 4.8

Ice Cream

Hours:
38 E. Magnolia Ave. in, Eustis
(352) 812-1366

Mystic Ice Cream Reviews

4.8 (45)

Write a review

November 2023

SO GOOD! They have so many flavors that were so enticing, it was hard to choose. They have adult flavors (infused with alcohol) and normal flavors. I had the grasshopper (alcohol infused) and the banana pudding, they were delicious! The two ladies working were very nice and let us try multiple flavors. I loved the 80's vibe with records all over the place and they have multiple tables to sit and enjoy your ice cream.

October 2023

Cute hippy-style retro ice cream shop. Everything is homemade there. You can get adult alcohol-infused or typical ice cream, sundaes and shakes. They also make waffle cones snd bowls for $1 more. I had a small (2-scoop) mint chocolate chip and chocolate peanut butter. It was very good. Server was helpful and friendly but working alone slows things down if they are busy. Prices are reasonable.

October 2023

An eclectic little shop in the heart of downtown Eustis. There were plenty of traditional and crafty ice cream creations to choose from, including selection for adults (alcoholic). Some of the names required more explanation as to what the ingredients were, but don't worry, taste tests are allowed.I found the chocolate incredibly smooth and rich, but a bit heavy after a while. The small portions were quite large in my opinion, not a traditional small single scoop. I'd prefer a...read full review

More Reviews(45)