10 Best Italian Restaurants near Fellsmere

“We stopped in last week...amazing! The pizza and salad were on point...and OMG the fresh hot bread!! It was a perfect dinner choice during a long week.“

“The Italian American Club is truly a hidden gem in our community! From the moment you walk through the doors, you’re greeted with warmth, friendliness, and a strong sense of belonging. The club consistently hosts fun and engaging events—from themed dinners and live music to holiday parties and fundraising events that support local causes. The members are welcoming, and the atmosphere is always lively and full of good cheer. It’s the perfect place to meet new people, reconnect with friends, and celebrate culture and many traditions. The food is fantastic, the drinks are well-priced, and the volunteers work hard to make every event enjoyable. Whether you're there for a casual evening or a big celebration, the Italian American Club never disappoints. NO, you don't have to be Italian to join. Highly recommend joining or attending one of their events—you’ll feel like part of the family in no time!“

“The wings are delicious.also,the onion rings and chicken wings.Great services 😋🥰🥰“

“Three of us first timers there Saturday night. We will be back again with more friends. We all ordered 3 different menu entrees and they were delicious. The tomato bisque was exceptional as was our server, Keri. All the tables were full and the servers, food runners and bus people kept everything running smoothly. Having had a restaurant background, I was impressed and that's not easy to do. Glad we found this jewel.“

“We were looking for a place close to where we were staying, this was only 4 miles away. Very quaint, clean, our waiter was awesome (thanks Andrew/Drew)!!! The food was yummy... had lasagna and manicotti. Nice and hot, the sauce was really good, and the bread they serve was nice and warm with soft butter (my mother-in-law would've loved that, huge pet peeve for her!). So glad we just happened to find this place. I think it must be a hidden gem. We will definitely be back.“

“Best pizza I’ve ever had! We were visiting from out of town and went 2x. Can’t wait to come back!!!“

“All the food is excellent!! Had the margarita pizza last night and it was by far the best i have had in a long time!!!“

“Love this place! Great pizza and always super nice to my son when we come in. Super friendly! Highly recommended“

“The server was very nice. The pizza is amazing. I’ve tried everything on the menu, and everything was Amazing.“

“Normally I’d highly recommend Davila’s Pizza East. I’ve never gotten poor quality food from there before. Evening of Nov 12, 2025 I ordered delivery thru Instacart from Davilas East, and ordered a pasta dish called Shrimp Scampi. I wish I could post the pic / description / price from their online menu vs what I received. It was so disappointing! I tried to request a partial refund or credit thru Instacart and basically got back a message saying they understood how frustrating that must have been and hope it doesn’t happen again in the future. (Thannnnnnnnnnnks lol)“