“Warning: This place can be habit-forming! From the mouth-watering aromas that greet you as you step inside, to the delectable desserts and everything in between, your taste buds are in for a treat that will leave you thoroughly satisfied.“
“We have only gone to the Italian American Club on Tuesdays when they serve wonderful pizza and wings. Price is right and our family looks forward to Tuesday night takeout. You must be there before five pm because ordering starts at 5pm sharp and a long line forms immediately. Getting there before five gives you the opportunity to order a drink at the bar and relax a bit. People are friendly and you don't have to be Italian to enjoy. The bar is big and busy and there are plenty of tables and chairs. I know they serve dinners on Friday but we have never tried them because I can make great Italian meals but not great pizza or great wings.“
“This restaurant is on my list for dinner every time I'm on the Vero Beach/Sebastian area. It was packed the evening we were there, hence very loud, but the service and food was excellent as always. I feel the prices have risen more than other Italian restaurants I frequent, but the quality remains so I'll likely continue to dine here.“
“Tried Wise Guys pizza for the 1st time the day before Thanksgiving. All thumbs-up here! Called and ordered 4 pizzas (Pineapple, Pepperoni, Veggie, and White) and a dozen garlic knots. Food was ready for pick-up in a little less than an hour and was hot and fresh. We had about 10 people who ate all the food and it was the best pizza we'd had locally by a long-shot. Pizza was very flavorful and the sauce has great taste. Garlic knots were also very well made with great flavor, and were cooked perfectly (most places burn them or undercook them).My only recommendation (for the business) would be for the person taking the order to mention the special of the day. I didn't realize there were specials until I got to there and saw the specials board inside.Other than that, 5-stars. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.We will definitely be returning to support this great small business!“
“Went there today with my mom and son it was a nice quiet time we ate outside and the server was still very attentive despite us being the only people outside. Quick friendly service and some of the best pizza my family has had in years. We’ve been going here for at least 10 years and it’s always been great. Try their Philly. All their pizza is amazing but the bread they use on that Philly really makes it.Kid-friendliness: Outside seating coloring books and large portions.Wheelchair accessibility: There’s a ramp and wide seating along with tables with removable chairs as well as outside seating.“
“Huge portions, great service and good food hard to beat for the price and the location. Would definitely suggest the cauliflower pizza one of the best I have had. The service is great very personable. The cannoli is unreal and one of the top five I’ve had.Atmosphere is basic but intimate in a remodeled 1980s Pizza Hut kind of way. Easily see this as a regular dine in just for the service and some cannoli.“
“GOODFELLA’S SEBASTIANI have been here 3 times lately and love it. (It used to be Vittorio’s) First time in I had a slice of pizza with sausage and a beer. The slice was excellent - crust crispy but not burnt, sauce delicious, and sausage plentiful and tasty. The beer was cold and the price on both great. Next I brought Monica and we split a beautiful Greek salad and I had the Brooklyn Dip Which was rare top round roast beef with melted Swiss and peppercorn Horseradish sauce done on a roll like panini with au jus - delicious and Monica had the spinach lasagna and garlic knots - all great. Prices great too. Today I rode the bike down and for lunch I got the Philly Cheese Steak Deluxe add banana peppers $9.75 and delicious. Also had a beer each time. Service is great, prices are great. 2 times the music was loud enough to be bothersome but they will turn it down upon request. I love this place and It is better than Vittorio’s was. I will be returning to try more menu items.“
“Worth the wait! We made a reservation 6 weeks ago and tonight was the night! Party of 5 and we all loved our experience! The concept, the food, the service and the entertainment were all excellent! Such a great variety and there is more than enough food to fill you up! It is a marathon IYKYK They could charge double and it would still be a bargain ( but please don't) I just can't say enough. Go hungry and just take it all in. Still wow!“
“I really miss having the dining room open past 4pm. This Fellsmere location has ALWAYS had better food and service than the Sebastian brother's place, but if you're looking to sit down after 3:30 pm, you'll have to go to the Sebastian location.“
“My server, Shay, was so sweet and attentive!! She juggled many tables and still gave my mother and me time to talk and relax with her. Very cheerful and appropriate customer service. And that’s all besides how good our pizza was!! We’ll definitely be coming back to dine in, carry out, and even deliver; the delivery man we saw come in and out was very kind in passing conversation with us :)“
“Went on a Friday about 4 pm. No one else there. The server was wonderful. Wife had fetucini Alfredo. She said it was good. The salads were great with a slightly sweet balsamic vinaigrette. My chicken parm was cooked great and the penne pasta was good. My only complaint was that the pasta was not drained and there was water in the plate that got everywhere. The pasta needs to be strained better. See pic. Real chicken breast, not a formed patty like Vic's.“