40 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fort Myers

“The best pizza in town finally in FORT Myers,, Real good outstanding pizza place to go and enjoy dinner with your love ones“

“10/10 pizza, vibes, beer, and milkshakes! Perfect family friendly outdoor hangout with an indoor expansion coming soon!“

“Amazing pizza and garlic knots! Delish!“

“1st.. the owner is AWESOME comes out talks to you. Carries on a gokd conversation and genuinely cares that I am happy with food and service. 2nd food is AMAZING. All in all 5 star PLUS.“

“Chicagoan here. Had my first 3 City Pizza tonight. Sou’side Chicago thin cut ‘tavern style’ supreme. Wow! It was soooooo good! You guys rock! I can’t wait to come over for a hot dog- drag it thru the garden, extra sport peppers!“

“Excellent garlic knots, salad and pizza!!! Thank you!“

“I can't say enough great things about Mellow Mushroom! This is the best pizza in town! Whenever I go I always start with the pretzel bites! So yummy and addicting. Then depending on what I am in the mood for I get a salad or a pizza. The salads are all delicious but my favorite is the Greek or bacon Blue Wedge. If I do pizza I get either the Buffalo Chicken or Pacific Rim. I love the thick crust and basically all of them. Then if there is room, for dessert, the chocolate brownie or cookie with ice cream! 😋 oh and they have vegan and gluten free items! Can't go wrong here! Thanks to Maureen Cruz for the recommendations!“

“Excellent NY style pizza. Been a few years since my last visit because of distance, but it was still great Pizza just like my last visit. This is a must if your in downtown Ft Myers even our President Trump came here to eat a while back! This is the same street that the 1985 Filming of Day of the Dead that was filmed. The opening scene was filmed right here in downtown Ft Myers. So this street has some filming history to it. I must say again the pizza here is fantastic and sooooo delicious. I even bought a cannoli to bring home. Go try it you might LOVE it! My next visit I will have to try the meatball parmigiana!“

“Great food and great service from Ali!“

“Went here with my kids and our friend while in the area. Staff was friends they looked like a bunch of high school or young college kids. When we asked for recommendations they all gave there fav items. They where patient with us as first timers. Food was excellent. Pizza amazing one of my kids won't eat the outter edge of pizza because there is no sauce and cheese so the kid making it made sure to go to the far edges he ate it all. Highly recommend. Just wish there was one closer it was over an hour drive for us .“

“Best pizza, best pasta and best wings! A perfect restaurant!“

“Badabing Pizza Co is truly a hidden gem! The restaurant has such a cozy, welcoming vibe the moment you walk in. The owners are not only incredibly kind and down-to-earth, but you can tell they pour their heart into everything they do. And the food? BEYOND delicious!!! You can literally taste the freshness in every bite. Everything is homemade, made from scratch with their own special recipes—and it shows!!! The portions are generous, and the prices are more than fair for the quality and care that goes into each dish. If you haven’t been yet, do yourself a favor and go. You won’t be disappointed!!!!“

“I LOVE this restaurant! Best pizza in town!“

“First time here, visited after a doctors appointment with my mom and dad, very cute clean place.
We ordered the Sicilian pie with sausage and meatballs. Came out nice and hot 🔥 as we all took a piece and bits into it we we're all amazed, crispy deliciousness in every bite !! Very flavorful and hit the spot 🤌

Little Sicily thanks for making pizza 🍕 like back home!! Will definitely be back it's worth the hour drive 🚗
🍕🇮🇹“

“Just a couple tables available to sit at , but the pizza was delicious deep dish pepperoni and bacon. We enjoyed our dinner.“

“Don't be fooled because it's in a large mall. The dough is hand made each day, scratch. The marinara is genuinely Italian, light, slightly sweet tones and not over powered by any sort of "Italian" seasoning. Cheeses are fresh and fantastic. It has that NY pie joint feeling in SWFL. A hidden gem. Personal one bite challenge 8.1. Great pie!“

“Good food very sweet waitress“

“Last night our Saturday morning running crew swapped running shoes for pizza and beer at Blue Moon Pizza, and it was such a great choice. We settled in to watch the U.S. Open and were pleasantly surprised at how good everything was. The crust was light and airy, the toppings fresh, and the flavors spot on. I went with the Margherita pizza—creamy, flavorful cheese paired with perfectly roasted cherry tomatoes and fresh basil. Absolutely delicious! Everyone at the table agreed the pizza was a winner. Blue Moon is under new ownership- (Gretchen Wilson), and from our experience, they’re off to a fantastic start. Great food, fun atmosphere, and a place we’ll definitely be returning to. Cheers to them! 🍕“

“My family and I really loved this placed! Never been here before but we were looking for a pet friendly place. I got a new puppy who is yappy but very sweet that I want to expose to more places. I was nervous but the staff were so welcoming and understanding. Food was amazing and reasonably priced! Couldn’t ask for more, thank you! 10/10 will return & recommend!“

“Best burger I ever ate & it was at a pizzerrea! Loaded French fries were great also. The pizza is really good also. But they need to watch the garlic knots when they are cooking so they don't burn. Al in all, I'd recommend friends Pizza to al.“

“Best Italian Beef sandwich in SW Florida. And I have have had them all.“

“Best pizza in Southwest Florida!!! Every time I visit this Mellow Mushroom location in Estero, Fl the food is fantastic and the service is amazing! I highly recommend ordering their RB Margarita which is made with top shelf Casamigos Tequila, Pretzel Bites with beer cheese as an appetizer, and the Holy Shiitake Pizza as an entree! The restaurant is very clean and spotless. I highly recommend visiting the location as you will not be disappointed! It is conveniently located between Miromar Outlets/Hertz Arena and Gulf Coast Town Center. Definitely my favorite Mellow location and restaurant in SWFL!🍕“

“I love the pizza at Poppy’s ! You have to get there and try this pizza!“

“I have never seen a more personable and friendly staff! Ambience was INCREDIBLE! Food was amazing! This is more than a restaurant; it is an experience!“

“Delicious food, great value for money and fabulous servers. I will continue going back to them.“

“Thank you for the birthday pizza! You guys rock and made an 8 year olds birthday!“

“Just a great local Italian restaurant with great reasonably priced food plus a nice happy hour menu from 2:30-6:00. Clean location and very pleasant staff. Most portions are large enough to do a take a home box for lunch the following morning.“

“Server Victoria is one of the best!“

“We were very well taken care of by Liv, who is absolutely delightful — always smiling, attentive, and incredibly helpful. She truly made our evening so much better.

The restaurant offers a great variety of Italian dishes, all very well prepared. The garlic bread with cheese served at the beginning is fantastic and worth the visit on its own.

Excellent experience! Highly recommended.“

“Fantastic dining experience!“

“My first visit, friendly service and clean, ham and pineapple pizza delicious.“

“This is my go to place every Friday for pizza and has been for a while now. This is the ONLY pizza chain that actually gives you the extra cheese that you pay for. Everywhere else has a pitiful amount of cheese even when you specifically request EXTRA (been told by people who used to work these places that they’re told not to actually give the extra cheese).

I’ve read a few reviews on here that the lady here is rude and that’s not true. She’s always been nice to me and I’ve joked with her. Don’t forget that in today’s society everybody is a victim and their narcissism points everyone else out to be an evil villain.

My only complaint is lack of locations. I drive out of my way to get to this store. I wish there was one in Cape Coral.“

“Got a large pepperoni pizza & a salad for friends who were housebound due to both people suffering from surgeries. The app was very intuitive & easy to navigate, keeping me updated on the progress of my takeout. The store was clean and the staff polite & efficient. The pizza was loaded with pepperoni!“

“Awesome as always !! Great food great people“

“Best pizza in this area hands down!“

“Have been looking for good New York style pizza and today I found it! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. My new go to for delicious pizza 😋“

“Always friendly and goes above and beyond for customers! Workers know my name and recognize me as soon as I walk up to order. My food is always to me in the time they tell me it would be done (normally about 10-15 minutes) and I know when I get home with my food it’s hot and delicious every time! Definitely my go to spot for quick dinner!!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 stars

I had an absolutely fantastic experience at Jimmie The Beef Guy! The Italian beef sandwich was just incredible. I've never been to Chicago myself, but my partner Ty has, and he said it tasted just like the real deal from back home. Plus, the owner was super welcoming and made the whole visit even better. Definitely a five-star spot!“

“Service was exceptional. Anthony is a ray of sunshine in the service industry, I would hir him. Very courteous and genuinely friendly.
Regarding billing, I think tipping requests have gone too far, especially when I'm the one driving there to pick up and yet there's still a spot on my bill with suggested amounts. That said, he stood out to me so I did tip him. The lPizza was delicious as expected at a pizza hut and ready fast. It's unfortunate this location has such a low rating. It's my 2nd time here and it's been perfect both times
Free parking right in front of the store.“