42 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fort Myers

“Wings were excellent! Love the wood fired taste and crisp! 🔥🔥🔥“

“The best pizza in town finally in FORT Myers,, Real good outstanding pizza place to go and enjoy dinner with your love ones“

“Owner is very friendly and helpful along with staff. They're great walking you through the extensive menu. Must Try“

“Great pizza, the Detroit Style was cooked perfectly.“

“Excellent garlic knots, salad and pizza!!! Thank you!“

“I have tried many Ft. Myers Pizza Shops and have not found one that makes a pizza close to New York Style Pizza. Today I was in the McGeegor Pizza & Deli area and thought I would try it. Surprisingly the pizza was amazing, the crust was well done, the sauce was tasty and the mozzarella was enough to make the pizza tasty and delicious. Will definitely be back and would recommend this pizza place for sure. Thank you for the unexpected pleasure to a tasty pizza pie. ⭐⭐“

“My husband and i have ordered food from here to go a few times now. The food is always great.. The portions for price are good but i will admit we always go back to the plain cheese pizza here. Something about theirs is just amazing ❤️ the custom service is always great, everyone is friendly yet professional and they make you feel like a friend and not just a dollar. we are definitely lifer’s now . Too bad we don’t live closer or we would be here more.“

“I have heard so much about DHOP that I finally went. I would rank it within my top 5 pizzas I have had in SWFL. Sauce was perfect and the cheese was high quality, the dough was average for me. We will definitely stop in again when we are in downtown “

“I can't say enough great things about Mellow Mushroom! This is the best pizza in town! Whenever I go I always start with the pretzel bites! So yummy and addicting. Then depending on what I am in the mood for I get a salad or a pizza. The salads are all delicious but my favorite is the Greek or bacon Blue Wedge. If I do pizza I get either the Buffalo Chicken or Pacific Rim. I love the thick crust and basically all of them. Then if there is room, for dessert, the chocolate brownie or cookie with ice cream! 😋 oh and they have vegan and gluten free items! Can't go wrong here! Thanks to Maureen Cruz for the recommendations!“

“Great food and great service from Ali!“

“I LOVE this restaurant! Best pizza in town!“

“I was here visiting family and had never heard of Blaze Pizza. I saw on Google that Blaze has a decent rating and the restaurant was close to where we were hanging out, so I decided to place a pickup order online. I ordered a large pepperoni and sausage, a large pepperoni and double cheese, a small gluten free mushroom, and cheese bread.

The restaurant seemed clean. My order was as ready when it was supposed to be. The staff was welcoming. When I got back to my family all of the food was still hot. The flavors were good (I tried all four items that I bought).

Upon looking at my receipt I noticed that I’d been charge a 15% tip which I didn’t know about and certainly didn’t authorize. I tip very well for good service when I dine in, and I am generous with delivery drivers, but I generally don’t tip if I’m picking up my order. I was shocked that a 15% tip would be added to an online order without the consent of the customer. At no point in the online ordering process was the addition of a tip noted.

I called the store for more than 20 minutes but no one answered. I made a complaint online.

The next day I received both an email and a phone call from a manager. They seemed to sincerely want to know what had gone wrong on their end. They were apologetic and compensated for their mistake.

Blaze Pizza certainly needs to address a couple of issues. First, no more automatically charging online customers a 15% tip that they did not initiate. Second, answer your phone.

BUT, I was impressed with their follow up. They won me back with their customer service. I’ll give them another try.“

“Best pizza, best pasta and best wings! A perfect restaurant!“

“Badabing Pizza Co is truly a hidden gem! The restaurant has such a cozy, welcoming vibe the moment you walk in. The owners are not only incredibly kind and down-to-earth, but you can tell they pour their heart into everything they do. And the food? BEYOND delicious!!! You can literally taste the freshness in every bite. Everything is homemade, made from scratch with their own special recipes—and it shows!!! The portions are generous, and the prices are more than fair for the quality and care that goes into each dish. If you haven’t been yet, do yourself a favor and go. You won’t be disappointed!!!!“

“Just a couple tables available to sit at , but the pizza was delicious deep dish pepperoni and bacon. We enjoyed our dinner.“

“Friend's Pizza on Colonial Blvd is a gem in Fort Myers! Their pizzas are delicious with fresh ingredients, and the garlic knots are a must-try. The staff is friendly and provides excellent service. The atmosphere is welcoming, making it a great spot for family dining. Highly recommend their delivery service too—always prompt and the food arrives hot. Definitely one of the best pizza places in town!“

“Don't be fooled because it's in a large mall. The dough is hand made each day, scratch. The marinara is genuinely Italian, light, slightly sweet tones and not over powered by any sort of "Italian" seasoning. Cheeses are fresh and fantastic. It has that NY pie joint feeling in SWFL. A hidden gem. Personal one bite challenge 8.1. Great pie!“

“terrible owner who thinks they can call their customers liars when they get sick off of their food. CROSS CONTAMITION IS HAPPENING! my wife took 1 bite of their pizza and threw up 3x and 2 shits AND her stomach started to hurt within 5 mins! left a review on their Google and the owner wants to call us liars. You don't just get sick like that if there is no cross contaminated food. Gloves are not being changed enough, hands are not being washed enough, utensils are not being cleaned enough or well for that matter and who knows what else. already reported this business for food safety concerns. my wife is a cook, serve safe certified and takes cooking VERY SERIOUS and she instantly knew it was cross contaminated, but again the owner thinks people lie about something like this for no reason. 2+ years of this being a favorite pizza spot to now being the absolute worst we have ever dealt with. also, we have ordered the EXACT SAME PIZZA FOR 2+ YEARS... Cecilian pizza with ONLY BACON & PEPERONI... never once has it ever had CHUNCKY CANNED TOMATOS, CHUCKS OF GARLIC, COOKED SHREDDED LETTUCE HIDDEN UNDER THE CHEESE but owner wants to call us liars about it and says it's always been that way... we know what we eat, clearly this struck a nerve with the owner as it should.... YOU GOT SOMEONE SICK! DO NOT RECOMMEND AT ALL!“

“Found this spot randomly while checking google maps for nearby restaurants. It had a high rating so I decided to check it out. I got the smash burger and a side of broccoli with a sweet tea. The young lady who took care of me was pleasant and my food came out quickly. From other reviews, the wings, chicken tenders, and pizza are winners! They have a few tvs for watching games and
it looks like they serve beer and wine only. This plaza has a cigar bar and another restaurant that I've dined in. It wasn't busy when I went so this is a seems like a good spot to get a meal. I wouldn't mind coming back!“

“Delicious food, great value for money and fabulous servers. I will continue going back to them.“

“Everything was excellent, Chicago style pizza was delicious!“

“Good food very sweet waitress“

“Best pizza in Southwest Florida!!! Every time I visit this Mellow Mushroom location in Estero, Fl the food is fantastic and the service is amazing! I highly recommend ordering their RB Margarita which is made with top shelf Casamigos Tequila, Pretzel Bites with beer cheese as an appetizer, and the Holy Shiitake Pizza as an entree! The restaurant is very clean and spotless. I highly recommend visiting the location as you will not be disappointed! It is conveniently located between Miromar Outlets/Hertz Arena and Gulf Coast Town Center. Definitely my favorite Mellow location and restaurant in SWFL!🍕“

“Fantastic dining experience!“

“Awesome as always !! Great food great people“

“This is our go to place in Fort Myers!! Being from NJ I can say this is the best Italian restaurant around!! We Never miss a chance to go!!!“

“Thank you for the birthday pizza! You guys rock and made an 8 year olds birthday!“

“The meatballs are the star of the house—super tasty and definitely recommended! 🧆 I ordered Luigi’s Favorite Pasta, and it was incredible—cheesy, rich, and perfect for sharing because the portion is big. 🧀🍽️

The pizza was also delicious—crispy and flavorful. The lasagna was warm, hearty, and satisfying.

Kayla was our server and did a great job—very attentive and kind. 👏

The ambiance is super casual and spacious, great for a relaxed meal with friends or family. Definitely a place to come back to when you’re craving classic comfort food!“

“Best pizza in this area hands down!“

“Please note that all of these reviews are from a prior owner. When it was Bella's NY Pizza. Must try the new place, it is delicious“

“I love the pizza at Poppy’s ! You have to get there and try this pizza!“

“My first visit, friendly service and clean, ham and pineapple pizza delicious.“

“Such a wonderful experience. Food was excellent. Dan and Sarah are wonderful hosts.“

“I drive 20 minutes each way to order from this place. The one close to me is a dumpster on fire. Too bad Little Ceasars doesn’t enforce any standards at all in their franchised stores. LC should pay a visit to this specific store and learn from them. Even the pizza tastes e feels better coming from this store. It’s the best LC store I’ve bought a LC pizza from.“

“My girlfriend and I are frequent eaters at Romeo’s, we love the food there. We tried switching to their BBQ sauce for a BBQ chicken pizza, and I’m not sure if it was the sauce or the cheese, but it smelled horrible and tasted rotten.

Besides that and some frequent order Mess ups, the food is actually pretty good“

“Have been looking for good New York style pizza and today I found it! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. My new go to for delicious pizza 😋“

“This is my go to place every Friday for pizza and has been for a while now. This is the ONLY pizza chain that actually gives you the extra cheese that you pay for. Everywhere else has a pitiful amount of cheese even when you specifically request EXTRA (been told by people who used to work these places that they’re told not to actually give the extra cheese).

I’ve read a few reviews on here that the lady here is rude and that’s not true. She’s always been nice to me and I’ve joked with her. Don’t forget that in today’s society everybody is a victim and their narcissism points everyone else out to be an evil villain.

My only complaint is lack of locations. I drive out of my way to get to this store. I wish there was one in Cape Coral.“

“Jerry is such a wonderful person!!! he reached out to me about food I had ordered and they were closed and refunded me. I was just trying to order food for my dad for the holiday and Jerry even offered to deliver pizza from somewhere else for him!! This place is great!!“

“We love papa John’s pizza. I haven’t had any in a while and we decided to get some the other night. It was great. I forgot how much I loved it. Plus the pepperoncini you get on the side! The service was quick and it was priced right. We’ll be going back there again.“

“Honestly this place is amazing I loved working here and having fun with my family members and I can’t wait to come back to work“

“We eat at pizza 2000 at least every other week. We just love it especially their gorgonzola salad“