50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Gibsonton

“Johnathon, is extremely sweet, patient and caring. Everytime I come in he is always the first person to greet me. Today I had trouble with ordering online , he took the time to help me figure my order out, establish the perfect pick up time and once we got there he made sure to take care of my needs. I always come in with at least one of my girls and he always makes it a point to speak to them and make sure they are also happy with our food. Really such a family friendly experience. Thank you!“

“The Best Cuban Pizza in Tampa!“

“A Slice of Home at Willie's Bloomingdale Pizza As a lifelong lover of pizza and Italian food—raised in the suburbs of Philadelphia where great pizza is almost a birthright—I was genuinely surprised by how hard it was to find truly good pizza after moving to Florida. For a while, I had resigned myself to the usual national chains, which, while convenient, just don’t offer that authentic flavor or neighborhood warmth I grew up with. That all changed when I discovered Willie’s Bloomingdale Pizza on Oakfield. From the moment I walked in, I was met with a welcoming atmosphere. The service is both friendly and professional—they treat you like family without ever compromising on quality. You can immediately tell that this is a place run with heart. The owner is a standout—professional, down-to-earth, and clearly passionate about both the food and the people who walk through the door. It's rare to see that kind of genuine care, and it absolutely shows in every bite and every interaction. The pizza? Outstanding. Flavorful, fresh, and made with an attention to detail that rivals what I grew up with back in Philly. For someone who’s picky about their pizza & Italian food, that’s saying a lot. Good pizza is hard to come by in this part of the Sunshine State, so when you find a place like Willie’s, it’s truly cause for celebration. And what better way to celebrate than with a slice in hand? Willie’s Bloomingdale Pizza is hands-down the #1 spot for pizza & Italian food also cheesesteaks in the area. If you’re nearby and craving something real—something that feels like home—I can’t recommend this place enough.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5 Mi Pizza Piu Florida is an absolute gem! The food is always fresh, flavorful, and made with real care. I’m a total sucker for a good calzone, and let me tell you—this place makes the BEST calzone hands down, in my opinion. Perfectly baked, loaded with delicious fillings, and packed with that authentic flavor you can’t fake. The rest of the menu is just as impressive, and the owner is always friendly and welcoming. If you haven’t tried Mi Pizza Piu yet, you’re seriously missing out. Highly recommend!“

“Went there yesterday with my husband and daughters. That was by far the best pizza I've had!!!! The owner was soo nice & we promised we'd leave a review about the pizza & not the bathroom that's getting remodeled!!! Lol“

“Great experience! Wow, pizza and breadsticks were amazing! Ashley was wonderful too at the Kissimmee location. Highly recommend this pizza company!!!“

“I accidentally placed my order at a different Hungry Howie’s location, and the manager, Ray, was incredibly kind and helpful. He immediately contacted the other store, made sure I was reimbursed, and then prepared my pizza fresh and quickly. His customer service was outstanding, and he truly went out of his way to help me. The pizza tasted great, and the entire experience turned what could’ve been frustrating into a really positive one. Huge thanks to Ray for the excellent service!“

“By far best pizza we have ever had! Also great service and cool environment.“

“Outstanding pies (pizza), salads, bread, garlic knots, and Bake Ziti. True Italian style!! Service was second to none. I would say, "The Best in Tampa Bay."“

“Delicious as usual however, we ordered one stuffed pizza split with different toppings on either side of the pie. I instructed them to put one of the toppings particular to that side so we could identify which side was which. they told us they couldn't do that but they would make each side identifiable. They didn't. We had no way of knowing which side was which. If I tell you how I want my pizza, please make it that way. This doesn't mean we will not order again because it is great pizza.“

“Was in the area i live in Sarasota but i always went to different cuban pizza places this place happened to be close to me and the reviews were beautiful so i came to El Recreo , i was pleased when I pulled up to be surrounded by beautiful green trees in this concrete jungle. My husband and i ordered, one chorizo pizza, a pepperoni pizza, a spaghetti a mango smoothie. I am always unimpressed by Cuban food in this area but…. Everything was perfect wow I will definitely be back“

“The food was BIG SERVINGS and staff was great. The staff stayed on top of the table checking back on a really regular basis. Price to food was great. We ate very well and took enough home to make a second meal. The food reheated very well!“

“The food and beers are always excellent, the only thing better is the staff! Our server, Naomi, is attentive, thorough and a pleasure to chat with. Highly recommend Gasparilla Pizza!“

“This was hands down one of the best experiences I’ve had in a LONG time walking into a food establishment. The positive energy of the staff, the cleanliness of the store, the customer service in general. Whatever Nate and his team are doing, it’s working! And to be completely honest, I was only doordashing last night and while I wasn’t a Papa John’s supporter before, I am now. Nowadays, you walk into food establishments and you. An just feel the heavy and dark energy, but this place was different. And it was genuine. Thanks again to Nate and his team!“

“Great food and great atmosphere! Wonderful service“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½
I recently visited NYNYPizzeria in Ybor City and it was a delightful experience from start to finish. The service was warm, attentive, and genuinely friendly—our server made us feel welcome and made great suggestions. The food itself was outstanding: perfectly crisp crust, rich and flavorful toppings, and cooked just right. The atmosphere was lively yet comfortable, with the right balance of casual fun and inviting energy. Whether you’re looking for a relaxed dinner or a fun night out, this place is a winner. Highly recommend it—I’ll definitely be returning.“

“They are open until 2 AM which is great! The crust is not pre-made or prefrontal, he spins it right in front of you. We had the Orr, pepperoni with pesto and honey Sriracha drizzle. The pesto was not overwhelming and the drizzle was the perfect amount of spicy and sweet. The Italian working there never stopped and worked quickly to fill orders. I noticed they had a Cauliflower crust option! Prices are great! Make sure you give them a try!“

“Great place to eat, the best vegan food in Florida. Absolutely best pizza I’ve ever eaten. The owner was so helpful to my wife Rose, explaining everything and taking care of us. We are from middle Tennessee but we will be back. All looking for a better place to eat healthy and great tasting food don’t miss this place.“

“quick service. friendly staff. authentic. delicious!“

“Thank you so much Eddie & Sam’s for correcting (re sending it out for us) our order being delivered to the children’s hospital when it wasn’t your fault the delivery driver did not drop it off. Once it was delivered the second time it did not disappoint it was honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had! I will be craving this pizza for days unfortunately I like to fair but will always get this anytime I’m in town! Thank you! ❤️“

“Best place for just pizza wings and beer!“

“Great flavors! Amazing pizza“

“Best pizza ever!! Especially the deep dish! We normally pick it up but really enjoyed the atmosphere and service eating in as well. 5 stars!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Yummy our family have been going here for years! We enjoyed our get together! Great pizza!“

“Great pizza with fun waitstaff.“

“Almost 2 years in business and their pizza is my personal favorite! Very high quality and delicious! Awesome job“

“the food was amazing along with the selection of choices. the price is on point.“

“Stopped there today for pizza. It was amazing. So happy we decided to stop. Bar service was incredible as well.“

“good pizza 🍕 good prices 😋good service 👍“

“I recently visited Pizza Kitchen, and I have to say, it was a pretty pleasant experience. We tried a few different pizzas, and honestly, they were all really good. The crust was just the right thickness, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. I particularly enjoyed their margherita pizza; it had a great balance of fresh ingredients and flavors.

The staff were friendly and attentive without being overbearing, which I appreciated. Prices were reasonable for the quality of food we received. Overall, Pizza Kitchen is a solid choice if you're in the mood for a casual meal. I can see myself going back for another slice!“

“Best pizza I've had in awhile. Pinellas has 1 that is authentic; this place was fantastic. Staff were so nice. If going to concert eat here first!!“

“Good but faster would be great“

“Delicious authentic NY pizza! We’ve come multiple times and their food is always consistently delicious regardless of time of day. Fast service and friendly employees“

“Great pizza! Fast service.“

“Absolutely delicious, but overpriced. The lady working there is semi-nice and the seating is inviting. It's closed random times when it's says it's open so you don't actually know when it's going to be available - seems to be random. All the pizza and sides I've gotten are extremely tasty and I'd get them again. But know you'll be spending $20+ for a 10-12 inch pizza“

“I love Anthony’s food especially the chopped salad and the Desserts 🧁“

“Great pizza restaurant with great food, The service is amazing and Bailey at the front desk had great customer service and quick. The atmosphere is like any old school pizza restaurant with wood table and checkers floor which gives that old school pizza restaurant vibe. I definitely will be going back when I get the urge to have pizza.“

“Mellow mushroom in Riverview was definitely a 10/10 highly recommended my kids never gonna want reg pizza again 😂😩🤦🏾‍♀️“

“We have been going there for years and is always great food, great people, and always a family favorite.“

“A wonderful experience enhanced by Zoey who was an outstanding frontline ambassador for expected service and care. I ventured away from my usual Thai Bowl and tried the Big Italy with crispy chicken and spaghetti squash. Dang…was it good! Portions were sufficient, well-prepared and proudly served. This selection might just become my favorite at Cali’s. Granted, the staff consists of young adults who are, in the least, committed to going to work to earn their pay. Their attitude is encouraging. Some of the comments posted may not be fair. One has to allow opportunity for on-the-spot redress of an actual or perceived wrong (the menu is self-explanatory or can be clarified by simply asking). No matter - this was not our first time at Cali’s and definitely not the last. We look forward to our next visit and selections. Thank you … Zoey (and staff) for another great “Cali experience!”“

“Called about specials, I was greater with a smile and passion! They asked about the amount of people I was feeding and recommend different menu options. I was very pleased can't wait to devour this New York style pizza“

“Wow! We had two food trucks (2 Rowdy Roosters and The Chief's Cantina) at our school's Prom. The kids absolutely loved it. They provided great options, the delicious food, and everyone we interacted with was kind and helpful. Kim was a pleasure to work with to coordinate the truck and menu options. We will definitely book them for a future event!“

“The pizza was delicious we had garlic wings so good the waiter was so polite and pleasant. I would come again that was the best pizza I've eaten in a long time everything was hot I'm here on vacation from the eastern shore but my Daughter lives here in Tampa thanks for youŕ hospitality Gloria from Maryland on the Eastern shore“

“Had never heard of this restaurant before moving here. Ordered online and the food was prepared withing 12min, and cheaper than ordering from some surrounding restaurants... So i didn't expect much, but I was BLOWN AWAY! I ordered the breadsticks and bbq wings. Both were cooked to perfection and they were liberal with the sauce! Me and my little ones INHALED this food! We ate it so fast we didn't get a chance to upload photos!! Marco's is now our new favorite restaurant!!!“

“Best pizza in town!!! Always fresh!“

“Stopped in for late lunch and Mike made me the best pepperoni pizza! The waitress was great and will make this location on South Dale Mabry a weekly stop. And forgot to mention the many lunch specials. I’m going to try them all. 🍽️“

“Great casual Italian spot, highly recommend the Bang Bang chicken sandwich. The chicken parmesan pizza has also been great when I have tried it. My partner’s favorite thing to get is always the Strawberry Walnut salad, she loves that dish as well.

Overall, good for a quick sit down lunch or casual dinner at an Italian place that isn’t too fancy.“

“There fast when getting your order“

“I have been in tampa for 12 years, moved from N.Y,,,. Pizza has been one of my biggest struggles... Cappys by far is the closest to N.Y pizza I've had yet.. Great food, Great service,and great price!!“