Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream

$ • Ice Cream, Pet Friendly

Hours today·

About Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream

Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream is a quaint ice cream shop in an easy in/out location on 17/92. It offers traditional favorites and some new flavors, with ice cream that is fresh, delicious, and made with fresh, original ingredients that do not taste artificial. Specific items like the cheesecake, chips ahoy Sundae, banana pudding milk shake, Carrot Cake, and waffle chip are mentioned, alongside pineapple water. The staff is friendly, helpful, and nice. The setting includes a patio with an outdoor seating area with chairs, tables, and string lightbulbs, providing a nice date night after dinner ambience. Customers can order up front, then stroll around back for pick-up to take-away or settle on the patio. The pricing is fair and very good. Some feedback notes that while flavors are good, some are too sweet, and there is a request for more sugar free vanilla ice cream. It is a place making passion into ice cream and keeping smiles with America’s favorite.

Menu

Add a Menu
Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu
Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream
Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream
View All Photos

Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream Reviews

4.6
84 ratings
5
81%
4
11%
3
2%
2
2%
1
4%
Food
4.5
Atmosphere
5.0
Service
5.0

Share your opinion about Lucy’s Homemade Ice Cream

We drove from Winter Garden after seeing a TikTok About Lucy's and let me.tell you, it was well worth the drive! We tried several flavors including bubble gum for the kids, horchata (made from homemade horchata) and my favorite maiz (corn). Served in fresh homemade waffle cones, this was some of the best ice cream we've had in a long time. Natalie took time to answer my several questions and was SO friendly! We'll definitely be back!
Delicious banana split! Great service and big portions.
My sister had been raving about this spot because it was recommended by someone at her job. We finally came here on a hot summer day and it was the best ending to our evening. With all of the flavor options and the old school ice cream shop ambiance, I can see why my sisters coworker would not stop talking about it. I absolutely love ice cream so when the employee recommended two flavors that tasted well together, I knew I was at the right spot for a sweet treat. I had the pistachio...read full review

Read All Reviews(84)

Hours

Monday 12 - 10PM
Tuesday 12 - 10PM
Wednesday 12 - 10PM
Thursday 12 - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 10PM
Saturday 11AM - 10PM
Sunday 11AM - 10PM
Updated on: