Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
$ • Bakery, Pet FriendlyAbout Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter & Jealous Pie
Three Sisters Mixed Berry Pie
Chill Don't Cross the Lime Pie
The Blue Dahlia Blueberry Pie
Beach Don't Kill My Vibe Pie
Peanut Butter & Jealous Pie
Wake Me Up Before You Cocoa
Blurred Limes Key Lime Pie
The Moon Pie French Silk
Peanut Butter Mousse Pie
Mixed Fillings Pie Shop Reviews
259 ratings
Share your opinion about Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
Tried a slice at RAM yesterday with my kids. So so so good. Will definitely be trying different flavors in the future and buying full size to show off to my fam at events 🤪
If you love pie, do yourself the favor of making the trip downtown to Mixed Fillings. They never disappoint, and everyone is super friendly. ❤️🥧 ❤️
Best pie I’ve ever had!!! Not only tasty but beautifully crafted.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 10AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
The Mixed Fillings Pie Shop offers a delightful dining experience with a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. Their pies, including flavors like peanut butter & jealous, key lime, orange creamsicle, and chess pie, are consistently praised for their exceptional quality and taste. Customers appreciate the attention to detail in the tailored crusts, with the thick chewy oreo crust of the peanut butter & jealous pie being described as magically delicious. The shop also provides a gluten-free crust that retains the taste and texture, earning praise from the gluten-free community. Many customers enjoy the variety pie when they can't decide which pie to choose, ensuring they won't be disappointed. The Blurred Limes pie is highlighted as a masterpiece, with its pretzel crust offering a perfect balance to the creamy, tart filling. Visitors enjoy the walk-up format, making it easy to quickly get some pie to go. The combination of sweet, salty, and tangy flavors makes the Key Lime pie a standout dessert that shouldn't be missed, and customers have noted the excellent customer service, even with lots of questions.