Upper Crust Pizza

$ • Pizza, Italian, Vegan

Menu Order Online

About Upper Crust Pizza

Upper Crust Pizza is a cozy restaurant in Key Largo, offering delicious pizzas with a homemade touch. The pizzas feature a pure tomato sauce and freshly made dough, creating a satisfying taste. The restaurant also serves mozzarella sticks and has a wide selection of draft beers, including rare options like Pilsner Urquell and Chimay. Customers praise the excellent service, with friendly owners making every visit special. The atmosphere is described as cozy, with a small indoor seating area perfect for relaxing. Reviewers highlight the fair pricing of the pizzas, considering the generous size and toppings. The staff's pride and attention to detail are evident, and the kitchen consistently turns out delicious food. The beer selection is curated with a story and profile for each choice, and the owners enjoy sharing their knowledge and discoveries. Overall, Upper Crust Pizza is a hidden gem in Key Largo, offering high-quality pizzas, a welcoming atmosphere, and attentive service that keeps customers coming back. Whether locals or tourists, visitors find it to be the only place for GREAT pizza, with many considering it the best outside of New Jersey, comparable to top pizza in the country.