“My friends are locals and recommended this place. They know my husband who is a chef and myself are foodies and love places that know how to pair flavors. This place definitely hits all the points. Friendly greeting when you walk in, place is clean and very nicely decorated, every employee seemed in a great mood, music playlist was perfect and all the tables seemed to be enjoying themselves. Now let’s move on to the important part, the food!! We got the special with honey, pistachio and whipped feta with bread, the flavors and freshness were top notch, we also ordered the bread service which came with a really good spice and oil blend as well as garlic con fie (sorry I don’t know how to spell it) ?, yummy and gave us extra bread for the feta. We got the double prosciutto pie with truffle!! Amazing!! As well as the house chips with blue cheese melted on it. We wanted to order desert because our friends said they were amazing there which I would imagine them to be with the way everything else tasted but we were all so full we couldn’t even think about it. Definitely a hidden gem amongst all the tourist trap restaurants which are plenty in the keys. Highly recommend and we will definitely be back!“
“Let’s keep this simple- we ordered the cheese pizza to try it for the first time. It was a perfectly balanced pizza. The cheese was very good quality. So if you like genuine New York or New Jersey stylepizza you’ll dig this place. Wait staff was pleasant and on point.“
“Stopped in while on vacation, food is excellent! Had lasagna, which came with a salad and bread. The house Italian dressing ranks at the top that I've ever had. I know, it's not that hard to make it, but this was perfect! Lasagna had a good amount of meat, cheese, and some spinach. Only complaint was it was a little light on sauce, so if you like sauce I recommend asking for extra.“
“Food was AMAZING!!!!!!! We were seated immediately, our waitress was great! The bread- the salad- the meal were all so good we did not have room for dessert!! We all brought home left overs and we all ate them again the next day because everything was so delicious!! Would absolutely eat there again!! You will not be disappointed here!!!“
“The pizza here is so flavorful, great crust, roasted garlic...yum. great pizza menu options also. The server was attentive, knowledgeable and helpful.The inside of this place is nothing fancy. Reminds me of the 90s. Not that there's anything wrong with that. ?You should eat here.“
“We realized, on our way through Key Largo, after a long day of paddle boarding, that we were craving Italian food. We decided to stop at Italian Food Company as it had a bit better ratings than another one nearby. We are so glad we did. The Arancini appetizer and it was delicious. Very gooey cheese and perfect fry on the outside. I ordered the Gnocchi ala Sorrentino which included pillowy gnocchi in a Pomodoro sauce with lots of melty mozzarella. My wife got the killer dish of the evening with the Fiocchi de Pera, which was a pasta wrapped (like a money bag) around pear and a soft cheese, topped with a light cream sauce and honey and almonds. It was unusual but a wonderful sweet and savory bite. Their dessert case is insane and we went home with three desserts. Leann was our amazing server. She walked us through the menu and the dessert case and was great in recommending wine pairings. We've never had such an adept waitress. She is perfect at that job. Oh, and the wood fired pizzas looked incredible.We just got off the Chefs Making Waves cruise on Friday that featured some of the best celebrity chefs that can be found on the Food Network and the food at Italian Food Kitchen would have outshone all of the food we had on that cruise. Thank you!“