16 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tavernier

“For anyone living or visiting the upper Florida Keys... It was probably the best pizza we have ever had!“

“Delicious food the desserts are amazing � � Maritzio is talented and entertaining so fun to have the whole place singing That's Amore � kids loved it!“

“Had my first experience at Lido 73 today. First off, the outside dining area is right on the canal where you can watch the fish and other wildlife while you eat which sure beats a TV in the corner. The second thing you'll notice is an expansive menu which truly has something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for a lite bite or a main dish (like myself) I can't imagine anyone being disappointed. The wine/beer list is equally as expansive and welcoming of all tastes.

Now down to business. I ordered the fillet medallions on and empty stomach and was blown away by the flavor and quality of the meat - cooked medium rare as I had requested. There is only one other restaurant that can match this quality and they are far more expensive without the accompanying sides. I was able to substitute mashed potatoes and asparagus which elevated the meal passed medley and fingerling potatos that come standard.

Give this place a shot, relax out back and leave full, happy and ready for your next adventure“

“Lovely Ladies behind the Counter, Awesome Eats, and Relaxing Atmosphere“

“Delicious. 99.999X perfect! Literally. True. **“

“Best pizza I ever had. I’m 73 and I’ve had a lot to try . Best ever!“

“Great atmosphere. Awesome food!!!“

“The pizza was FANTASTIC! The restaurant had a comforting atmosphere and the food was great. Leo makes one of the best pizzas in Key Largo if not the best. Being from Italy it reminded me of the flavors of my hometown and culture. Congratulation to Leo and his pizza, spectacular!“

“Wow is all I can! Wings are on point, covered in lots of sauce just how they should be!!! Cheese and margarita pizza was beyond perfect. Pizza dough is the best I have ever had, not hard to chew at all. Will def be my new place when im here!“

“Out exploring the Florida Keys for Spring Break and loved it all. On the way back my wife and daughter just wanted a good slice of pizza and continue on the road back home. Bumped into this place right off the highway, immediately greeted by Markito who clarified that although he didn't sell by the slice he sold small personal pizzas. Sat at the picnic benches with family and Service dog and in less than 10 minutes we had tasty, fresh and crispy crust pizzas. Owner continued to check in to see if we needed anything and always with a smile. Thin blue line flag out front showed his support for military and law enforcement which was appreciated. Great quick stop with great service and a smile.“

“Visiting from Michigan and was so excited to find this gem. My husband ordered a Pepperoni Pizza while I enjoyed the Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp. Definitely wish I could take this restaurant back home with me, because everything was delish! The entire staff were so very pleasant as well. From one restaurant owner to another, thank you and keep up the excellent work!“

“Excellent…. Think we have a new local contender…“

“Awesome place, great bartenders, fantastic owners, and the coldest Busch Light in the keys! This historic bar is a must stop with phenomenal pizza and full menu. I strongly recommend a visit to the Whistle Stop.“

“Great pizza,nice atmosphere and nice people. Highly recommend“

“Great food! Love the Oscar shrimp for dinner and garlic rolls!“

“Awesome place, great bartenders, fantastic owners, and the coldest Busch Light in the keys! This historic bar is a must stop with phenomenal pizza and full menu. I strongly recommend a visit to the Whistle Stop.“