39 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lake Alfred

“First time going today August 16,2022,Pizza is great,it made my husband think that he was back in New York,the sauce,the dough and cheese is great,we will coming back soon and we are going to tell our Family and friends,customer service is great ,the owner make you feel like Family.“

“I ordered for the first time tonight. Extra large New York style well done with a dozen hot wings, all flat. This is the first time I've had a delivery that showed up so quickly the wings were still too hot to bite into, I had to wait a few minutes. Awesome service!“

“We had an amazing experience the staff is great the food was awesome and we will definitely be back.“

“El pan que sirven de entrada riquisimo,la pizza divina y la waitress Charisse 20 of 20“

“First time trying J Burns Pizza and it was AMAZING!!! We ordered a taco pizza and a pepperoni pizza 🍕. Very tasty and delicious!! Service was top notch!! We will definitely be back!! *Winter Haven location Pictures in the comments“

“Whenever I am in town visiting my sister I always want to eat at least one meal at Country Angels. Their food is delicious. Love their catfish filets.“

“Ordered last night for pick up. Food and service were perfect“

“Fantastic, delicious pizza!“

“Hungry Howies in Polk City CANNOT BE BEAT! I always order from this location due to the nature of the location being close to home but also because of their excellent customer service, delicious food (made correctly might I add), and friendly staff. Tonight when ordering on the app I accidentally ordered at a wrong location and when I got here they offered to make it right then and was very kind about my mistake. The manager was super understanding and offered a free drink. Something so small for my mistake was very appreciated! Thank you Polk city for being great!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“This place has amazing food for a decent, affordable price! And their menu is quite diverse in terms of selection.
I usually don't go out of my way to leave reviews umprompted, but the food here was so honest-to-goodness amazing that I'm compelled to leave one in appreciation. :)
The steak wrap was so delicious and you could tell by the taste that the ingredients were all 100% freshly chopped and cooked. The flavor was so much richer and each ingredient was actually distinguishable from each other.
Also had the mango cheesecake and it was equally as rich in flavor. I normally dislike cheesecake but MAN was that great! It was sweet but not overpowering and the mango is front and center.
I can't wait to try their namesakes of pizza and wings after that great meal. Definitely coming back for more!!“

“Love the wings the sweetness spicy remind me of a place in New York. Sals birdland“

“The best!!! Truly enjoyed the pizza!!“

“Absolutely LOVED this place! Food is amazing, 10/10!!!“

“We went there at dinner rush time, the place was really busy but the service and food was excellent. The person at the counter explained the whole concept of the buffet and if we didn’t like any pizza on the buffet ,we had an option to order special requests that was really good. Great service, awesome staff. Everyone working there was commendable . Alot of games for kids aswell for them to have fun.“

“Miss Carmen was absolutely amazing!!! She went above and beyond the call of duty!! She sets the standard for how ALL customer service agents everywhere should strive to be like!!! She was so warm and friendly, you can feel her kind heart!! ❤️ Thank you Miss Carmen!!“

“Fantastic Pizza and Wonderful staff!!!“

“Love this pizza. A little disappointed because I didn’t check my pizza before leaving. Got all the way home and one was burnt. You had to scrape the toppings off without eating the burnt crust. LESSON LEARNED. Guess with the new over- some of the temps are off a bit. Still a favorite plate to eat and enjoy!!!! TIP- Check your pizza before it walks out the door! I need a new one! lol“

“Another delicious pizza from Pizzano’s!! My family has been ordering from Pizzano’s for many years. We’ve never been disappointed with an order. The staff is always so sweet & friendly. They are definitely our go to for pizza in Haines City. ❤️“

“This pizza was so good! I’m a Minnesotan born in Queens New York and have had my share of New York pizza. We were on vacation in Florida and just happened to order pizza here and it was so good we ordered it again a day later!“

“For the money this place is great. It’s not for some folks but I really like it. 13 bucks gets the two of us a meal and leftover cold pizza in the morning.“

“Marco's delivered a pizza big enough for my whole family to be filled in under 20 minutes delivery time. The pizza was gone almost instantly. The value there is high due to the delivery time, taste and quality of pizza. I've never only eaten Marco's Pizza at home, so I don't know what the atmosphere is like closer to their kitchen“

“I had an awesome experience at Domino’s thanks to Jeff! He was friendly, professional, and made sure my order was perfect. The food came out hot, fresh, and exactly how I wanted it. You can tell Jeff really cares about great customer service. Definitely one of the best experiences I’ve had at this location. Thanks, Jeff!“

“09/24/2025 Dundee store. The young man was very organized and courteous. Took orders,processed the orders all very effective. Also was dealing with a young lady that would not do what he polity ask her to do. Please tell him I thank him and feel his hard work and attitude will prove helpful in his future.“

“We eat here a lot takes just like It does in New York forget about it !!!!“

“This pizza was so good! I’m a Minnesotan born in Queens New York and have had my share of New York pizza. We were on vacation in Florida and just happened to order pizza here and it was so good we ordered it again a day later!“

“alfredo was amazing! definitely going back soon.“

“I’m so excited that R place is open again, I was so sad when the restaurant closed a few years ago, their pizza was my absolute favorite and it tastes just as good as I remember! Located in the parking lot where the restaurant used to be and super friendly!“

“Celeste is truly AMAZING. She is the heart of this Marco’s Pizza. Every single time I come in for the cheesy bread, she treats me so well and makes me feel genuinely welcome. She has such a warm, inviting presence, and it shows in how smoothly everything runs when she’s there. She knows how to handle her team, she knows how to handle a rush, and she does it all with kindness, patience, and confidence. No matter how busy it is, Celeste is always exceptional sweet, respectful, and a true team player with outstanding leadership skills. Honestly, I love this Marco’s mostly because of her. She is my favorite, hands down. She’s number one to me. That said, the entire staff is very sweet as well, which says a lot about the environment she helps create. The managers should be incredibly proud of the team they have especially Celeste. She’s a gem and deserves all the recognition.“

“Affordable prices and fast delivery! We love Hungry Howie’s!“

“We eat here a lot because it is one of the only things open late in winter haven. They always get it to us super fast, it’s even came in less than 20 minutes before and everything is always perfect, which we have not found to be common among other restaurants in the area. Thank you!“

“Very great place good staff“

“Great food with the best value around! I recommend the stromboli! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“I recommend this place if you like friendly staff and live music on some nights,song quizzes,trivia night,etc. the food is great. I recommend the chicken runners . I usually don’t like to hang out and eat somewhere when I’m working out of town but I really enjoy myself here and unwind. Thanks staff!“

“We eat here a lot because it is one of the only things open late in winter haven. They always get it to us super fast, it’s even came in less than 20 minutes before and everything is always perfect, which we have not found to be common among other restaurants in the area. Thank you!“

“We ordered Thick pizza but they gave Us the wrong pizza and the thing that made it worse is that the pizza wasn't The pizza type we ordered and we have to order again and get our Thick pizza this time we went back and forgot 3 times but the pizza tasted good 👍“

“we're in Florida for vacation. food was AMAZING! and I'm so jealous we don't have one in maine! staff was very friendly!“

“Great park! If you have kids especially young kids this is the place for you. Now some of the stuff could be updated but over all the food was pretty good, rides had play areas for kids waiting for rides, everything was kid friendly. The staff were all good with kids. I was very impressed with the imagination area. They had a robotics exercise for the kids to do and they had an area to try some STEM type stuff. If I had some complaints I would say it stinks there is no discount on sets purchased at site and no free shipping. Highly recommend for anyone with young kids but go before they are teens.“

“I ordered Papa John’s at 6:06pm for my son…. Papa John’s delivered at 6:20pm… Now THAT is service! They are ALWAYS fast and the drivers are ALWAYS polite! I’ve ordered from competitors in our town. One takes 1-1/2 to 2 hours to deliver EVERY time, the other is never consistent or runs out of ingredients. We are ? team Papa John’s!“