Upper Crust Bakery

$$ • Bakery

Menu Order Online

About Upper Crust Bakery

Upper Crust Bakery is a well-known restaurant specializing in a variety of delicious pies, including peach, cherry, apple, banana cream, pecan, and chocolate crème. The bakery's pies are praised for their flavorful crusts, though some customers have found the fillings to be overly sweet. While the freshness of the fruits used in certain pies, such as peach and cherry, could be improved, the bakery's offerings are generally well-liked.

The bakery's customer service has received mixed reviews, with some customers appreciating the organized and smooth pick-up process, while others have found the staff to be less friendly and helpful. However, the bakery's pies, particularly the standout banana cream pie, are known for their natural taste and good ratio of crust to filling.

Customers have long enjoyed the bakery's pies, with one reviewer noting that their mother has been purchasing the pies since the 1980s. The Key Lime pie, in particular, is praised for its balanced and mild flavor, in contrast to the overpowering lime taste found in some other versions. The bakery's pecan, chocolate cream, and blueberry pies are also customer favorites.

Despite the recent passing of the owner, the bakery continues to offer its renowned pies, with customers even traveling from out of state to enjoy the Key Lime pie. Overall, Upper Crust Bakery remains a destination for those seeking high-quality, flavorful pies.