11 Best Italian Restaurants in Marco Island

DaVinci's Italian • $$
599 South Collier Boulevard Suite 215, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Pappardelle Bolognese
Linguine Alle Vongole
Chicken Parmigiana
Ravioli Alla Vodka
Carpaccio Di Manzo
Rigatoni Marinara
Veal Saltimbocca
Gnocchi DaVinci
Calamari Fritti
Burrata Caprese

“Perfection by any measure!!!“

4.6 Superb1334 Reviews
Ciao Bella Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$
1000 North Collier Boulevard Suite 6, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad with Optional Anchovies
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Stuffed Pork Chops
Spumoni Ice Cream
Gnocchi Bolognese
Soup of the Day
Beef Carpaccio
Chicken Marsala
Stuffed Shells
Pasta Fagioli

“Muy buena gastronomía y excelente atencion“

4.6 Superb309 Reviews
Davide Italian Cafe Italian • $$
688 Bald Eagle Drive Suite 2541, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Tagliatelle with Clams Mussels Shrimps in a Light Fresh Tomatoes Sauce
Sautee Mussels or Calamari
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Homemade Special Pizza
Spaghetti Puttanesca
Italian Wedding Soup
Chicken Cordon Blue
Lasagna Bolognese
Zuppetta Di Pesce
Chicken Piccata

“Best Bronzino I the area.“

4.3 Superb274 Reviews
4

Sami's

Sami's Pizza • $$
227 North Collier Boulevard, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Lobster Ravioli
Chicken Piccata
Pepperoni Pizza
Chocolate Cake
Chicken Marsala
Hawaiian Pizza
Caprese Salad
Cheese Pizza

“Delicious food, excellent service!“

4.6 Superb683 Reviews
The Boulevard Italian • $$$
1000 North Collier Boulevard Suite 15, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Key Lime Pie
Scallops
Carpaccio
Lasagne

“Warm service, beautiful food, and a room that instantly puts you at ease. We loved the holiday decor. Every dish was genuinely delicious. We celebrated a birthday and they went out of their way to make the birthday girl feel special. Left happy, full, and already planning to return. A true gem and must when visiting Marco Island!“

4.8 Superb189 Reviews
Osteria Capri - Marco Island Italian • $$$
918 North Collier Boulevard, Marco Island

“Went for the first time yesterday all staffs were extremely kind , The host sat me in a beautiful view and she was very helpful!!“

3.6 Good89 Reviews
The SpeakEasy Marco Island Italian • $$
1106 North Collier Boulevard, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Maine Lobster Roll with Lemon Aioli Diced Tomato and Lettuce Served on a Hoagie Roll
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza
Twin Lobster Tail Special
Loaded Italian Beef
Speakeasy Sandwich
Blackened Grouper
Grouper Sandwich
Chicken Tenders
Lobster Bisque
Coconut Shrimp

“The shrimp BLT was a fabulous sandwich! Enjoyed our lunch! Service was excellent! Thanks“

3.8 Good371 Reviews
Tony's N.Y. Pizza Pizza • $
Recommended
145 South Barfield Drive, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

The Madison Square Garden
The Park Ave Margherita
The Manhattan Deluxe
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Cheese Pizza Slice
Eggplant Parmesan
Meat Lovers Pizza
The Queens White
Chicken Parmesan
Antipasto Salad

“As a long time year round resident I have had the food many times, usually great. The other day I picked up a chicken parm dinner to go. Most of it went in the trash. I think it was made the day before. Chicken was like leather and the spaghetti was like trying to eat shoelaces. Please dont pass off old food as fresh. I will be back, though.“

4.3 Superb164 Reviews
Arturo's Bistro Bistros • $$
969 North Collier Boulevard, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Porcini Mushroom Ravioli with Goat Cheese
French Onion Soup
Veal Parmigiana
Pasta Bolognese
Chicken Marsala
Shrimp Cocktail
Island Grouper
Twin Tournedos
Veal Francaise
Beef Carpaccio

“Five stars—again—for Arturo's Bistro on Marco Island.

Our most recent dinner at Arturo's was our sixth visit since first discovering the restaurant in May 2025, when we celebrated our anniversary there. That first experience was exceptional, and Arturo's has continued to impress us every time we've returned.

Once again, the food and drinks were outstanding. There is a consistency here that keeps bringing us back.

A special mention to Neal at the bar, who was entertaining, engaging, and added considerably to the enjoyment of the evening. Our server, Mihaela, was attentive, efficient, and highly professional—excellent service from beginning to end.

Six visits in a little over a year says more than any single review probably can. What began with a memorable anniversary dinner has become one of our favorite Italian restaurants on Marco Island.

Outstanding food, excellent drinks, terrific people, and consistently professional service. Arturo's Bistro continues to earn our five stars. We will most certainly be back.“

4.2 Good312 Reviews
Joey's Pizza & Pasta House Pizza • $$
257 North Collier Boulevard, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Lasagna Our House Specialty
Joey's Way Paper Thin Pizza
Garlic Dough Knots
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Parmesan
Sicilian Pizza
Meatball Sub
Italian Beef
Cesar Salad
Garlic Bread

“Ordered the large combo pizza and added bacon…. I have NY and Chicago pizza (and from many other geographies and locations). This is the BEST pizza anywhere!!! We always go to Joey’s when we visit Marco Island…“

4 Good577 Reviews
Cav's Kitchen & Cocktails Pizza • $$
701 Bald Eagle Drive, Marco Island

Customers` Favorites

Mussels Marinara
Chicken Parmesan
Pasta Bolognese
Slice of Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Deep Dish Pizza
Pizza Pie
Lasagna
Salad
Wings

“Went to Cav’s to meet friends and was pleasantly surprised with the service received at the bar. Yashika and Evan were a dynamic duo! Friendly, smiling faces, helped ease our frustrations after waiting nearly an hour for 2 orders of wings. Despite the kitchen taking an eternity, the wings did not come out great but it was nice having these bartenders take genuine care of us! This was my first experience at Cav’s and will definitely be back just for them! If you want to spend time having great conversations, tasty cocktails and fantastic service go see Evan and Yashika!“

4 Good265 Reviews

You May Also Like