25 Best Seafood Restaurants in Marco Island

“Great place to visit on your boat. Call ahead they have a great dock attendant. Also, Grouper is not always on the menu but is usually available. You have to ask for it and it's worth the $12 up charge. I ordered it fried. It was light and crispy on the outside and moist on the inside. Perfection! The calamari was also perfect! Great place to watch the game as well.“

“I wasn’t too sure about going and boy am I happy I did! The service was incredible and the food was superb. I will definitely go back! The crab legs were delicious and the blood orange margaritas were a necessary repeat.“

“We could eat dinner here every time we come to Marco!! We love it!!“

“It is now a family tradition to go to Pinchers for dinner after a nice day on the beautiful Marco Island beach! The service is always phenomenal and food is delicious, and, of course, kids eat free! The fried calamari is always fresh and full of flavor! I always have the grilled shrimp Po' Boy and it never fails to satisfy. My wife had the grilled Mahi-mahi and it was one of the best that we've ever had! The seasoned green beans and the garlic mashed potatoes are ???!!“

“Best owner.. My generations of family have been going since the 1980’s!“

“Haven't been here for a while and it was a pleasant surprise to see what a nice job they did remodeling. We weren't very hungry so we started out with two bloody marys. Loved the way they were garnished and the mix was excellent. After cocktails we both had the salad bar. My favorite was their kosher dill pickles and the options on the salad bar were adequate. Everything was tasty and the service was very good. It was a fun place to revisit.“

“Fantastic food and service!!“

“The most delicious lobster rolls!“

“I like it simple. A great Mom & Pop style, open air bar for lunch. Friendly service. Nice sandwiches & the Key Lime pie is "HOMEMADE".“

“Food and service was outstanding. The Tripletail was amazing , as was the coconut shrimp and Thai Calamari. We live in Naples and this restaurant is better than any on 5th Ave. This is a must try if you’re looking for a first class experience.“

“The most amazing food and service… feels like home!“

“Restaurant food and service were great. At breakfast station, Esquado was very engaging. I asked about soft boiled eggs and he suggested to make me poached eggs and homemade hollandaise sauce. I didn’t recall the last time I had such wonderful eggs. It came out perfect. Thank you.“

“The food and service was amazing We highly recommend Fin Bistro always a local favorite“

“My neice bought me a gift card 3 weeks ago for Mangos because we love the restaurant, went there to use it and the waitress tells us we can't use it at this time...So you sold a gift card to someone when you can't use it...That seems illegal and very bad business“

“Would have been a perfect evening out if it wasn't for the front hostess,who we were told is named Diana, who passes herself off as the owner. After being shown to the dining area our friends asked if we could change the table we were brought to so that it wasn't right in the walk way coming in. We asked the wait staff and they courteously sat us at another table of our choice. After settling in, this person named Diana came to our table and chastised us for changing tables. We were told we couldn't just do that, that WE had to go back up to the front and tell them we wanted to change, not just take the word of the wait staff who we asked, which Diana said probably didn't understand English and had no right to accommodate our request. Perhaps she needs to chastised the wait staff for their response, not the customers. Image our surprise of being publicly confronted in a rude and loud voice witnessed by the people seated at the tables around us, by this person claiming to be an owner rather than making sure her customers were satisfied with the seating.
We would have left the restaurant at that point had we not brought another couple with us and didn't want to inconvenience​ them.
Our waitress Mechella, was just wonderful and the food and preparation was delicious. However I don't know how long a business can survive with someone like Diana being rude and obnoxious to customers.“

“If you haven’t been to this restaurant you need to go. I would describe this restaurant as an eclectic and industrial vibe with great ambiance. Our server Sam was phenomenal! He was very attentive, professional, respectful and charming. We went there on July 13th 2024. Our table had the burrata appetizer and the shrimp cocktail. They were plated beautifully and very delicious. I had the special of the day which was cobia over a bed of Parmesan risotto with a lemon beurre blanc sauce and Hericot Verts. I am not a fish fan but I wanted to try something different for a change and I was so happy I did. The fish had trout roe on top and it popped in your mouth and was fantastic. I finished everything on my plate. Sam sold me on it with his description and the chef provided a meal I will never forget. My dining partners had filet mignon, Lobster Madagascar and Schnitzel A’la Holstein. I tried them all and I loved each and everyone of those dishes. I wish I lived in Marco Island so I could go there often.“

“Everything about this place is just over the top, food, drinks and the staff. Vernell Symonette was amazing!“

“Rum Runner is the best..cheers !!“

“Really a 4.5. If I had two “complaints”, it would be that the cheddar biscuits were not that good and that I wish my grouper had been bigger than 8oz (although it’s very big and meaty for 8oz!). I’ve never had grouper before and went with the blackened grouper based on our waiter Diego’s suggestion and boy, he did not steer me wrong! It was possibly the best fish I’ve ever had. It was almost like a steak. Please get a side of blackened shrimp to go with your grouper cause it paired together so well. Let me talk about the clam chowder: if this wasn’t the best clam chowder I’ve ever had, then it is surely the second best and it DEFINITELY had the BIGGEST chunks of clam I’ve ever had in a clam chowder. I absolutely loved it. For my side, I got the Mexican street corn which was very good, next time I might ask for the corn to be grilled even more.
You can skip the cheddar biscuits, they (unfortunately) are nothing like and nowhere near as good as Red Lobster’s (which is very weird to say since everything else was so good). The gf got the Cobb salad which came with lump crabmeat and blackened shrimp, garden fresh tomatoes, fresh bleu cheese and a house made ranch dressing. Overall, this was easily the best meal I’ve had at the JW Marriott and if I ever come back to Marco island, I’m definitely coming back to Quinn’s.“

“Best Mexican food I have ever had!!!!!!!“

“We were in the area for the weekend and wanted someplace to watch the Miami Hurricanes football game. We were told about the Sandbar and it didn't disappoint. Everyone was nice and the food was good. Lazlo gave us great customer service too. We enjoyed sitting at the bar and talking with the locals. We will definitely go back if we are ever back in the area. Can't beat a great sports bar with good food and cold beer!!“

“Excellent dining experience at Marco Prime. Perfect portions, prepared to order with a variety of sides. Service was well timed w courteous wait staff. Put this place on your list.“

“Delicious food and drinks. Will definitely be going back. Music was really good also. The place looks great since the remodel from the storm.“

“Food was amazing, clean place and people friendly“

“The steamed clams and mussels were delicious and they bring it to your table in a steam pot! Loved it“