Tony’s N.Y. Pizza
$ • PizzaAbout Tony’s N.Y. Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Half Sausage Half Cheese Pizza
Meatball Parmesan Sub
The Washington Square
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Athens Salad
Garden Salad
Tiramisu
Tony’s N.Y. Pizza Reviews
107 ratings
Share your opinion about Tony’s N.Y. Pizza
This was the First Time Ive been to Tony's, and I must say that the Service I received from a Ms.Madison, was Over the Top! She was absolutely Delightful, Very Prompt, Very Respectful and All in All just very Attentive and made My Experience overall Worth every Dollar! I will definitely be coming back to Visit!
We visited for the first time tonight. Madison was our server. She took excellent care of us and even recommended the lunch weekly special to us and the house salad. We ordered Bruchetta, Cheese pizza with Alfredo base, and Pepperoni and Cheese pizza, and a house salad. Everything was very good and we can't wait to return very soon.
Great Authentic New York pizza at great prices i stop in to grab a slice almost every Sunday if your in the area grab a slice and try it they sell by the slice great atmosphere and the staff are always friendly would recommend to anyone who loves pizza it's a must stop shop highly recommend
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
Tony’s N.Y. Pizza is a popular spot known for its authentic New York–style pizza in Naples. Visitors often praise the perfect, thin, and crispy crust that snaps and folds just like real NY pizza. The sauce is flavorful and tangy, complementing the cheese and toppings perfectly. Many customers consider it a hidden gem for good Italian food, capturing the essence of New York pizza that is hard to find elsewhere. The atmosphere is lively and authentic, with a cozy vibe that at night feels like being in Italy. The staff is friendly, attentive, and genuinely enjoys working there, making guests feel welcomed and appreciated. Some reviews highlight the excellent service, with staff members engaging with customers and even changing music to suit the mood. The restaurant’s cleanliness and nice-looking environment add to the overall experience. Customers who have visited multiple times note that the pizza and food quality were once consistently good but mention that recent takeout experiences have been disappointing, with some feeling the taste and quality declined. Despite this, many still recommend Tony’s N.Y. Pizza for its delicious pizza and Italian dishes like eggplant parm sub, which has received high praise. Overall, Tony’s N.Y. Pizza offers a genuine taste of New York pizza with a friendly atmosphere, making it a favorite for those craving authentic Italian-American flavors.