50 Best Pizza Restaurants near North Fort Myers

“We’re new to the area and looking for good places to eat. We found a gem. Just ate an incredible dinner at Pizza Connection. The restaurant is in a big shopping plaza next to Publix with plenty of parking. It is decorated in a great casual Italian family style and is immaculate. The pizza and dinner entrees were outstanding. Garlic knots were to die for-moist and garlicky with a sprinkle of cheese on top. So fresh! For dessert, the salted caramel cheesecake was oh so yummy. We will be returning every week! Put them in your GPS!!“

“If I could start one of these up north where I live, I'd put all the pizzerias out of business! The deep dish crust is AMAZING!
Unfortunately, my husband has been on no carbs/ sugar this year but we did a splurge on the Jets 10 but with thin crust and even that was excellent!
This is the one thing we get as soon as we make it back down lol.“

“New favorite place unlocked 🙃👌
The pizza is great and I love the milk shake of Mamey , ( update if you want the best best Pizza you need to say I want skinny Pizza and in the Shake You Say, Not Too Much Sugar, and That Gonna be Amazing 🫠🫠🫠🫠“

“I'm from New Jersey so I look at pizza in a different way I don't know how to explain it but if you're from there you know, Heavenly Pizza hands down in our opinion is the Absolute best pizza Florida has, it's right up there with home, even better because it's right down the street they have canolies too, the service when you walk in and I call you by your first name it feels like you're home staff is so friendly excellent service they bend over backwards for you deliveries are quick and with a smile every time I go in I say thank God for heavenly Pizza if you don't know now you do visit them you will not be disappointed“

“Called in an order, very friendly and polite and insightful on the ingredients. Was told it was be done in about 15 minutes (I was already walking in to pay as I called the order in because I live close by and was out), the lady who helped me was quick and very friendly. The inside was clean and rustic vibes but a calmness to it. The pizza and garlic knots were done in about 6-7 minutes, and I ended up paying about 25-30$ total which is less than any chain, and it’s a nice thin crust pizza. The garlic knots were the best in north fort Myers, so “The Fat Apple” will receive my business in the future. And they should receive yours as well if you were looking for good food at a good price from a local place.“

“Mmm deep deep dish! Best Little Caesars in the area!“

“Best pizza I’ve had and I’m A German in Czech and a Polish Siciliano“

“My pizza was delicious I ordered the new Parmesan stuffed crust & chicken bacon ranch pizza it was well done the crew are all very hard working store in Andalusia has a lot of team member it’s very busy but very polite and they work fast. I ordered online & got a great deal only spend 16 for both pies 👍🏽Thanks to all team members and keep up the great work😊“

“just wanted to say that I tried the bacon mania pizza tonight it was awesome but might I suggest 😛 instead of the Canadian bacon (that we all know is ham) let's add some more bacon 🥓🥓🥓 strips“

“The best pizza in town finally in FORT Myers,, Real good outstanding pizza place to go and enjoy dinner with your love ones“

“Amazing pizza and garlic knots! Delish!“

“Amazing service and excellent pizza“

“Chicagoan here. Had my first 3 City Pizza tonight. Sou’side Chicago thin cut ‘tavern style’ supreme. Wow! It was soooooo good! You guys rock! I can’t wait to come over for a hot dog- drag it thru the garden, extra sport peppers!“

“Amazing little Italian restaurant! The food was fabulous! We were in a large group so we had a few appetizers, the calamari, stuffed mushrooms & fried ravioli were all so good! And the portions on the baked spaghetti could feed 3 people! But it was superb 😊 And our beautiful waitress Denise, was Super Fantastic! 10/10 Highly recommend enjoying an evening at this cute little place 😁🫶🏼“

“It was delicious and will be back soon. Everyone was nice and the food was very fresh. Very clean too.“

“I can't say enough great things about Mellow Mushroom! This is the best pizza in town! Whenever I go I always start with the pretzel bites! So yummy and addicting. Then depending on what I am in the mood for I get a salad or a pizza. The salads are all delicious but my favorite is the Greek or bacon Blue Wedge. If I do pizza I get either the Buffalo Chicken or Pacific Rim. I love the thick crust and basically all of them. Then if there is room, for dessert, the chocolate brownie or cookie with ice cream! 😋 oh and they have vegan and gluten free items! Can't go wrong here! Thanks to Maureen Cruz for the recommendations!“

“Oda is a hidden gem! Extremely friendly service & the best Italian food in the Cape! We have never had a bad meal here or a bad time. Anthony Gerard Tognarelli“

“Great place to grab a local brew if visiting from out of town and some amazing pizza! Super affordable slices being in a touristy town! Well worth the wait! Get the mosaic grouper IPA and hop in line! Great staff and as an Army Veteran/Firefighter EMT I felt at home coming here!“

“Went here with my kids and our friend while in the area. Staff was friends they looked like a bunch of high school or young college kids. When we asked for recommendations they all gave there fav items. They where patient with us as first timers. Food was excellent. Pizza amazing one of my kids won't eat the outter edge of pizza because there is no sauce and cheese so the kid making it made sure to go to the far edges he ate it all. Highly recommend. Just wish there was one closer it was over an hour drive for us .“

“Thank you so much for the complementary garlic knots!!! 🥰 I always order extra garlic and they remembered me“

“Came for the pizza and pints. Stayed for the killer hard core show! Definitely will be back!“

“Pizza is very good. Real close to NY pizza. We had the meatball appetizer and they were good and not great. I know great meatballs as I made tens of thousands of them when running an Italian place in the early 70's. The real key is to not make them so dense mainly by incorporating grated cheese and eggs as binder along with bread crumbs, fresh parsley, onions and garlic Also one trick that no other Italian place does is to get the finished meatballs into a pot of sauce to soften while absorbing the sauce. The garlic knots we received were a big disappointment and we will not order them again. They were not fluffy like the pizza crust and were tough to eat. The red sauce was ok but it is missing spices. I think maybe nutmeg, grated cheese,and Italian spices would add some flavor and bite. Overall though pleasant surprise and we will be returning. I am interested in getting their sausage with peppers and onions hoagie. Bravo.“

“I LOVE this restaurant! Best pizza in town!“

“Great pizza“

“Such a great pizza and wings. We will def. be back again“

“Love this place.. it’s definitely my neighborhood go to. We especially love Brook!! She’s like family to us, she is professional, curious, and has a wonderful customer satisfaction rating.. the place was updated tasteful and didn’t skip a beat as the transition was flawless! Very proud to shout out praises!!!“

“Been coming here for a couple years now periodically. The staff is always friendly and, most importantly, the pizza is always really good!! Tanya was very kind and helped me figure out what I was trying to order even though I didn’t know the name lol. Thank you to the staff as always, and an extra special thank you to Tanya!! Keep up the great work guys!“

“5 Stars ⭐️! Ordered the 16” S&P was very good, crust and sauce were awesome. Can’t wait to try the other different styles.“

“Great atmosphere and wonderful food! Bartenders were awesome!“

“Just a couple tables available to sit at , but the pizza was delicious deep dish pepperoni and bacon. We enjoyed our dinner.“

“Excellent pizza and delivered hot at 9 pm on a Wednesday night thanks to Doordash. On our list to visit soon.“

“The food, staff, experience and everything about this place is amazing! My family and I order from here monthly and it is never disappointing. We truly love it here and the customer service is unmatched. The hostesses are always so sweet & friendly. Even on very busy days, they always have a smile on their faces & have a great demeanor. We love it here!!! Thank you for all you do! So blessed to have come across this amazing place and the people there!“

“My family and I really loved this placed! Never been here before but we were looking for a pet friendly place. I got a new puppy who is yappy but very sweet that I want to expose to more places. I was nervous but the staff were so welcoming and understanding. Food was amazing and reasonably priced! Couldn’t ask for more, thank you! 10/10 will return & recommend!“

“The pizza was excellent, the service was great and the new ownership has really improved the place. Trivia Night on Wednesday’s was a lot of fun, too.“

“You should totally stop by the pizza shop and get a bite to eat; the owner is very nice and the atmosphere is friendly! I am eager to enjoy my food. And I am very excited to see what else they have to offer! :)“

“Our waitress, Celina, was absolutely exceptional!!! Super friendly and so very kind! We ate there on a Friday and went back a week later and she remembered our names and greeted us by name, as soon as she saw us!!“

“Best pizza in North cape are!!!!“

“Every Tuesday we stop by this Pizza Hut and it’s become our little tradition. I pick up pizza for my son, and he absolutely loves it. The pizza is always fresh, hot, and made just right.

The staff is friendly and the service is quick, which makes it even better. You can tell when a place is doing things right because kids don’t lie — and my son is always happy when he walks out with his pizza.

For us, it’s more than just pizza… it’s our weekly moment together.

See you next Tuesday! 🍕“

“Best Italian Beef sandwich in SW Florida. And I have have had them all.“

“Very nice staff probably one of the best pizzas I have had in awhile. Really good place for the family to kick back get a beer and some good food!“

“So delicious, clean establishment and great food!“

“Absolutely our favorite pizza in all of Cape. I have never intentionally ordered a mushroom pizza in my life, yet the Holy Shitake pie here keeps me coming back for more (& introducing new guests each time!) Super pepp is a very close second, and miles ahead of any other pepperoni pizza out there. Chris, the owner, not only hand-tossed our dough (see epic shot), but he is one of the kindest, most generous community servant I know. Alicia, our bartender, was super attentive and made great drinks. She timed our orders perfectly, and seamlessly multitasked the bar and the tables in her area. I highly recommend this place, but it’s also 100% worth noting that the pies are MUCH better in the restaurant than if you order to go. Do yourself a favor…at least for the first experience. And say hi to Chris & Alicia!“

“We had amazing experience there, everything was so delicious!“

“I definitely would recommend but would recommend clarifying your order third time I've ordered and my order what's wrong and was told there's nothing they can do about it. and this may sound Petty but the fact I spent $30 for a two topping pizza and then when I called back realizing that they have a special and I wasn't told about it just kind of was the icing on the cake“

“Best Bartenders in SWFL!!“

“my son and I love happys for a playing social scene of fun. it has alot of indoor play ground equipment and a ball pit with laser games for the kids to have a blast to play for hours with a good price .we have been coming here for years,one of his favorite spots to meet new friends. they also have video arcade games but need to buy tokens at a good price. I am so happy to be able to experience the fun at happys! highly recommend this place of fun!“

“Delicious food, great value for money and fabulous servers. I will continue going back to them.“

“Spectacular pizza and the staff is amazing too boot! Best pizza in the cape!“

“Server Victoria is one of the best!“