Papa John's in Orange Park

“Good experience at the Papa John’s in Fleming Island. The crew was friendly and worked fast even though the place was packed. Customer service was great, and the 50% off carryout specials made it an awesome deal. Pizza was solid, will definitely be back!“

“I’d actually never had Papa John’s before, but wanted to get the jack-o’-lantern pizza on Halloween for my kids. I was very impressed with the speed and efficiency this location had on a busy holiday, and I was even more impressed with how cute and tasty the pizza was!“

“We almost always get pizza on Wednesday. We were a little concerned when the people who worked at this Papa John's moved on. Brandon, the new manager, has ensured that the quality of the pizza and the friendliness of the staff stayed consistent. We have a Papa John's closer to us but we will continue to pick up our pizza at this location. Plus the parmesan garlic chicken wings are amazing!“