12 Best Italian Restaurants in Punta Gorda

“On Sept 11th my husband & I enjoyed a delightful and most delicious meal. It was our anniversary and the staff made it even more special. The only downside is when we paid the bill we were not told that the tip would be POS entered separately from our account. My husband checked our account and he thought the tip had not been given. So he made a trip to Carmelo's to ask about why and to correct. He was told the tip was done separately - think this should be told to their guests. Thank you for a lovely evening and amazing food.“

“Went back to Brooklyn Joe's today. Had the sausage with onions and peppers. It did have red sauce and white American cheese on it. I'm sure you could have provolone or something different if you choose to , but the sandwich was very good. The sausage had a good fresh flavor with a nice spice to it. Plus the pizza by the slice is good. I noticed that older people were seated eating plus young kids coming in to eat. Also workers coming in for lunch. The food is good and the place has a good character about it. The employees have a good personality and all seem to be welcome. Thanks“

“Fresh warm bread to dip in the broth from the Clam's, Sausage & Onion dish...delicious.“

“I am new to Punta Gorda and enjoyed a cheese cake and pie at a friend's home. I was immediately hooked! I have purchased many of their baked goods including some favorites that I purchase often. The sour dough bread is amazing, and my go to cannoli pastries that are the best I have ever eaten. Nino's is a local stop I make over and over again! Yum“

“The pizza was the best I have eaten in 22 years!!“

“Great food! Owner, Charles Pecoraro is Awesome! Highly Recommend! 🍷🍕🥗“

“Walking into this place feels like stepping into an Italian family’s home; warm, welcoming, and full of heart. From the moment we sat down, you could tell this wasn’t just another restaurant… this is a labor of love. The food was absolutely incredible. Every dish tasted homemade, rich with flavor, and cooked with care, the kind of meal where you can tell the recipes have been perfected over generations. The pasta was perfectly cooked, the sauce was bold and comforting, and every bite felt intentional. What truly sets this restaurant apart is the people. You can feel the pride the family has in their food and their service. They treat you like family, not customers, and that warmth makes the experience unforgettable. If you’re looking for authentic Italian food made with passion, generous portions, and genuine hospitality, this place is a must-visit. Support local, support family-owned and most importantly, come hungry. We’ll absolutely be back. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We tried Elena's yesterday while visiting Punta Gorda. We really liked our experience. Our waitress was excellent. She was very friendly and attentive. Service was fast, almost too fast in that our meal arrived before we finished our salad and soup. The food was fresh and tasted great. I personally didn't care for the gravy (with the chicken dinner), but it was okay. Everything else was great. Portion sizes are large. Prices are very, very good. Their menu is diverse, and I'd love to visit again to try some of their other offerings. Great, cozy ambiance feel to the place as well.“

“Had the Fritto Misto Mercato and the Bang Bang Shrimp. Absolutely amazing food. Presentation, flavour, quality, portion, impeccable.“

“Our favorite pizza place. It’s fantastic! Highly recommend!“

“Picked up a large two topping pizza for $7.99; They have great pizza at half the price of other local pizzas.“

“Had the thin crust Supreme pizza.
EXCELLENT!!!
Listed to live music by Mike Dougherty on the patio. Great job.
Very busy so the staff was stretched a bit but they worked hard and helped each other out. Thanks to those who work hard! Great place..“