14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sebring

“Very kind customer service, great pizza!“

“We stopped in on a Saturday evening about 5:15.
We told them we were thinking of eating in. The person behind the counter gave us a couple of menus and told us to come up to the counter when we were ready and order what we wanted.
We claimed a two person table and sat down to decide what we wanted.
We ordered the 14 inch supreme pizza.
The flavor was really good. The crust was fairly thin and properly made.
It seems to me after ordering pizzas from about a half a dozen places that they do not use much tomato sauce on their pies in this area.
I watched the artisan pizza maker gently toss the crust before putting two scoops of pizza sauce on top.
I could not see any of it in the finished product!
These people care about their pizzas!
A nice girl came by and set us up with our pizza and plates and napkins.“

“Stopped in for a drink and to check the place out. Christopher, the bartender, greeted us at the door, and was both personal and professional. He told all about the place and it's history. I had the IPA, which was great, and my wife had a cocktail with their home made lemon vodka. Also very good. She liked it so much that we purchased a bottle. Would definitely stop in again when in the area.“

“Tonight was my first time buying from here and we will definitely order from here again. You can taste the quality in the pizza, from the sauce to the cheese, even the pepperoni (which I normally hate) even the customer service was hearty and welcoming, this place gets two thumbs up on our book!“

“We ordered a large pepperoni and a large deluxe pizza for delivery. They said about 45 minutes. I would say it came in about a half an hour.
The pizza was delivered fairly hot and had very good flavor.
For some reason, this area doesn’t seem to put very much sauce on their pizzas.“

“I love their oven baked subs and salads, too. The subs are baked like calzones and bread is seasoned just like they season their pizza crust, layers of flavor.

Vegetarian options: Their salads are not skimpy and you can tweak them a bit, take something off or add something more. The pizzas are flavorful and can be vegetarian unless you don't eat cheese. They have onion, pepper choices, mushroom, olives, pineapple, etc.

Parking: This is in a strip mall, there are 3 or 4 rows of parking beyond the curb spaces.“

“Ordered a Parmesan Stuffed crust, extra cheese pizza with Parmesan bites as we were passing through. Need to let you guys know the crew that was working around 3pm on 7/12 likely made one of THE best Domino's pizzas I've ever ordered from Domino's. Made an unexpected (and inexpensive) family trip stop pretty awesome. Thank you guys!“

“I’ve been ordering pick-up from this Pizza Hut almost weekly (my kids might as well be the official Pizza Hut fan club presidents 😂). Their deals make it easy to feed my family without breaking the bank, and the food is always ready on time. The staff is kind and consistent, which makes every visit a pleasant experience.“

“As far as Little Ceaser's is concerned, it's a very solid one. Sometimes they have the greatest pizza you'll ever eat, other time's, it's just okay. Employees rotate with some frequency, but they typically have very good staff, everyone at the time of my writing this is excellent. Their credit card machine has had issues with receiving gift cards for an extended period of time and their mobile app doesn't accept gift cards, which has caused issues more than once.“

“I am very impressed by the large menu with everything from burgers, soup, ice cream, canned jelly, you name it! Also, the portions are HUGE. When I say foot long, the Cuban is 12 inches long if not longer. The staff is super friendly and helpful navigating the menu and offering recommendations. Food is always hot and fresh, pizza is to die for!“

“Hands-down, the best pizza place ever in Highlands County. I will not go anywhere else. Every time I go in there it’s the best experience ever owners are the greatest and always attentive and very good. Yummy food every Friday or Saturday the hubby and I go to eat there, and we will not change our favorite pizza spot“

“Restaurant was very clean and staff was very helpful with explaining the menu. Prior to today, we haven't ate at a Pizza Hut in 10 years, but that's going to change now. We'll definitely start including Pizza Hut in our takeout routine.“

“Pizza was good, but they messed up the order. We got two Buffalo chicken pizzas instead of the two chicken alfredo pizzas we ordered. I like Buffalo chicken and it was good but for the ones looking forward to those alfredo pizzas, it was pretty disappointing.“

“Made an online order tonight for crazy puffs. Received a call about 5 min later from the manager Tasha. She called to inform me that being short staffed and running out if the puffs it would take linger due to having to fresh make them. I very much appreciated that. I stepped in after getting there to check in my order. Teshia was very polite and prompt at letting me know it was still in the making. I’m very pleased with the service from them. Thank you both“