50 Best Italian Restaurants near Siesta Key

“Everything was absolutely amazing!! Excellent service, food was delicious!! Hands down a must! We will definitely be back!!“

“First off, this place is amazing! It’s definitely a small hole in the wall shop but the pizza and atmosphere did not disappoint! Had the spaghetti and meatballs also, very delicious and can’t forgot garlic knots! Will definitely be back!!! Price is great“

“We had a family gathering catered by Dolce Italia and everything was absolutely amazing! We had trays of the Trenne Dolce Italia with sausage, an eggplant dish and homemade pasta with meatballs, which was absolutely delicious. The Mista salad was beautiful, fresh and the perfect compliment to the meal. The process was easy thanks to Matthew’s suggestions and the food was hot, packaged well and ready to be served.“

“So delicious, everything is home made. It is a small intimate restaurant and the owners/chefs are so welcoming. The pasta is so delicious and the focaccia bread to the mussels appetizer to the lamb sauce over fettuccine was perfectly cooked and seasoned. The homemade mixture they serve with the bread is unlike anything we have ever had and it was their grandma’s recipe that made it extra special. I would suggest a reservation for this hidden gem!“

“My husband and I just had the most delicious dinner at Nikki Greek in Golf Gate! Everything was bursting with fresh, vibrant flavors—truly close to authentic Greek cooking. Fresh ingredients were purely delicious. The presentation was beautiful, and every bite was absolutely wonderful. We loved it! Opa!!!“

“Hidden Gem. The owners were very welcoming and the food was fantastic.“

“Amazing wine, food and service!“

“Always a great evening, The service is amazing and the food was delicious“

“We came here for the first time this week. Our waiter was incredible. The food is probably some of the best Italian that Sarasota has to offer. We will absolutely be back. Thank you so much for a wonderful date night!“

“We have ate here twice now & every time we do it’s just amazing. The food is excellent & the service is good. I love how intimate the restaurant feels. The table side Caesar salad is so good & the spumoni for dessert is one of the best desserts I’ve ever had. I also really like how the menu is on a chalkboard, as it adds to the intimate feel of the restaurant. Thank you Marcello. We will be back!“

“Rocco and crew catered my Mom’s 80th Birthday party! Food was fabulous. All the guests agreed. Thank you again for everything. Next time we are in Sarasota we will be in for dinner.“

“Excellent!!! the hostess was so friendly. the waitress very attentive . I highly recommend it !! I just moved from Texas . I'm so happy !!“

“I return for the spiedino de mare or the chicken trio - delicious“

“We’ve had several excellent meals at Sara’s kitchen. Homey atmosphere, delicious food and you always feel like family. This past weekend we had a large party and closed the restaurant on a Saturday night. It was unbelievable. Fantastic food, excellent service, beautiful decorations. Please give this fabulous gem a try. You won’t be disappointed.“

“We had our first visit to Maestrale last Sunday, March 1st. Our group of 7 was exceptionally pleased with our meals (we've never seen our 3 1/2 year old granddaughter eat so much!), the attentiveness and the ease of scheduling the reservation. Our meals were all amazing and it was the first of many visits as we expect to enjoy many more meals at Maestrale. We can't wait to go back!“

“Our first visit to Mona Lisa Italian Restaurant will definately not be our last. Aaron greeted us and seated us and treated us well throughout the meal. The music was amazing. Italian opera was perfect to set the atmosphere. The artichoke and the mushroom starters were wonderful. The bread was yummy. The Caesar Salads were fresh and delicious. We ordered the mushroom ravioli, seafood risotto and shrimp scampi. All excellent. The wine pours were very generous. We had a great time and will definately be back and recommend this restaurant to all of our family and friends.“

“Amazing atmosphere and food“

“Very attentive service, great outdoor seating, tasty menu with so many good options to pick from. Grouper catch of the day (blackened per server recommendation) added the scallop enhancement and sweet potato fries was phenomenal with a refreshing cucumber spritz mocktail“

“Thanks you . cibo davvero delizioso. il vitello è super tenero“

“Lived here for 12 years and just discovered this place. Definitely the BEST Italian restaurant around. Everything tasted like my mother and noni had prepared it. Caesar salad was the real thing. Gnocchi truly melted in my mouth. Sauce was exceptional.“

“Amazing food in downtown Sarasota.“

“Delicious meal! Service was great! Matthew our waiter was super!“

“Incredible, 5 stars all around!! The service was incredible!! Every appetizers, drink and meal was perfectly cooked and homemade. Restaurant was beautifully spaced out with romantic lamps on each table. Servers were attentive. Give them a visit!“

“We took grandma for her 97th birthday lunch. We could not have picked a better spot! From helping mom get inside with her walker to the outstanding service for a party of 9 to the fantastic food, we were so impressed. You can taste the love in every bite! They make their pasta and focaccia in-house and you can certainly taste the difference from dried bulk pasta. We tried a variety of options from soups, salads, pasta and stuffed focaccia sandwiches-all were so delicious. The restaurant is quaint and they made us feel like family that came in for a delicious home cooked meal. We will be back! This is my new favorite restaurant!“

“We have become regulars here, the food is always fantastic, staff is great, Jess REALLY knows what she's doing with those pizzas. Just typing this has me craving a stella and a fig & pig pie. No loud music, nice, chill atmosphere. Trust me, just go, whatever you pick is gonna be great“

“The food at Sardinia is exquisite. The atmosphere is elegant and the owner is very warm and friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant. One of the best in Sarasota! Will be returning there with friends and family many times.“

“? this place.. great service from Joseph our bartender.. absolutely yummy HH ? and appetizers were awesome ? will be definitely be visiting again soon ! ?‍♀️?“

“We were there last evening for dinner. This location is much smaller than the one at UTC. Difficult to carry on a conversation even at a small table. Food was good and service was as well. Very busy and noisy for a Wednesday evening. We prefer a more intimate experience, as well as excellent food.“

“Was a great evening with the wine Pairing yesterday. The wines were great and Tatorial was informative. The 5 Dinner courses were exceptional, can't wait for the next ? one.“

“If you’re originally from the Northeast you likely had many excellent Italian restaurants to choose from. In Florida that’s not necessarily the case. 500 Degrees is one of those places you dream of finding. Fantastic old school Italian. It’s owned and operated by a wonderful family that obviously puts their hearts and souls into this restaurant. If you haven’t been there do yourself a solid and give them a try.“

“Excellent place to relax! Great people, great food.“

“The homemade sausage is excellent! The caponata was a little mushy. Overall, not a bad meal.“

“Just slammed some Ziti and bread. never disappointed!!!! Thank you for treating us awesome and thank you for the amazing food!!!!“

“Most autenthic italian restaurant in town!“

“My husband and I had a delicious dinner and superb service by Julie our server. We always look forward to our dining experience at Caragiulos.“

“If you’re in Lakewood Ranch and craving New York–New Jersey style pizza, you have to try Valentino Pizzeria Trattoria. 🍕 I’m from Long Island, so trust me when I say I know good pizza — and theirs is!. I just realized they were originally established in New Jersey, and honestly it all makes sense zzzThe red sauce, the crust… it tastes like home. Their whole menu is amazing, — the chicken piccata, the chicken parm, literally every entrée is done right. You can tell they put pride and professionalism into everything they make. If you haven’t been, go support this awesome local spot. You won’t regret it! 🙌🇮🇹🍝“

“We had Valentino’s cater our son’s wedding and the food was absolutely amazing!! Everything TASTED YUMMY!! We ordered three different salads, garlic knots, brucette, caprese salad,crazy chicken Alfredo, meat lasagna, eggplant parm. Ziti, meatballs, sausage, chicken parm and Mediterranean chicken. Everyone raved about the food! The women who delivered it was so friendly and did an amazing job. They even supplied the serving utensils.“

“Great food, and the service was exceptional, best lasagna I’ve had in a long time“

“The best meal I’ve had on Longboat Key in 6 years…we did the Savor Sarasota extended meal with wine - $60/person, and everything was well above expectations: great wines by the glass, the tris di bruschetta was the best I’ve ever had, as were the meatballs, and the pastas, branzino and tiramisu all are worthy of ordering again.“

“Authentic Buffalo Style pizza. Homemade crust and sauce is to die for. Definitely our go to place for pizza from now on. ❤️🍕“

“This place is incredible! I felt like I was in Italy as far as food and atmosphere goes. Hands down best pizza I’ve ever had and all the pasta is homemade. The place was full of Italians, true Italians which is always a good sign. Highly recommend!“

“Alright, here’s a polished version that you could post. Riva in Longboat Key was absolutely amazing from start to finish. We came in for lunch andwow! It reminded me how much great service can elevate a meal.

The whole team was warm, attentive, and knowledgeable without being overbearing. They gave us space but they were always exactly where we needed them. Everything was done thoughtfully, from the pacing of the courses to the vibe and the attention to detail. There was real care in the overall experience. Obviously, great food matters, but it’s that blend of quality, hospitality, and atmosphere that turns a meal into a memorable experience, and Riva has that completely nailed. We left so impressed and feeling like it was an incredible value for the level of service and care that we got. Easy 5 stars.“

“Best pizza in Sarasota hands down..will be getting again tomorrow with friends!“

“The food we had was excellent, and we enjoyed talking with the owner who said he has been in business for 21 years. Its important to support small restaurant businesses especially when they serve authentic Italian cuisine and desserts made with fresh ingredients and pride.“

“Great atmosphere and delicious food! Very family friendly as our 7 year old had a blast! Well worth the price and hope to return again soon!“

“We love wood fired pizza and Atmosphere delivers in every way! This small friendly spot on Beneva has the best wood fired pizza we have ever tasted in FL -“

“Great atmosphere Amazing drinks! They’re open now! After hurricane Milton! The best Mule I’ve ever had“

“Went here for the first time last night with some friends. Friendly staff, great food and service was phenomenal!!! I had the lasagna and was fantastic. Made from scratch ingredients....homemade bread, made from scratch cream of broccoli soup. wings are out of this world! It is a hidden gem! We will definitely go back!!!“

“The food was exactly what keeps people coming back. Everything we ordered was fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. It’s great comfort food at a fair price, and it’s hard to go wrong with the menu.

The service was also friendly and attentive throughout our visit.

The only downside is the atmosphere. The restaurant was quite loud and crowded, making it difficult to have a relaxed conversation. It lacks the cozy, authentic Italian ambiance you might expect and feels more like a busy chain restaurant than a place to enjoy a leisurely dinner.

If you’re looking for good food and great service, Olive Garden delivers. Just don’t come expecting a quiet or intimate dining experience.“

“The pizza was amazing. So much cheese!!“