50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Siesta Key

“First off, this place is amazing! It’s definitely a small hole in the wall shop but the pizza and atmosphere did not disappoint! Had the spaghetti and meatballs also, very delicious and can’t forgot garlic knots! Will definitely be back!!! Price is great“

“Love it here! Best food ever!“

“Wow Wow Wow! Absolutely delicious and authentic Italian food! I never order pasta from a pizza joint... I'm way too serious about my pasta. I took a chance on Capo as I'd had a slice of their eggplant pizza and it was fabulous. I orded the rigatoni bolognese, and requested penne as a substitute. It was heaven. The sauce was perfect - the amount of garlic was subtley handled as was the rest of the seasoning. No bitterness and not too sweet either. You can tell the sauce had been cooked awhike and not rushed. The meat was high quality and the coupe de gras was to burrata! A huge helping of cheese right in the middle of the dish. The serving was huge... I only needed it for myself and I got 3 meals from it. Of course as all pasta lovers know it was even better the second day. I had the good fortune to be offered a meatball to try by the owner. I went back the next week for an order of meatballs and tried the gnocchi. Highly highly highly recommend giving this place a try!!!“

“Lenny'z has a great atmosphere. The pizza was fantastic - New York style of course. The meatball appetizer was especially good. Our server Caleb brought the whole experience together with skill and a great attitude. He was outstanding. Thanks.“

“We had lunch today at Oak & Stone in North Port. Wellen Park! Great food service and pleasant atmosphere. 5 ⭐️“

“Found this amazing pizza on Sunday while driving through Gulf Gate! Delicious, fresh ingredients and reasonably priced- go try it if you are looking for something more exciting than your average pizza!!“

“I recently hosted a group dinner at the Mellow Mushroom in Sarasota for 80 Sarasota High School baseball players and their moms and it was AMAZING!!! Everyone had such a great time! The food was delicious! Service was awesome! And dinning area and set-up were perfect and for our group! We'll definitely be back! Owner, Karen Atwood, is so supportive of our team! She's awesome!“

“Great friendly place, best thin crust pizza ever“

“Best pizza in Sarasota hands down..will be getting again tomorrow with friends!“

“At my request my husband picked up four pies for our family yesterday. It has been so hard to find decent pizza since I left NY in 96. They greatly exceeded my expectations. If you want legit northern style pizza, I couldnt recommend more. I have tried pizza from every where recommended and it was always missing something. This place brings the flavor and homemade authenticity from a true pizza expert. You can tell that so much heart goes into every slice. LOVE! A++“

“We love wood fired pizza and Atmosphere delivers in every way! This small friendly spot on Beneva has the best wood fired pizza we have ever tasted in FL -“

“Great atmosphere and delicious food! Very family friendly as our 7 year old had a blast! Well worth the price and hope to return again soon!“

“Fantastic place. Sal’s is the best pizza around and the owner was super friendly as was his staff!“

“Food was prepped quickly and was delicious. Grace was fantastic!“

“Delicious pizza I’ll come again“

“Gave this place a shot super-late one night when nothing else was open and couldn’t have been happier. The pizza was great and they keep serving food in the hours when everyone else has closed or shut down their kitchen for the night. Now that I know about it, I’d go back even when everyone else in the area is still open/serving.

Update: Ordered from them a few times since I wrote my original review (?) five years ago and my last experience was really rough. The pizza was just so poorly made and not at all up to the standards I’d come to expect from them. Hopefully it was just a fluke but it was so disappointing that I haven’t been back since. I’m only dropping my review to 4stars because of all the good experiences I had before but… that last one was pretty bad.“

“Best Pizza ! Every Friday for 15 + years , great people , great food. , recommend to everyone ! YUM !“

“Used these guys to have pizzas, salad and garlic knots delivered to PAM rehab hospital for nurses, assistants and therapy staff for taking such great care of my dad! Nick was most helpful taking and helping me with my large order for 40 people. Everything was delivered on time and still quite warm when folks started coming through the line! The lunch was delicious, everybody really appreciated it, and we will be back again! Thank you 😎❤️“

“I love their pizza! Definitely one of my favorites in town and their cheesy breadsticks are awesome as well! Plus location is grand. You can get pizza and then ice cream right next door!“

“Great time with great friends.“

“I’ve been coming to Rico for a few months now I’ve been taken care of by Leah and Abby for lunch most of the time. Great service great attention, which is why I keep coming back again and again love the food. Love the service. Keep up the good work.“

“Great service at the Drive thru or inside! The thin crust pizza is delicious and very reasonably priced! Great Caesar salad also!“

“Best wings ever! Dog friendly seating outside. Favorite pizza in Sarasota and a healthy roasted veggie salad“

“We have enjoyed every meal we have ordered BUT the pizza is THE best we have had in our 5 years in Florida, and the caesar salad is always delicious! The staff is friendly, but the physical place itself is not inviting.
However, the fact that we come from Parrish for the food says a lot.“

“This is how you do pizza!🤌 10/10 recommend! Would definitely order from here again!“

“Great food and great service. Chef Joseph came out to greet us and talked to us about his special risotto preparation. It was nothing short of fantastic!“

“Du Quebec a siesta key première arrête en arrivant sur l’ile délicieuse les enfants l’adore“

“We had an amazing experience at Big Top thanks to our server, Val! She was incredibly attentive, super nice, and made sure everything was just right throughout our visit. Her friendly attitude and thorough service really made our meal extra enjoyable. Highly recommend!“

“Best pizza hands down ! Real New York style pizza ! Amazing“

“Excellent Italian cuisine. Service and food were outstanding. Highly recommended!!“

“This Bee Ridge location has been a staple of our Friday night pizza for a long time. I usually pick it up & the young man at the drive thru window is always very kind & prompt... so I make sure & give a cash tip, (when I have cash on hand), that is. We've never had a bad pepperoni pizza... also, can't beat the price!“

“My family is never disappointed with the food or service!! My pizza is always hot, fresh and absolutely delicious. We adore the staff and the one time we had a mix up they were so quick to fix it. Don't always believe the negativety you see online about a place. THE KAREN is a growing pandemic. You can't treat people like crap and expect good service!! Well unless you are a Karen!! Be kind and tip well. This staff is worth it!!“

“Awesome pizza. Great hospitality. Love it. All kind of Pizzas ready to go. Awesome Stromboli as well. Highly recommend“

“Keltsey, Elena, Bri are absolutely amazing, Elena had such a warming and sweet welcome at the host stand, Keltsey was holding down the bar perfectly and was making conversation with all of the guests and ensuring they were having a good time, and Bri was very attentive and was so helpful with the beer wall and the questions we had about the menu. All three girls showed amazing hospitality to us today! They were fabulous!“

“This is how you do pizza!🤌 10/10 recommend! Would definitely order from here again!“

“First off, this place is amazing! It’s definitely a small hole in the wall shop but the pizza and atmosphere did not disappoint! Had the spaghetti and meatballs also, very delicious and can’t forgot garlic knots! Will definitely be back!!! Price is great“

“Ordered this pizza for delivery tonight, was a first time customer. Their pics looked good so I thought I would try it. I got a large pie, well done, with peperoni, sausage, anchovy, and an order of wings. I was thoroughly impressed with all aspects of the food. Pizza was nice and thin and crispy, they did not skimp on the sauce or toppings. It was very flavorful. The wings were also outstanding. Nice big quality wings and their buffalo sauce and garlic parm sauce must be made in house because I havent tasted them before and they were really good. I will 100% order from them again.“

“Very welcoming as soon as u walk in, friendly staff, quant and cozi. I got the bruschetta, very good!!! Then a large sized garden salad which was good, then the capellini with maranara sauce and sausage and all wonderful!! I didnt feel rushed and my food came out as I finished one meal and not all at once, the pasta was not watery like most places and sausage was so good!! Not to mention the background music was great 😊“

“This was a unique experience and you should try it at least once. Choose your toppings from just cheese to just shy of the kitchen sink! My wife's pizza was literally piled high and I wasn't so sure it would cook all the way through!
I loaded mine with jalapeño peppers and other spicy toppings. Excellent!
Service was quick and efficient. Customers came and went but the place never looked sloppy or overwhelmed.“

“Very clean and something to do for everyone! Amazing atmosphere and the pizza was awesome! My 3 year old enjoyed it very much as well as me and my husband, we will definitely will be back! overall we were NOT disappointed ❤️“

“We are in love with Jet’s Pizza now that we’ve found them in Lakeland and in Sarasota. We were in Sarasota visiting with our daughter and son-in-law for the weekend and decided to have pizza on a Friday night. You can imagine that’s not an easy choice to make given the crowds. But I called Jet’s to see if they had tables inside. They informed me that they had two tables and we headed over. We were greeted by the friendliest face of a pizza maker ever! He told us he was “living the Pizza dream!” What a great guy.\n\nWe had the four corner Detroit-style pepperoni, which was perfect perfection. We also tasted the chocolate chip dessert cookie and loved it. Our daughter and son-in-law chose a different pizza with the Detroit crust and some wings. If you’ve never had their pizza, you need to know that each piece has corners. That’s what makes it so extra special.\n\nNothing was left when we were finished with dinner! We had a great time and interacted with customers and management throughout our meal. Great food, great service, and a lot of laughter. I highly recommend this location. Very personable and friendly.“

“They always have the best service at this location. Thanks Webber St. Domino's!“

“I worked in pizza many years ago, and I've eaten pizza all over this country as a trucker. I have never in my life seen picture perfect pizzas. Like the ones in the commercials, until I ordered from this little Caesars. Not once but twice, the pizzas looked almost too good to eat. Seriously I am impressed. Y'all deserve a raise.“

“Alex is the best. He was born to do customer service, he needs to be in management if he is not already. I screwed up my online order, he happily fixed it and was so patient and helpful. The pizza was prepared perfectly and they even cut it in squares for me. Thank-you Alex. If I still had my business I would hire you in a heartbeat“

“? this place.. great service from Joseph our bartender.. absolutely yummy HH ? and appetizers were awesome ? will be definitely be visiting again soon ! ?‍♀️?“

“Amo este lugar es pizza cubana auténtica !! Yo ordeno la pizza para que mi familia me la traiga por avión a Virginia cada vez q ellos me visitan. También he visitado el lugar y la atmósfera y la gente es bien profesional y atenta! Me encanta! La recomiendo 100%!“

“Amazing wine, food and service!“

“I ordered and it was at my house ELEVEN minutes later! Its Saturday at 6pm dinner time! I thought the tracker was broken. Its hot, delicious. Perfectly baked "more" like i lke it and i had three items. I had tipped extra to use up the gift card and its deserved. Nice Job crew!“

“We took grandma for her 97th birthday lunch. We could not have picked a better spot! From helping mom get inside with her walker to the outstanding service for a party of 9 to the fantastic food, we were so impressed. You can taste the love in every bite! They make their pasta and focaccia in-house and you can certainly taste the difference from dried bulk pasta. We tried a variety of options from soups, salads, pasta and stuffed focaccia sandwiches-all were so delicious. The restaurant is quaint and they made us feel like family that came in for a delicious home cooked meal. We will be back! This is my new favorite restaurant!“

“We stopped in Marco’s and ordered 10 large pizzas for delivery later early evening. The staff taking the order were fantastic and very helpful. The delivery was great and on time. The pizza was delicious and hot! We love Marcos Pizza in Nokomis.“