28 Best Italian Restaurants in Stuart

“Fabulous family owned restaurant. Excellent food and service. We dine there quite frequently and you are treated like family. Great specials and always freshly cooked. Occasionally, you may need to wait a few extra minutes because they’re not popping anything out of a can. It is all fresh cooked to order. Extensive menu, delicious, desserts, and family, friendly. A+++“

“How does a restaurant get 30+ people to rave about their dinner? Ask Piatto Divino. They know how and they do it easily. There are very few restaurants that can do that. Bravissimo!!!“

“What a wonderful treasure of an Italian restaurant. From the fresh garlic bread to the amazing food to the service. 18 of us didn’t affect them at all! Definitely going to go back.“

“Excellent authentic Italian restaurant! The food is delicious - you can't go wrong with anything you order; eggplant parmesan, linguini with clams, salads, garlic bread - all are amazing and I could go on and on! The restaurant is family run and there is always warm and pleasant service from the chef's family. I highly recommend reservations because it is so good that it's always busy!“

“I have to say this place rocks. If you are looking for authentic Italian food served by an authentic Italian family then this is the place. Service impeccable, people are fast friendly and so damn kind. Food was delicious and you taste the herbs and fresh tomatoes. My whole party was extremely happy and we were a party of 75! yes, 75!! Not one of the people in my party had a negative comment, not even a hesitation. We will be back. Thank you to the beautiful family who runs, owns & cooks to make this sooo Good!“

“Great food and good service. Excellent chicken parm“

“Michelina's never disappoints and it has become our favorite Italian restaurant. The food is always perfectly prepared and delicious and the kitchen is accommodating to any special requests. The entire staff is warm and welcoming and makes the experience totally enjoyable. Michelle is the best hostess and Logan is the best waiter anywhere. We highly recommend Michelina's for dining or catering.“

“Servuce from joanie was great. everything crafted to perfection with a delightful touch: a small serving of eggplant caponata accompanying our tomato mozzarella appetizer, house salad paired with a slice of heirloom tomato and homemade balsamic cream vinaigrette dressing, freshly baked bread, and a complimentary limoncello at the end.“

“My wife and I had the small plate lunch, lentil soup, Caesar salad and for her meatballs and for me, fettucine alfredo. food, service and price were great. Our server Sammy is top drawer, he knows the menu and knows how to treat and interact with the guests.“

“We love Mario’s and just celebrated our 3rd Christmas Eve there. I think they have the best sauce I’ve had in Florida. We usually get the calamari, pizzas, and a few pasta dishes and have never left without full bellies and big smiles. The family that owns Mario’s is welcoming, attentive, and gracious. They have downsized their footprint and updated the decor. To be honest I was a little taken aback with the new modern feel. It used to always remind me of my Italian grandma being there, BUT even though the restaurant had a glow up, the always delicious food and staff warmth still puts my heart right back at my grandma’s table. As long as there is a Mario’s, we’ll be loyal patrons.“

“Delicious food, great atmosphere, and joyful servers! Loved this place.“

“Went to this place for the first time Sunday and will absolutely be back. The food was so good. The portions were generous, and the staff was absolutely amazing. They made the place they also did a kind gesture for my husband and I as it was our first time eating hereand that was so sweet and surprising we will be back. Can't recommend this place enough.“

“Not only does Salerno Pizza support our TCCA community with give back nights, they have also bailed us out personally with pizza parties! Today they went above and beyond, opening early to make pizzas for our 2 year olds birthday and let me tell you, EVERYONE LOVED THEM. 10/10 recommend Salerno Pizza for not only pizza but all your Italian needs! Oh and they offer a cash discount!!“

“One of the only places to get a decent slice of pizza!!! I've been venturing on the rest of the menu and so far it's been very tasty!!!“

“I’m so excited for Angelo’s to be in Stuart! This is a brand-new location and you can already see the heart and hard work going into it. The pizza is delicious (just like the original in Jupiter!) and the atmosphere is fun, lively, and family-friendly.

Every new restaurant has a little learning curve, but the team here truly cares and is improving every single week. You can tell they want to bring great food and great service to the community.

I’m looking forward to making this one of our regular spots. 🍕❤️“

“Had an amazing experience and delicious food. Also Henry, our server, made the experience even better!! Five stars for him!“

“Our favorite Italian Restaurant. Chicken Parm and Chicken Francese our favorites!!!! The portions are very generous .. you won’t be disappointed.. Tino is an amazing cook !!!“

“This is an over exaggeration of what really happened we were a little busy but no one ever waited two hours they were late showing up the whole party came in late the most they were there was 45 minutes we do cook everything to order“

“Absolutely wonderful experience. Birthday dinner for my husband . Couldn’t have asked for a nicer evening. Excellent food , fabulous wine selection.. The owners go above and beyond to make your dinning experience memorable.“

“Annas is my absolute favorite pizza place. I’ve been visiting since her other shop on Monterey rd. Collectively 20 years at least. Always amazingly delicious, and plentiful servings! Great service as well. A heads up, She’s old school, so Cash only. Every once in a while I’ll make a mistake and eat pizza elsewhere out of convenience, I’m a good 12 miles from Anna’s. However I always regret caving in, instead of getting Anna’s.“

“Love the great service and a menu that just says we have it all . Fun to watch the jurors every so often . Be back pretty soon !“

“The single best pizza in FL! Born in Chicago, raised in Fairfield CT. You cant beat this anywhere, its like being home again, give it a shot, my family is white clam. I order a large Jimmy’s special for myself & take the rest home.“

“great food-b-tenders very friendly im there every thur rain-shine price's good & leslie a great b-tender good to b.s, with " go there "“

“The sauce is very watery. The meatball not homemade. I was disappointed“

“Great food and great service“

“Great food and great service“

“A random person told me about this restaurant that has the best Philly cheesesteaks. We decided to try it when my parents were in town and it is fantastic. The steak Philly with everything on it was delicious, my chicken Philly was perfect for me and the Patty Melt was great too.
The fries were wonderful. Looking forward to coming back.“

“last time here ordered mama linos pizza thoroughly enjoyed it made by owners i think we came back again ordered same pizza again and it was a total disappointment made by a Spanish guy...didnt taste the garlic or basil as described in menu“