27 Best Italian Restaurants in Stuart

“I was raised eating pizza on the streets of NYC. Lil bit a Brooklyn is the best around. Good pizza is hard to find in Florida. This place has great pizza.“

“Fabulous family owned restaurant. Excellent food and service. We dine there quite frequently and you are treated like family. Great specials and always freshly cooked. Occasionally, you may need to wait a few extra minutes because they’re not popping anything out of a can. It is all fresh cooked to order. Extensive menu, delicious, desserts, and family, friendly. A+++“

“I ordered chicken Parm and lasagna for a party. by far the best food ever. all guests raved about the food. thank you“

“If you want authenticity - visit Piatto Divino in Stuart! You will not be disappointed! The owner is from Sicily and their food reminds me of my roots! Thank you for such a beautiful birthday dinner Al and the team!“

“Great food and good service. Excellent chicken parm“

“My wife and I had the small plate lunch, lentil soup, Caesar salad and for her meatballs and for me, fettucine alfredo. food, service and price were great. Our server Sammy is top drawer, he knows the menu and knows how to treat and interact with the guests.“

“Let me just say that chivalry is not dead!! Chef noticed I walked outside while my friend and I came in for dinner. Was so cold I couldn’t sit and wait for dinner so I walked outside to warm up. He asked why I was outside and I told him it was too cold inside. He apologized and went inside. When I went inside to sit down he came out with a sweater for me. Felt part of the family and cared about. Was any amazing experience!“

“Servuce from joanie was great. everything crafted to perfection with a delightful touch: a small serving of eggplant caponata accompanying our tomato mozzarella appetizer, house salad paired with a slice of heirloom tomato and homemade balsamic cream vinaigrette dressing, freshly baked bread, and a complimentary limoncello at the end.“

“Mario’s is my favorite Italian restaurant on the Treasure Coast. The food is delicious and always consistent. It’s family owned and it shows plus service is great. Your meal starts with garlic bread and pizza bread always fresh and yummy! My favorite is the Veal Parmigiana they give you plenty I always have leftovers. My husband and I have tried other Italian restaurant however, none as good as Mario’s!!!!“

“Pretty pricey (seafood Alfredo with shrimp and scallops was $39), but the food was very good. Staff was attentive but not the most personable. It was fairly empty, so it was quiet, but I could see it being very loud if it was full. Wife had the flounder and that was awesome too. Nice place but with drinks it's about $200 for 4 people.“

“One of the only places to get a decent slice of pizza!!! I've been venturing on the rest of the menu and so far it's been very tasty!!!“

“Not only does Salerno Pizza support our TCCA community with give back nights, they have also bailed us out personally with pizza parties! Today they went above and beyond, opening early to make pizzas for our 2 year olds birthday and let me tell you, EVERYONE LOVED THEM. 10/10 recommend Salerno Pizza for not only pizza but all your Italian needs! Oh and they offer a cash discount!!“

“Delicious food, great atmosphere, and joyful servers! Loved this place.“

“Our favorite Italian Restaurant. Chicken Parm and Chicken Francese our favorites!!!! The portions are very generous .. you won’t be disappointed.. Tino is an amazing cook !!!“

“Had an amazing experience and delicious food. Also Henry, our server, made the experience even better!! Five stars for him!“

“Absolutely wonderful experience. Birthday dinner for my husband . Couldn’t have asked for a nicer evening. Excellent food , fabulous wine selection.. The owners go above and beyond to make your dinning experience memorable.“

“Annas is my absolute favorite pizza place. I’ve been visiting since her other shop on Monterey rd. Collectively 20 years at least. Always amazingly delicious, and plentiful servings! Great service as well. A heads up, She’s old school, so Cash only. Every once in a while I’ll make a mistake and eat pizza elsewhere out of convenience, I’m a good 12 miles from Anna’s. However I always regret caving in, instead of getting Anna’s.“

“This is an over exaggeration of what really happened we were a little busy but no one ever waited two hours they were late showing up the whole party came in late the most they were there was 45 minutes we do cook everything to order“

“Once again, we had the absolute best experience at Pusateri’s in downtown Stuart! From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel like family. Their Chicago-style hot dogs and pizza are out of this world – truly the best we’ve had around here! My favorite, the Chicago dogs, were authentic, loaded just right, and took us to the Windy City. What really made our visit unforgettable was how the team went above and beyond to help us celebrate my husband’s birthday. They surprised us with special treats and desserts that made the day feel truly personal and memorable. It’s rare to find that level of care and hospitality – they didn’t just serve us great food; they gave us a great memory. If you’re craving real-deal pizza or a classic Chicago dog, do not miss Pusateri’s. We’ll continue to keep going back!“

“great food-b-tenders very friendly im there every thur rain-shine price's good & leslie a great b-tender good to b.s, with " go there "“

“Great food and great service“

“The single best pizza in FL! Born in Chicago, raised in Fairfield CT. You cant beat this anywhere, its like being home again, give it a shot, my family is white clam. I order a large Jimmy’s special for myself & take the rest home.“

“The sauce is very watery. The meatball not homemade. I was disappointed“

“Great food and great service“

“Mom and I went for lunch on a shop keeper’s suggestion of a Local Favorite. So glad we did. Met Bri as I was parking and immediately felt welcome even though we’re not local.

Mom loved the Philly and today’s special was a Cuban which I got. YUM! (Fries were especially yummy and crisp). Thanks to Bri for the suggestions.

The restaurant is tiny, but welcoming. Almost like you’re walking into a kitchen for lunch. Even the other diners welcome you.

And to top it off, the Brightline went by just as we were heading to the truck. (Love the CHOO-choos)

If I’m in the area again … yup…I’d be back in a heartbeat.“

“I visit the Stuart area few times a year. Stumbled across this Primos on my way downtown. Tried the chicken cheesesteak, it was top notch. Better than a lot of the places I go to in the Philly area. Staff were super friendly. Bob waited on me he is from Philly, knows the lingo and service with a smile. Definitely stop back next time I’m down.“

“last time here ordered mama linos pizza thoroughly enjoyed it made by owners i think we came back again ordered same pizza again and it was a total disappointment made by a Spanish guy...didnt taste the garlic or basil as described in menu“