Jersey Mike's Subs in Tallahassee

“Traveling west on I-10 03/27/26 at 1:00PM, stopped at this location. I was amazed at how very friendly and how quick they prepared our meal. They were a three person team, I watched while in the meatcutter clean the cutter after each customers sandwich and when he took our order he took it with a kind and friendliness facial expression. I didn't communicate with man on the grill but he was working very quickly. The lady who put the condoments on our order was also very profient and polite. The whole team worked as if they were the owners of the business. If I owned my own shop, I would have tried to steal they away from you.“

“Jersey Mike's on Mahan has become a favorite for my office! Occasionally, I need to order something quick and easy for lunch meetings for my office and Jersey Mike's is our go-to! I will place an online order for 10-15 subs and when I go to pick it up, the orders have always been right on time, packaged neatly with each name written on the subs for my convenience (thank you!), as well as great quality subs that taste amazing. I've never heard a complaint from my office mates - only praises! Even with a large order where there is understandably room for human error, I still have not received a single sub that was made incorrectly. My office loves this location and we appreciate all the employees there!“

“I just want to take a moment to recognize this Jersey Mike’s at the West Tennessee St. location for their outstanding customer service, especially Colby and Jessica. From start to finish, the team went above and beyond my expectations. They were professional, friendly, and genuinely willing to help.

It’s rare to experience service that feels this intentional and welcoming. They didn’t just provide great food, they provided a great experience. Their attention to detail and positive attitude truly made a difference.

Thank you, Colby and Jessica, for setting the standard for what customer service should look like. I will definitely continue supporting this location!“

“The employees are super friendly and professional. You feel welcomed like when you show up at the home of a friend or family. They take the time to make the sandwiches exactly how you want them by using high quality ingredients. I recommend this place whenever you're on this side of town.“