17 Best Sandwich Shops in Tallahassee

Firehouse Subs Tally West Sandwich Shop • $
1420 Capital Cir NW, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Firehouse Meatball
Italian
Engineer
Chips
Hook

“The 5-Stars is because this is the single BEST firehouse sub store i've ever been to. It is managed VERY WELL and has awesome employees. Firehouse corporate should check this store out to see how it should be done. Its easily 5x as fast as the other Tally FH storesConsistently good, i work down the road and eat here every week.Note - it gets busy at lunch, so use the app if you dont want to wait, but no matter what, you won't wait long.“

4.1 Good50 Reviews
Which Wich Superior Sandwiches Sandwich Shop • $
218 S Magnolia Dr #2, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Sandwich Regular
Buffalo Chicken
Spinach Wrap
The Avocado
The Wicked
Fries
Reuben
Salad

“Stopped into this location on a whim and glad we did. Great location, very clean and quick. The guys working there were really friendly. I'm a big fan of the buffalo chicken, but it's always fun to make your own sandwich on a paper bag menu, then sit down and relax for awhile. Definitely get the fries & which-sauce. Always highly recommend“

4.3 Superb30 Reviews
Which Wich Superior Sandwiches Sandwich Shop • $
3020 W Pensacola St a, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak
Ultimate blt
The Wicked
Roast Beef
Chips
Steak
Fries

“Every time I come to this location there is nothing but good vibes and food. During my visit today I was greeted by Everest and Kelsey. They have amazing customer service!! Everyone at this location is always super polite and they always ensure I have a quality experience. The food is always fresh and taste good every time. 10/10 all around !!!“

4.2 Good35 Reviews
PrimoHoagies Sandwich Shop • $
1600 W Call St, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Italian Hoagie

“My husband and I shared a medium sharp italian sub and it was perfect. When we left he was wishing we had gotten the 2ft sub to take home. Since we aren't in Tallahassee very often, I'm sure that's what we'll be doing next time.“

4.1 Good44 Reviews
Chicken Salad Chick Southern • $$
1410 Market St STE D3, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Salad Broccoli and Pimento Cheese
Small Buttercream Frosted Round Cookie
Chocolate Marshmallow Crispy Bar
Spicy Pimento Cheese
Loaded Potato Soup
Olivia's Old South
Buffalo Barclay
Jalapeno Holly
Broccoli Salad
Sassy Scotty

“I ordered the Fancy Nancy on a croissant. The croissant itself was hard on the bottom, which took away from the sandwich. The loaded potato soup had too much cheese and the potatoes were not fully cooked.I love Chicken Salad Chick but today was a horrible experience!“

4 Good56 Reviews

6
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
2401 Mill Creek Ln, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

White Chip Macadamia Nut
Oven Roasted Turkey & Ham
Vitamin Water xxx
Grilled Chicken
Elite Chicken
Subway Club
Cookies

“This is my Subway of choice in Tallahassee. Not just for the menu choices, but for the excellent customer service. Tristan helped me with my order yesterday. He was very friendly and has a great work attitude! Looking forward to my next visit. My sandwich and cookies were delicious! Thank you Tristan!“

3.9 Good94 Reviews
Freshroots Kitchen Sandwich Shop • $
1605 E Plaza Dr #101, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Chicken Salad
Cuban

“The cutest location with nice indoor and outdoor seating available. The salads are huge and incredible, the sandwiches are so delicious - my favorite being the jammin. I've also had the mac&cheese and tomato bisque which were both amazing. 10/10“

3.9 Good71 Reviews
Goodies Eatery Sandwich Shop • $
116 E College Ave, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Reuben Sandwich
Beef Master
Salad Bar
Bagel

“I got a tuna salad salad and my husband got a Monster turkey sandwich. It was reasonable. The salad (I soon learned) is from a salad bar. I highly recommend ordering the salad, because you get to truly build your own salad.There were pastries and on the other side of the restaurant is where the hot drinks are (I also later learned).Vegetarian options: Salad bar, some sandwiches that exclude meats“

4.1 Good31 Reviews
OG Subs Sandwich Shop • $
444 W College Ave #112, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Authentic Meatballs Marinara Sub
Wrap Caesar Chicken Tender
Italian Salad Platter
Italian Special Sub
Chicken Tenders
Buffalo Sub

“We popped into OG’s the day after game day and it was the perfect sandwich to refuel after an evening of fun. The two guys working were lovely and made some pretty great recommendations on what was yummy. I will come back next time we are in Tally.“

4 Good34 Reviews
Chicken Salad Chick Salad • $
1496 Apalachee Pkwy Suite 14, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Fancy Nancy Chicken Salad w Nuts Grapes & Apple Sandwich
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Classic Carol
Loaded Potato
Sassy Scotty
Cookie With
Pasta Salad
Grape Salad
Fruity Fran

“Great food, great staff. If the prices were a little lower, we'd eat there more often, but we've never had a bad experience here. The situation with tipping the cashier is a bit ridiculous as well - this is a trend that needs to die now.“

3.9 Good49 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
1450 Timberlane Rd, Tallahassee

“Ok, I have been to over 20 different Jimmy John’s locations and this one has awesome by the book customer service. Having traveled all over the US while in the military and for business since I retired I see all kinds of places. This one was top notch tonight for sure. My family had been on the road for over 8 hours on our trip to Disney World and I wanted a great #16 Jimmy John’s for dinner before bed and I got much more than that. The guys there made me smile and where very nice. Great job.“

3.7 Good36 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
3122 Mahan Dr Ste. 301, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak
The Number Four
Sub Sandwich
Cheesesteak
Tuna Fish
Club Sub
Chips

“Personally, this location would be my favorite out of all in Tallahassee. I love the environment and the readiness. I always order online and one of the managers that works there I think his last name is Thomas, always has my food ready for me and he is always so nice. 10/10 love this location!“

3.7 Good32 Reviews
Firehouse Subs Bannerman Crossing Sandwich Shop • $
6676 Thomasville Rd Suite 2, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Firehouse Salad with Grilled Chicken
Firehouse Meatball Small
Hook & Ladder

“I recently found out that Firehouse has gluten free bread. I called today to find out their gluten free process before I ordered. I was thrilled to find out that they clean the station, use foil to toast the gluten free bread on, use separate knives, and the employee making the gluten free sandwich washes their hands and change their gloves. I was able to eat my first Firehouse subs since being diagnosed with Celiac Disease and it was amazing! Thank you to Jonathan and team for taking such good care of this gluten free gal!!“

4 Good12 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
1355 Market St Ste. A-6, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Chicken Philly Cheesesteak Bowl
Turkey and Provolone Cold Sub Giant
Ham and Provolone Giant Cold Sub
Subs by the Bag
Roast Beef Sub
Chips & Drinks
Club Sub
Chips
Mike

“This jersey mikes was nice, plenty of seating, and they had a couple tables outside. Sandwich was nice and big and filled, I always try to get the giant sub. I love that red sauce nex to the peppers. Staff was cool. Place was clean. I’ll be going to this one more often.I’ll add some food photos next visit, I was so hungry I devoured it immediately.“

3.7 Good27 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
699 W Gaines St Unit 104, Tallahassee

“This is one of my favorite Jimmy John's of Tallahassee area. It's always neat and clean everything is always fresh. Spell the breads always wonderful going in and it's just the kind of place you like to go in and sit down and eat for a little while watch the people go by“

3.9 Good10 Reviews

16
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
3196 Merchants Row Blvd Suite 160, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Oven Roasted Turkey
Cookies

“Would have given five stars if they always had white bread and fresh sweet tea prepared. Food is always good, but waiting behind someone that orders "all that and the kitchen sink" is sometimes frustrating. However, the point of Subway is getting exactly what you want on your sandwich...“

3.8 Good12 Reviews

17
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
5023 Crawfordville Rd Unit 6, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Cookies

“The girls were about to close, but they didn't try to rush me out. They took their time and and got it right. Thanks girls. They need a raise!!!?Parking: Woodville, FL plenty of parkingWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible parking and entrance“

3.6 Good27 Reviews
Loading...
map Map