12 Best American Restaurants in Tarpon Springs

“Local Tampa Bay Folks: Tarpon Tavern review: While this is a Tavern with your classic bar, TVs playing with the sports games, and a lively crowd, the food is beyond what you would expect. In fact, as other patrons' plates came out, I was really excited to receive our meal. It was busy and a little bit of a wait to get the food, but it was worth it. As a self-proclaimed pickle enthusiast, we decided to order the fried pickles. I had heard that they were different than most fried pickles, and surely they were for the better! The one thing I hate with most fried pickles is that there is more batter than pickle. The batter was very light, and you could even see the entire pickle through the coating; however, it was still crispy and golden. These guys achieved the perfect balance of crunchy exterior with a juicy, briny interior. From first glance, this is not your ordinary bowl. The bowl is visually appealing: vibrant veggies, grilled chicken, rice, olives, feta, and onions. A creamy tzatziki sauce and naan bread points bring a simple dish together to make a truly great meal. As a vegetarian, finding well-curated food is always hard. In a way, it's annoying. And like many places, they had the classic Beyond Burger. (boring). So, I spiced it up. I ordered their Smash Burger and had them substitute the Beyond Burger patty with their Tavern Twister fries. The burger came with grilled onions, pickles, lettuce, tomato and the ever-famous smash sauce. I had them add grilled mushrooms. From the first bite, the Beyond Burger defied all expectations. The patty had a remarkably meaty texture, was juicy, and was cooked perfectly. The flavor profile really brings the burger to the next level. The flavors and taste with the different toppings surely made the burger the best, especially with the restaurant's signature smash sauce, a harmonious blend of tangy and creamy, which ties the entire creation together. Whether you're a committed vegan, a curious flexitarian, or a die-hard carnivore looking to explore the plant-based realm, the smash burger with a beyond patty is a must-try. I didn't take any pictures as I was on a lunch date.“

“Awesome food. Awesome service. Great place to go. Very clean.“

“Christmas Season. Love the Big Christmas Tree and decoration! Last night. Busy with 5 minute wait. 8 People. Dinner. Food was so Tasty! Whole party loved it here. Service was efficient and incredibly friendly!! From the hostess to the servers all Smiles!! Will be back very often! New fave spot! Just moved to the lake. Shared all plates.. would order ALL again! Best Burger I've had! Calimari amazing! Whole family will be back often! Great Service! Everyone Friendly, efficient, attentive, made us feel valued. Planning big birthday here for 40 people as the value can’t be beat. Prices are in line with anywhere else… but the VIEW!! on the water! Gorgeous. Sunset! Pink sky over the lake. Love the ambiance & vibe. So Happy we found our new hangout! + Great Music!!!“

“This is one of the best seafood restaurants that I’ve been to in the area. The atmosphere is great…you can sit right on the water and have an amazing view of the sunset (obviously when the sun is actually setting) but either way there’s a nice view, great food, and almost always receive great service, depending on your waiter/waitress and how busy they are. Some of the dishes can be a bit pricey, but there’s a great variety of options, and almost all of the fish are locally caught. I highly recommend this place!“

“love their pulled pork grilled cheese sandwich it's so delicious“

“Every thing from start to finish was done with a pleasant manner and a smile. Thanks Christine. Tom and Curt“

“Best breakfast in Tarpon Springs“

“Anyone who’s ever been to johnnys knows they are the hottest spot for wings, burgers, flatbreads, and decently priced drinks! They are ypur game day location to watch any Ball game you want . They are also very accommodating to big parties.
Majority of their staff has been with them a very long time and I think it’s evidentt that they are where all the Locals go. Stop in during happy hour from 11-6pm ! Cheers 🥂“

“great food! great atmosphere! a favorite in tarpon!“

“went with my family to captain jacks, had a spitfire of a time, our server, reanna was incredible! the food was amazing and the service, being a old waiter myself was absolutely incredible!! thank you reanna and captains jacks!“

“As a first-time visitor, I was thoroughly impressed by the overall quality of the service and the food provided.

The atmosphere was welcoming and vibrant, contributing significantly to the enjoyable dining experience. I would like to specifically commend Tyson, our server, for his attentive and friendly service. Additionally, Kevin, the bartender, crafted outstanding beverages that perfectly complemented our meals.

I lool forward to returning in the near future. Based on this visit, I would highly recommend your establishment to friends and family, as I believe they would also enjoy the exceptional service and culinary offerings I experienced.

Thank you for providing such a memorable dining occasion.“

“Our server was amazing. I can’t remember her name but she was pregnant and working her tail off. Thank you ♥️“