Italian Restaurants near Valrico

“After growing tired of eating chain store pizza with a seemingly decreasing quality, or being just outside of delivery area, our neighbors recommended Formaggios. We tried a meatlover, and a white pizza without spinach. I don’t see myself going back to chain restaurant pizza if I’m near Formaggio’s!“

“I have been a long-time frequent customer and was very disappointed after trying their new online order process. There was no disclaimer the order would be delivered through a meal service rather than their own drivers. I received cold pizza and soggy wings nearly 2 hours later after the new delivery service decided to drive my pizza around the area fulfilling other customer’s orders from other restaurants first, this is after it likely sat at the restaurant for 20-30 minutes after it was ready for delivery. Had I known this, I would have called in my order directly as I have done in the past. We live within 5 minutes of the store and always receive hot pizzas quickly when ordering via phone. I should have noticed the increased menu prices and realized it was to account for a delivery service fee, but I didn’t. There should be a disclaimer on your website that online orders are delivered through a contracted delivery service. When calling to get an update on the delay I was put on hold and hung up on four times before giving up.“

“Y'ALL HAVE THE BEST PIZZA AROUND.. me and my fiance keep coming back and I would definitely give you guys 5 stars.“

“Absolutely love Westshore Pizza!
Every time I visit, the food is fresh, flavorful, and served hot. Their pizza has the perfect balance of crispy crust, rich sauce, and gooey cheese. The wings are also amazing — crispy outside and juicy inside, with just the right amount of spice. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and the service is quick. Westshore never disappoints. Definitely one of my favorite local
The new Owners are the best 100% recommended 👌“

“Had a marvelous dinner. A most wonderful server Mykaela. She was fantastic. Energetic, knowledgeable, thoughtful. Breath of fresh air. Thank you so much!“

“Steven was wonderful 👍🏾😊. He gave me a glass to celebrate and blend with my group“

“Went today for the first time (Plant City) and didn't get free breadsticks, all in all the food was good, the customer service sucked!“

“Great Food here in Brandon Like you never left NEW YORK! This is my favorite Italian Restaurant in Florida. It first has a wonderful ambience classy and romantic. I tried it with clients. Since then my wife and I have been going back ever since. The food is Amazing their Red Sauce is perfect could not be better. Their Chicken Parm is some of the best. Their Alla Vodka one of the best in Florida and they are always making memorable specials that you will be using bread to soak up the last drop. Great appetizers like the Carozza will tease your palate for more and more yummy goodness. A slice of delicious Limoncello cake and a cup of espresso is the perfect way to end a fantastic dinner out. The setting is perfect not to big “you feel you are in a subway station but not to small that you are eating dinner on the other table's lap.” It has a romantic and calming décor. Every other Wednesday they have live music. The wait staff is attentive, professional, playful, and friendly. Vito the manager and his nice wife are the best. They are from New York owned restaurants in New York they know how to make great food.“

“ALLISON at the Brandon location WAS AMAZING! She was very attentive, so sweet, food came out quick and hot! She was very helpful with any questions and our drinks were never empty without a refill next to it! Highly recommend, would come back just for her!“

“Several friends recommended this place and I'm glad they did. Love this place, very trendy cozy decor, food was delicious, staff was great and the drinks were tasty. Highly recommend.“