16 Best Ice Cream Shops in Columbus

“This was my 1st trip to Crumbl. My 12 & 13 year old granddaughters wanted to go, they'd been before. I was disappointed that most of the cookie choice were not to my taste/liking. Things like pink donut and sea salt nutella. I'll maybe try them again. Hopefully they'll have regular cookie choices next time.“

“Went with my daughter and got a coconut paleta and strawberries and cream. They were delicious!“

“We LOVE Jeremiah’s and their wonderful team! Awesome treat and a great environment.“

“Delicious!! Would definitely go back!!“

“Cold Stone has become my family’s go-to place for dessert and birthday cakes. The reason we keep coming back is simple: the ice cream is always delicious, the flavors are consistently great, and the service is outstanding. Every visit is the same high-quality experience. The staff is always polite, friendly, and welcoming, which makes a big difference. It’s nice to find a place that delivers great products and great customer service every time. Highly recommended!“

“We LOVE Jeremiah’s and their wonderful team! Awesome treat and a great environment.“

“Tried the Popbar for the first time had the cookies n cream popsicle and it was very good as well as the frozen mango lemonade 👌🏾, plenty of flavors to choose from as well as adding toppings to your pop definitely worth it, treat yourself.“

“Amazing ice cream and delightful server!! Yesterday was our first time there and we are already planning our next trip. If you like delicious, one of a kind ice cream, you have to come to Kilwins. You will not regret it! I haven't even tried the apples which looked like a dream 😍 Maybe my next trip will come sooner than expected, apples are healthy anyway....“

“Great ice cream and great service“

“It's my new FAV fast food restaurant! Excellent customer service!! Hot and delicious food! And the cheeseburger Kid's meal, including sandwich, side, drink, and ice cream for $6.99, it's perfect for my pocket 😋 👌 😄 😊!“

“I was really starting to doubt this location because the service had become slow and some of the workers were very rude. But last night completely changed my mind. There were two girls and a boy working, and even though they were pretty busy, the girls had everything under control. They got us in and out quickly, all while keeping smiles on their faces and never showing any attitude. One had dark hair and the other had lighter brown hair, and they were some of the sweetest girls. Their kindness and great service honestly changed my opinion about this location.“

“Great ice cream and great service“

“Great ice cream 🍨 !!!!!!!“

“I ordered the firecracker burger and it was good but not spicy. I had next to no lettice, bacon crumbles and no fried Jalapeño pieces but the burger was still good. the snickers blizzard was good but melting...they definitely couldn't do the flip cup on it and the fries were super cold. I'd say it was okay but definitely not the best...they could use a lot of improvements. I try to be considerate of the short staff...also THE DINING ROOM ISNT OPEN even though their website says it is...“

“Omg!!! If you haven't had the vanilla dipped churro cone... You are missing out!! The churro flavor that hardens into a shell on the vanilla ice cream if you don't know what churro tastes like...If you have ever eaten Cinnamon toast crunch!! That is exactly what it Tasted like.. super sweet and refreshing ...love!! This may only be around for a limited time so if you think you might like this sweet, crunchy, rich , mouth watering delight.... You may want to hurry to your nearest Dairy Queen...“

“Service is great, and always timely. The staff always verifies and brings exactly what you ordered. The milkshakes and other drive-in items are always delicious and nostalgia inducing. Has the drive-in atmosphere that brings back memories of simpler times.“