17 Best Italian Restaurants near Fayetteville

“It’s just a great place with outstanding food.“

“Our waitress got both the soup type and noodle types wrong for our orders. She also left croutons off the salad and never brought them though she said she would. The chicken was rubbery and lukewarm when it came out. Definitely not the experience we’re used to at Olive Garden or any Darden restaurant.“

“Delicious egg plant parm,!“

“Ever disappointed with their food. Very good pizza.“

“Great service and nice menu selection.“

“Delicious food! The new $10 take home is fantastic and makes it more affordable to eat there“

“Great food and service, will make them a regular when in town .“

“It’s rare that I write reviews, but our experience at Borgo absolutely deserves one — and for context, my wife and I are truly food obsessed. We moved here from Austin, TX and northern New Jersey, both places where excellent Italian food is easy to find. In the three years we’ve lived here, we’ve tried at least 15 restaurants in the area, and every single one has been forgettable, I’ll leave it at that. Borgo changed that instantly. From the moment we walked in, I noticed something unusual: the dining room was full, yet the atmosphere was calm, lively but not loud. When we sat down, we found ourselves next to three older couples speaking Italian. That alone told me we might finally be in the right place. A lot of restaurants claim to be “family owned,” but at Borgo, it’s the real thing. The entire family is from Italy. The owner came over to welcome us personally and took our order with genuine warmth. His wife is the chef. His sister was checking on tables and making sure everything ran smoothly. The whole experience felt like stepping into a small trattoria in a small Italian town and I don’t say that lightly. The food was exceptional. We started with the burrata with prosciutto and an arugula salad. Both were exquisite. The burrata tasted incredibly fresh and was served at the perfect temperature I don’t know if it’s homemade, but it certainly tasted like it. The arugula was vibrant and peppery, as if it had just been picked, and the dressing was beautifully balanced. For mains, we had the trout, the linguine with mushrooms, and the eggplant parm. Every dish was outstanding, but the eggplant parm stopped me in my tracks — I literally closed my eyes after the first bite. It was that good. Dessert was tiramisu and the limoncello cheesecake, and both were flawless. Light, flavorful, and not overly sweet, exactly how they should be. And the service? Flawless. Warm, attentive, personal, the kind of hospitality that makes you feel like you’re eating in someone’s home rather than a restaurant. It took us 45 minutes to drive to Borgo and we cannot wait to go back. After three years of searching, we finally found a place that feels like the real deal. Simply put, our experience was exceptional.“

“Just had the BEST Fit and Delicious I’ve ever had at ANY Partners!! Great food and FABULOUS service! I’ll drive from PTC to Tyrone to this Partners!!“

“The best Philly and Italian sub and more spot in town you will leave satisfied!!“

“Normally don’t write reviews, but I wanted to come here because I was in search of a new pizza spot instead of the one I usually go to. And honestly, I’m so glad I did!

The pizza was really good, the sauce was great, the cheese was amazing, and I loved how the toppings weren’t extra or overwhelming. We got a 14-inch and loved it.

The gelato was amazing too! I especially loved the peach cobbler flavor.

We also had an amazing server named Kiki. She was so sweet and super attentive, always asking if we needed anything else even though it was pretty busy when we came in.

10/10 would definitely come back again. The prices are amazing too!“

“I ordered delivery 12/11/2021 I was told by the manager they were short staffed for deliveries and it would take a while to make my 2 belly busters and cheese sticks for a holiday party. no biggie I understood. pizza showed up on time. we tipped the delivery dude extra because I know what that's like having to rush for deliveries. this was our 7th or 8th time ordering and the quality was amazing as always. very satisfied as a customer. support this shop. worth it every time. can't recommend there pizza enough!“

“The service and food were excellent! Both Ryan’s were amazing! (Chief/ GM and waiter) Ryan was very attentive and precise with our orders. We didn’t have to ask for anything! They were on point with everything. Our food was hot and delicious.“

“Order food a while back and all I could think about for the next 47 minutes and 29 second was how freaking good that pepperoni Magnifico was. The cheese was perfectly melted, the pepperoni was just the right amount of crispy and crust was just simply delectable. The way that thing fit in the box just right almost had me in tears. And that’s not even to mention the perfect hand off I got from the driver. I wish I knew their name so I could shout them out. I even had a dream about how sensational this whole experience was. Got to my house hot and in time too! Will never forget that experience, Marcos will forever be my go to pizza place. GOATED!“

“Absolutely delicious pizza!!! we will certainly be back!!! :) :)“

“Their food is great, and customer service even better. This restaurant is very intentional about their operation. I'm impressed!“

“The crust is the best! Sauce good too.“