50 Best Italian Restaurants near Milton

“My wife and I have come here various times over the last few months and we have become somewhat regulars. We enjoy talking to the owner Joe and one of our favorite servers, Holly. We've got recommended by a friend and we highly recommend coming here as well. It's in a little hard to find shopping mall but the food is amazing and you feel like a regular even if it's your first time.“

“One of my favorite restaurants. Sabrina was our waitress most recently. She was fabulous. We don’t often have someone confirm each persons order and she did every time. Great food, great drinks, and great service. Best way to celebrate my birthday this week. Thank you“

“Food is amazing! My husband got the small 5 meat stromboli (which really isn't small) and I had the pesto panini (because he hates pesto and I love it). We live 20-25 minutes away and he said he wished we had one of these closer to home. We will definitely be back!“

“The place is cozy, you feel like family. The service from the entrance was excellent. Zoey our waitress was phenomenal, so attentive and sweet. \n\nThe food was excellent. The veal was amazing. Th chocolate mouse was to die for. Overall an excellent experience. From a spoiled Miami foodie, 5 stars“

“This is our go-to date night. Never had a bad meal. The specials is where it's at! Rollatini anything is amazing. Expect a wait even if you have a reservation, but just grab a drink at the bar while you wait. It's a small restaurant but very cozy and you feel the love that the family has but into running this establishment. They gave us a nice homemade pickles for a surprise xmas gift - so sweet! Just love this place. Get there early or try to make a reservation before 6pm to avoid the crowd.“

“Excellent food and service!“

“Cute, cozy, and absolutely delicious. The sandwiches are amazing and are done in a way where you know whoever is making it cares, which I appreciate so much. I would recommend this place to anyone! I just found out about this spot, I wish I knew sooner.“

“Rene went above and beyond what was expected and she was extremely knowledgeable about the menu. She had just the right amount of attentiveness without seeming intrusive. She is an amazing value to your company. My angle hair pasta was overcooked twice and because of Rene, we would come back.“

“There isn’t just one thing that makes 141 my place to go, it starts with the people that work there, they are not just people that work there, but are like family !!! Then you have the other patrons that frequent this fine establishment, they are also like family !! I haven’t even got to the food yet or their wine selection !!! Let’s just say, I have spent my last 4 Birthdays there, plus even had my OG Rugby Banquet there !! Oh yeah, and I have a tendency to rent the patio for my friends and their furry babies to hangout, so they are Pet friendly on the Patio. If I sound like someone that goes there a lot, then you are right !! Not only is a Restaurant, but I also call Trattoria 141 my home and all the employees my family !!!!“

“Will provided GREAT service! Food was excellent as always!“

“The food was amazing, my 9 year old devoured the meatballs and garlic knots (they were crispy on the outside and soft/chew on the inside, 10/10 recommend). The minestrone was delicious and came with a bun that tasted like my grandma made it 😊 The staff were kind, welcoming and very attentive. I will definitely be returning!“

“Amazing food with huge portions….“

“A wonderful restaurant! Warm, welcoming staff, romantic atmosphere, amazing food. A great experience. So good!“

“Delicious food and great service!“

“Am so full of excitement and gratitude for what you have done for me Mrs. Nancy Kelvin , if I was told I will ever meet a forex trader as legit and honest like you I will probably not believe because of the bad experience I have had before trying to invest and been scammed, but someone recommended Mrs Nancy Kelvin to me, I was so much in doubt and didn't want to lose more, but this time I choose to invest little and I invested $1000 and in just 5days mrs Nancy Kelvin helped me earn profit of 2.86403 BTC which is equivalent to $25,250 and so I kept investing more and today am financially successful. Please i am very happy to introduce all my friends and family to invest in themselves and their family. Instead of looking for other evil ways to make money or …“

“THE BEST MOST MAGIKALLY DELICIOUS CHICKEN PARMASIGIANA I HAVE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE!✨️🤌🏾👌🏾🙌🏾😋🥰😍👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾“

“Megan and Ben are fabulous as hosts and bartender respectively and always make sure our order is correct and delicious and warm.“

“absolutely recommend this place!! 🙌🏼 been coming here for years and love this place.. very friendly and kind people also great food!“

“Very casual, very good made to order pasta and huge portions“

“I have been dining with Village Italian for a few years now and they never disappoint! the staff is super friendly and the vibe is upbeat. They also do a lot of local sponsoring which is great for the family feel and honest presence. The food is phenomenal, the place is gorgeous! Highly recommend this for a great experience and delicious food! We will keep coming back.“

“Yes as my wife & I eat there all the time“

“Best Chicken Parmesan in town.“

“Love the vibe of this location!“

“Excellent. Beautiful location. Looks like an old Italian house. Our server Sean was accommodating and pleasant. We will return for sure. 🇨🇮“

“I am on this side of town once or twice a week and I just happen to walk in one day got the lasagna and now it’s regular stop.“

“Excellent service great Italian food!“

“enjoyed our meal and the cake for dessert was huge.“

“I don’t write reviews often, but I wanted to give recognition to my awesome bartender Heather! She took such awesome care of me and made me feel at home. And the drinks were so delicious!! Thank you so much for your awesome dedication. I definitely will be back, Love this place and Heather!“

“Congratulations to the employers and the owners“

“Absolutely delicious and very generous portions Highly recommend!“

“Oh my goodness! Thank you very much Daniel & Brooke for catering our ATSAR event this past weekend. The chicken parm was absolutely phenomenal as well as the rolls and salad! What a delightful dinner after being in the field all day! You rock AWESOMESAUCE!!“

“Best Pizza in Alpharetta!“

“Connor Is the Reason I Believe in Olive Garden (and Humanity)
I need everyone to understand something: Connor is not just a waiter. Connor is an experience.
From the moment he walked up to our table, I swear a soft glow appeared around him like he was sent directly from the heavens… or at least from the back kitchen carrying unlimited breadsticks like a hero on a mission.
Connor greeted us with the kind of warmth that could heal childhood trauma. He didn’t just ask how our day was—he asked like he actually cared. Emotionally? I felt supported. Mentally? I felt stabilized. Gastronomically? I felt guided by a true pasta professional.
He kept our drinks topped off before we even noticed they were low, which makes me suspect he possesses either superhuman perception or telepathy. When he brought out the breadsticks, he didn’t just drop them off—he delivered them with the grace of someone presenting sacred artifacts. By breadstick #4, I was ready to follow this man into battle.
His recommendations were immaculate. He talked about the menu with the confidence of someone who has journeyed through every noodle, every sauce, every soup like a culinary explorer. When he suggested the entrée, he looked me dead in the eyes like, “Trust me.” And I did. And he was RIGHT. Connor has never lied in his life—I could feel it.
By the end of the meal, I felt a deep, emotional bond with this man. Not in a weird way—just in a “this person single-handedly made my day 10x better” kind of way. Olive Garden, if you ever lose Connor, I will riot. Peacefully. But passionately.
If you go to this Olive Garden and don’t ask for Connor, I’m telling you right now: you’re missing out on a life-changing experience. This man deserves a raise, a promotion, and his own limited-edition pasta shape.
Thank you, Connor. You are the reason I will be returning.
And also the reason I’m still thinking about those breadsticks.“

“Amazing sandwiches!! Have been looking for a place that does it for a long time-they totally hit it, and then some. Try it!“

“Delicious food, excellent menu and great service“

“Wings and more Wings!😎“

“We love ordering from this location! Excellent customer service and the pizza is made just how we like it.“

“Highly recommend Vincenza's Pizzeria! You can't go wrong. This is a must-visit. This is my first time enjoying this wonderful spot!!! You won't regret stopping and enjoying a great pizza! YUM!!!“

“1st time here and my experience was EVERYTHING! Great customer service and they helped me figure out what I wanted. They were very patient. Food fresh, not a long wait, prices not bad. I’ll def make a drive to get this again. Thank you guys for a phenomenal experience!“

“They were out of fish n chips so I ordered a Alfredo pasta with chicken. The grilled chicken was nicely done, but the pasta was partly cooked, stuck to one another..
The staff would ch3ck on you regularly and keep you updated about when the dishes will be out.“

“Okay, so let's get real here - there aren't many Chicago style pizza options in the ATL. You've got one Rosario's left (Cumming), Twin Cities pizza (Buford?), Bobby G's (Alpharetta) and the several Nancy's locations. This review is for the location near the Northpoint Mall area.

Of the several options, IMHO Nancy's is the best choice. I'm a native Chicagoan. None of the locals come close to Chi options, but y'all gotta roll with what we got.

Now, if you want to catch a Bear's game, Bobby G's or Rosario's are the choices. Mangia.“

“We celebrated my daughters 21st birthday in style! Great food, great singing…just an all around good time. Thanks for making her birthday a wonderful celebratory family memory. The owner is such a joy! ❤️❤️❤️“

“Took the family to Campania for the first time. We ordered 3 different pizzas, a Mediterranean salad with shrimp, chicken, cannolis, walnut cake, 2 different types of Italian ice cremes and everyone walked away with a smile.\nThis was excellent Italian food all made from scratch. The pizzas are the real thing! Forget N.Y. Style or Chicago. I’ve been to Italy numerous times and this is what food is supposed to taste like.\nI only have one regret, and that was with the fried Calamari appetizer. In Italy I often get a seafood salad made with fresh pickled calamari. Please try offering this rather than the fried which seems to be served in every bar and chain restaurant in Georgia.“

“Great food and cozy atmosphere! The service was friendly and quick. absolutely delicious. Will definitely be coming back“

“Love the owners and staff. Down to earth and just good people! Garlic knots are too good not to praise their virtues: doughy, cheesy, garlicky. Pizza-lover’s heaven!“

“Hunter and staff were awesome! Excellent food fresh & hot pizza and chicken parmigiana)and service this past week. Highly recommend stopping by and enjoy!“

“Great people, great food, great games and memories!!“

“The food was amazing.Chessa and Kim the bartender are amazing .it’s my new place to go.The staff is very friendly“

“I love NY Pizza of Milton is one of those pizza places that have gone from mediocre years ago to probably some of the greatest pizza around in the area. For a classic New York style pizza this place is the best good ratio of cheese, sauce, n that classic NY style crust that drops. One bite 8.8“

“awesome Food, Friendly atmosphere and can't wait to go back again“