50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Milton

“One of my favorite restaurants. Sabrina was our waitress most recently. She was fabulous. We don’t often have someone confirm each persons order and she did every time. Great food, great drinks, and great service. Best way to celebrate my birthday this week. Thank you“

“Fridays are the best Vienna Beef 🥩 hotdogs the absolute best and there’s no one around that has them except this place“

“The staff was amazing as my friend and I sat and caught up. At least 3 of them checked on us to make sure we were OK. I am impressed by the hospitality and friendliness.“

“Food is amazing! My husband got the small 5 meat stromboli (which really isn't small) and I had the pesto panini (because he hates pesto and I love it). We live 20-25 minutes away and he said he wished we had one of these closer to home. We will definitely be back!“

“good service..........“

“Starting to loose its luster. I have been a Big fan of PLP in Alpharetta, but recently the food has missed the mark. We've had issues with the very expensive pizza being skimpy or totally missing toppings, thrown together with no Love and flavorless. Our Grecian Salad salad greens had turned pink and there were very few or missing ingredients.

This is twice now!!! One more time and I'll go back to Little Caesars. GET IT TOGETHER PLP Alpharetta!!!!“

“Desi pizzas doing the rounds! Alpharetta is where you will find them!
Went to dine in on a double date. We inhaled the first slices right as it was brought out. It was perfect 🤩
Flippin’ pizza was da bomb!! I loved the Bombay chaat pizza and my friends loved the achari paneer. We had some potato wedges in desi style and garlic knots cos… well we had pizza! Duh! We’re given an onion chaat salad on the side which elevated everything to more festive mode. Everything was 😘👌🏻
The place is older but the food is divine! Has beer for beer seekers with pizza. 🫵🏻
I am coming again for sure! Was recommended the samosa one for the next time. So looking forward to that 👍🏻“

“My wife and I have come here various times over the last few months and we have become somewhat regulars. We enjoy talking to the owner Joe and one of our favorite servers, Holly. We've got recommended by a friend and we highly recommend coming here as well. It's in a little hard to find shopping mall but the food is amazing and you feel like a regular even if it's your first time.“

“Great drink, food and atmosphere 😊“

“this is the best authentic neapolitan pizza anywhere around! The staff is amazing and very welcoming and always available to answer questions! Love it!“

“Absolutely delicious and very generous portions Highly recommend!“

“I dined here on Saturday, the Cheese Steak Stromboli was so good I returned on Sunday to enjoy another one.“

“Best Pizza in Alpharetta!“

“Cool vibes for pizza place. Great music too.“

“Big “Thank you” to Dave (Manager) for his generosity in donating gift cards to Girl Scout Troop # 19799 at Dolvin Elementary in John’s Creek GA. This group is working to achieve their Bronze Service Award by collecting toiletries and birthday supplies for charity. This is one of the many reasons why we love our local Mellow Mushroom and appreciate their support in the community.“

“Our go-to for the weekly pizza fix. Seriously, the sauce, cheese, and dough are better than anything in Atlanta, and we’ve tried.“

“We have been wanting to try this place and glad we did! Bri was our server and she was awesome! She was very knowledgeable regarding all menu items and there are a ton of ver different/non-traditional pizza menu items. We had their baked wings in four different flavors and a large pizza, half and half. One half was their white garlic based sauce veggie and the other was an Indian chicken spiced. We enjoyed it and looking forward to going back.“

“Visiting Roswell, GA for a baseball tournament and this was across from our hotel. I was skeptical if it would be true NY style pizza, but boy was I wrong! You can get 2 NY style size slices and a drink for under $9 and the service was great! Garlic shaker on the table = dead giveaway this is a legit NY style pizzeria. Wish it was a chain so I could have this in my hometown!“

“Wings and more Wings!😎“

“If you want authentic Neapolitan pizza, this is the place. The crust was perfect—light, airy, and with just the right amount of char. The Margherita DOP is a standout, with genuine, fresh flavors that taste like they came straight from Italy. It truly transported me back to a pizzeria in Naples.“

“Pizza was outstanding!! 10/10“

“Okay, so let's get real here - there aren't many Chicago style pizza options in the ATL. You've got one Rosario's left (Cumming), Twin Cities pizza (Buford?), Bobby G's (Alpharetta) and the several Nancy's locations. This review is for the location near the Northpoint Mall area.

Of the several options, IMHO Nancy's is the best choice. I'm a native Chicagoan. None of the locals come close to Chi options, but y'all gotta roll with what we got.

Now, if you want to catch a Bear's game, Bobby G's or Rosario's are the choices. Mangia.“

“This is the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. Exceptional customer service as well.“

“I continue to pursue a great delivery pizza in Johns Creek. Many positive reviews for this place led me to try it. They do not skimp on toppings, which are fresh, and the cheese and crust are great. I have to agree with some of the reviews - the sauce is tasty but just too sweet.“

“Took the family to Campania for the first time. We ordered 3 different pizzas, a Mediterranean salad with shrimp, chicken, cannolis, walnut cake, 2 different types of Italian ice cremes and everyone walked away with a smile.\nThis was excellent Italian food all made from scratch. The pizzas are the real thing! Forget N.Y. Style or Chicago. I’ve been to Italy numerous times and this is what food is supposed to taste like.\nI only have one regret, and that was with the fried Calamari appetizer. In Italy I often get a seafood salad made with fresh pickled calamari. Please try offering this rather than the fried which seems to be served in every bar and chain restaurant in Georgia.“

“We love Sid’s! Great service, delicious pizza and a great space for kids. :)“

“We love ordering from this location! Excellent customer service and the pizza is made just how we like it.“

“Christian was my server he was amazing. Hi recommendations were perfect.“

“We are foodies and if the food is good, the restaurant gets added to our weekly rotation. Vendetti’s pizza is the absolute best pizza in the county! Always comes out fast, fresh and you can tell that the dough, sauce and cheese are high quality. Usually order a pizza at the bar and always get excellent service from the staff. Their salads are also the best in the area, fresh ingredients!!! Had many other dishes and love them all!“

“Highly recommend Vincenza's Pizzeria! You can't go wrong. This is a must-visit. This is my first time enjoying this wonderful spot!!! You won't regret stopping and enjoying a great pizza! YUM!!!“

“The food was amazing.Chessa and Kim the bartender are amazing .it’s my new place to go.The staff is very friendly“

“Mamma Mia! Great pizzeria! Great Neapolitan style. Perfect crust. Wife had the white pizza and greatly savored it. Very very fair price, $13 for 24- inch cheese. Nice outdoor seating on Canton. Good vibe with classic rock music playing and friendly staff.“

“This is my favorite pizza place in our area. The staff is always very friendly and the food is great. Not only is the pizza great, but I also love the chicken Philly and the wings. The prices are also very fair for what you get. The slices are huge.“

“1st time here and my experience was EVERYTHING! Great customer service and they helped me figure out what I wanted. They were very patient. Food fresh, not a long wait, prices not bad. I’ll def make a drive to get this again. Thank you guys for a phenomenal experience!“

“Great food and cozy atmosphere! The service was friendly and quick. absolutely delicious. Will definitely be coming back“

“I visit this Marco's even though it's further than another one, but it's because it's great! The service is friendly. Everyone is passionate about good food. Quality and temperature is always high, and I just highly recommend this location!“

“Great people, great food, great games and memories!!“

“I love everything about this place; the staff, food, and atmosphere. Nice patio and the open-air seating area is shaded by an amazing pecan tree. It's HUGE! Open mic nights out back on Thursdays is a personal favorite. The staff is great. It's totally worth becoming a regular for their friendly treatment. Awesome pizza of course but delicious salads too if you are looking for something on the healthier side. Last but not least, the bar with the long wall of tasty beers on tap... Yum!
Put everything together and you've found your new favorite hangout. Cheers!“

“Crust was the star this time!!! Pillow soft with just the right amount of crunch. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio but this time, this time the crust was king!!! We also ordered the Signature salad and meatballs and ricotta all of it was spot on. As if the above was not enough the service was efficient if not outstanding. If you are in the area and want Great pizza this is the spot!!“

“Best customer service by Rome and most Amazing food we’ve ever had. Mandi and I left full and happy! ♥️Thanks so much Rome! 🤗“

“Amazing food. Such an unusual mix but absolutely incredible!!Amazing owner and staff!“

“Hunter and staff were awesome! Excellent food fresh & hot pizza and chicken parmigiana)and service this past week. Highly recommend stopping by and enjoy!“

“Lauren has taken over from Vick n Dianna?!? Vick u could not have picked a better person than Lauren to manage n deliver the Best Napoltean pies. She manages to serve better pies and best service. We r so v v happy. Best tasting pizza in Atlanta. Light flaky crust with perfect ingredients. Well done. YUUM PIZZA. THX.“

“Best chicken wings i had in my life are here, Pizza is really good . But the smell inside the restaurant is horrible, chairs and floors are sticky and smelly. Restroom also is not clean. I would recommend the managers to do a clean up. Staff is friendly . Looks like the place is a little outdated. but thats ok. Just a clean up will fix all the issues.“

“Hunter and staff were awesome! Excellent food fresh & hot pizza and chicken parmigiana)and service this past week. Highly recommend stopping by and enjoy!“

“awesome Food, Friendly atmosphere and can't wait to go back again“

“Delicious food, excellent menu and great service“

“Good food, and is faster than most pizza joints. Tip your drivers if you have them deliver. The drivers pay for fuel and the vehicle, the delivery charge doesn't go to the driver, they actually pay the driver below minimum wage while delivering. $10 is a reasonable tip, regardless of how much you order, unless it's so much the driver has to make more trips.“

“I love NY Pizza of Milton is one of those pizza places that have gone from mediocre years ago to probably some of the greatest pizza around in the area. For a classic New York style pizza this place is the best good ratio of cheese, sauce, n that classic NY style crust that drops. One bite 8.8“

“Love the owners and staff. Down to earth and just good people! Garlic knots are too good not to praise their virtues: doughy, cheesy, garlicky. Pizza-lover’s heaven!“