Ice Cream Shops near St. Marys

“Ordered an all American smasher with bacon, tots, and the berry citrus refresher (still). I went late at night, about 2hrs before they close. No line. I had to wait a bit for the food but it was freshly made. The burger was good. I also like that it comes in a cardboard box and not a wrapper. The tots were just how I like them, nice and golden and crispy, not soft or soggy or cold. You get a lot of them too. Might've just found my new go-to spot for burgers. I didn't care for the flavor of the drink, I'll just try a different one next time. Perhaps the watermelon peach or the cranberry limeade. All in all, I liked it. I would come back. I recommend it.“

“The peanut butter lovers sundae was to die for! Tasted like peanut butter pie!“

“Went with my family for the first time the other night and really enjoyed it!“

“Love the friendly staff & allllll the yummy options! I can be as picky as I want & not feel guilty! Our go-to place to bring family & friends!“

“This is a great store. But this review is to say they are such nice people. I was looking for a specific gift this past Christmas that I thought they would have, but they didn't carry. They were very helpful in pointing out one of their competitors a few blocks down that could help me. Very much appreciated!“

“Can’t miss this stop on our way to Florida. Best ice cream and great customer service.“

“Awesome place, great and friendly environment. My kids and I love it“

“Delicious and love the flights to try all the flavors!“

“Best fudge in town and fantastic milkshakes“

“Great!!“

“Thanks for the wonderful Gender Reveal Eggs!!! The staff is friendly, helpful, and delivered a wonderful basket full of gender reveal goodies. My children frequent the Mooresville location and could not have been more excited to have Peterbrooke as part of their special day. Thanks again for the beautifully crafted chocolate eggs and great service… Will share pictures soon…“