20 Best American Restaurants in Tifton

“My first experience at mama Nell’s was wonderful. I told the guy who took me I’d eat that very same lunch 365 days a year. Thanks“

“I purchased a catering order off of the app. I got to the store to pick it up, but the app messed up and ordered it for the following day. The manager approached me and said that he would immediately get the order in for me. I literally only waited 10 minutes and they had the whole catering order out to my vehicle and helped me load the car. That’s fast service and I appreciate it!“

“LOVE THIS PLACE!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“I WANNA SHOUT OUT LAST NIGHTS CREW MEMBERS AT APPLEBEE'S THE CLOSING TEAM. ME AND MY FAMILY WANNA THANK YALL AGAIN FOR THE ABSOLUTE AMAZING NIGHT WE HAD. YALL HELPED US MAKE MY OLDER SISTER BIRTHDAY THE MOST REMEMBER ABLE AND AMAZING NIGHT WE ARE SO GREATFUL FOR YALL GOD BLESS YOU GUYS.“

“Great food! Eat there at least once or twice when visiting Tifton.“

“Just want to say that the waitress Dawn Marie was outstanding. We stopped at the Longan’s Roadhouse Tifton Ga. and was kind of skeptical at first since several members of our party are on very strict dietary restrictions. Once they sat us down Dawn Marie brought another waitress over who had a special dietary items on it. We were all able to find items off of the “special” menu. In addition Dawn Marie made sure that everything came out like ordered and provided service above and beyond. The other waitress that helped also was very knowledgeable of how items were cooked and the ingredients used. Again they both were outstanding and an asset to making our stop enjoyable. We definitely will be going back to this restaurant in the future. Thank you Dawn Marie.“

“My family and I stopped here at midnight to eat. It was DELICIOUS. The staff were super friendly. Shout out to the hurricane pin worker and the cook! We're from Michigan headed to Florida, they broke down their menu to us. My food was delicious. I asked for my bacon to be a little more cook, and the cook delivered. It was
✨delicious✨“

“Good Quick Food Friendly Staff“

“Man. I really wanted to love this place, but the 4 stars seemed about right for me to agree with — especially all of the five-star ratings. The chicken was decent but not seasoned that well. The breading was pretty hard (maybe not fresh), but the inside was really tender and enjoyable. It sort of let me down, though, compared to other chicken places. What really boosted this to the fourth star was the catfish nuggets. Incredibly tender and flavorful, leading me to believe they do fish better than chicken. Maybe that's where I went wrong. They do have a really large menu, and while being on the fence about 3 or 4 stars, I'd have to try more options to really make a convincing case either way. The chicken alone would have made this 2 stars.“

“We ate breakfast at Northside Cafe , the meal and service was outstanding.“

“Food was great. Clean people friendly. Very nice would definitely go again.“

“My family and I ate for Valentines dinner here! From the moment we walked in we were greeted with multiple smiling, happy faces! Our service was top notch!! The kids had a blast. The food was delicious as always. Our server was so sweet! All around great experience!!“

“Oak smoke is spoken here.

What I saw first was a smokehouse next to a rack of oak. That's all I needed to know and pulled into the busy parking lot.

My suspicions were confirmed by a bunch of local license plates.
I'm in. I smoke, over oak, and I like it.
I'm traveling through and can't do that right now.

It's honest BBQ. Seasoned gently and smoked to perfection.

The pork and beef were perfect. I should have got more for later.

We'll be back to try the rest.
Much appreciated.“

“Valentine date night. 2-14-24. We were seated, order taken. Food arrived. The food was exceptionally awesome. Delicious flavor and cooked to perfection. A huge shout out to the chef tonight. You need a raise dear. The waitress however, was a different story. We NEVER saw her again after she took our order. Never came back to check on us, never came back for drink refills, never even brought us a check before we left. We paid at the table and they automatically added a $14.00 gratuity to our bill. I certain want the cook to get that gratuity not the waitress!!!“

“Always good food I stop a lot when I come though keep up the good work“

“I recently decided to give Cookout another go and I was pleasantly surprised. I last tried them at the Tifton location shortly after they opened and was disappointed to say the least. This time was much different. Clean environment, food was excellent, and friendly service. Current management has definitely turned things around. I do recommend.“

“I went in for takeout and order four meals and some add on to the meals. Customer service was great and the wait time was good. The food was overcooked and dry and not prepared well. The fish was hard and the shrimp was over not good. Grant we went in at a busy hour and in the past I have visited this same location and the food has been delicious.“

“Great food and Wyatt was provided great service with a smile.“

“We were traveling from Illinois, & needed to stop & dine. Decided to go here, as we were about 3 & half hours from getting home, in Florida. We were taken care of , by Bethany, who had such a nice warm & greeting smile. Our order was correct, service was quick & she was thankful on our visit. She is a ten on stars, not five. Food was good & filling. If we lived in the area, we would go again.“

“We work so hard let’s keep doing it 5 stars“