Pizza Restaurants near Tybee Island

“We ordered a large pepperoni and extra cheese pizza and this was the best pizza we have had in YEARS!! They didn't have delivery tonight but it was worth the short drive to get it.“

“We love it here! This was mine and my husband’s 5th time coming here and it was great. The environment was amazing and the atmosphere is very welcoming. This time didn’t end like we would have wanted. Our server was great except he kept calling us dudes or some other nickname that isn’t used to address women. There were 3 guys and 3 girls so dudes wasn’t the most appropriate name to call us when trying to get our attention. As the night went on service was still good but then was time for the check. We asked our server for our check but no check was given to us, just a total (which was $50). We gave him $61 and told him to keep the change. We started thinking about how there was no way 8 beers and an $8 nachos costed that much (we ate 2 nights ago with family and all 5 of us ate and had 1 beer for $54). After confronting our server asking for a receipt, we got some attitude (like he knew he had been caught, and he was). After waiting to get the receipt it never came. He then sat down and showed me his notes. He lied and added things that we didn’t order trying to get more money out of us not knowing we have been there several times. After going back and forth on him being wrong and charging us too much, I said if every beer was $4 (which they are cheaper than that) or bill would be $40. He looked at his notepad nervously and said you’re right it’s $40, again lying and not actually knowing what it costs. He didn’t know where he messed up or what we actually had. Once we settled on $40 because I was tired of arguing, he brought me $10 assuming he still got an $11 tip. I left it and just said I hope he doesn’t do this to other people and understands how to be honest so he can keep my $11. Hoping to have this be a lesson for him. This was very frustrating because 1, don’t steal from customers and try to play it off (which he was and that’s why he was shaking and stumbling on words nervously when he got caught) and 2, don’t steal from your company. Overall, I highly recommend this place. We just won’t ever have him as a server again. I wish we knew our got his name, but we didn’t!“

“Sarah was our bar tender and she was amazing! Always friendly and the drinks were great! She can make anything you like! 10/10 recommend!“

“If I could give this restaurant 10 stars, I would. They were short staffed but still found time to call and check in to let us know where they were with our order. After all they went through, I gave them the wrong street address and the wonderful driver stayed on the phone with me to get our location figured out. On top of that, the food was delicious-the pizza was amazing and the wings were perfectly crisp. Thank you, Lighthouse Pizza!!!“

“Stopped in to this store a few times on our trip to Daufuskie last week. It's small but has a nice selection of items and some items local to the island. Very friendly owner. We plan visit the island again next year, and hope to try some of the food!“

“Great service and great pizza Great job by management, wonderful pizza made by a great manager with Autumn helping! I send all my students here from the college too, they love pizza & service! Best Regards,

Professor Bill Stankiewicz

Supporter for Heroes MAKE America

OSHA Safety Training, Overhead Heavy Crane, Automation, Robotics Consultant

Savannah Technical College

Subject Matter Expert International Logistics

Member of Câmara Internacional de Logística e Transportes - CIT -at The International Transportation Industry Chamber“

“I have ordered pizza to pickup for my employees and it was awesome. Decently priced and great quality. I just came here, for the first time, to meet some friends, listen to live music, and have a cocktail after work; which was also great .
(The street out front is a little loud. On a Saturday at 9pm it seems like one out of ten cars is auditioning for the Fast & Furious, but oh well.)“

“Wonderful communication and service. High quality ingredients with careful preparation. We love our Island’s crew!“

“The pizza is phenomenal!!“