15 Best Bakeries near Winterville

“This bakery is my number 1 choice when ordering cakes. The staff is amazing great customer service and prompt service“

“When you enter the store the aroma of the cookie dough smells amazing. I was kinda disappointed that the banana upside down cake was not available at the time of purchase. I managed to select other cookies. My overall experience was great. I would recommend to family and friends.“

“Delicious offerings every day and wonderful seasonal treats, too. Thank you for being such a wonderful addition to our community.“

“We worked with Sweetie Pie by Savie for our wedding cutting cake in July 2025. We loved our cake, it was exactly what we asked for! She was very easy to work with and we enjoyed many of the flavor options. We ended up going with a ginger spice cake with cream cheese frosting. We kept some cake frozen for our one year anniversary and it was still delicious when thawed and enjoyed now!“

“I just had the best tres leches cake!!! Highly recommend this bakery!!“

“Great food and atmosphere! Wonderful service!“

“While there's an outstanding bakery in Watkinsville, GA, renowned for their Bacon-Cheddar Quiche, patrons should be aware that reaching the destination involves traversing a speed trap set by the Greene County Sheriff's Office on Greensboro Highway between HWY 316 and I-20, a hazard that has led me to alter my route and avoid Greene County during my regular commutes between Auburn, GA and Shaw AFB, SC, a decision I suggest others consider as well.“

“Great cake makers, funny and sweet designs ( and tasty ).“

“We really enjoy visiting the cafe. The coffee is fabulous the pastries are very good overall. Skip the mini croissants, they are very chewy. It has a lively atmosphere . Every time we have visited it's been very busy and it is a small Cafe with limited seating inside. They do have nice outdoor seating. The parking lot does have handicapped parking. But the curbs are very high and the only handicap curb cut is quite a distance from the restaurant. In fact it's not far after you enter the parking lot so keep your eye open for it. So although it is accessible I wouldn't call this convenient for anyone using any Mobility Aid. We have been there twice and both times I saw multiple people using canes or walkers struggling to get up the high curb because they couldn't locate the curb cut.“

“We went to the downtown Athens location, everything is great …!“

“Best mocha cake I ever tasted. I will be ordering fron here again“

“A great place to eat or order out. The food is delicious--both comfort food as well unique, exotic combinations. Chef Tim's use of certain spices makes Dondero's take on some dishes so different and so crave worthy. The people who work here are also just good folks--they deserve our patronage. Try em---you'll come back.“

“We ordered a Valentine's cookie cake, and it was the BEST I have had...and I am picky about my cookie cakes. 😉. It was a thicker cookie than you would get from a grocery store, and the taste was so much better. The frosting was incredibly delicious and didn't have any of the "fake" aftertaste you might get from a store bought cake with red icing. My girls also enjoyed the "bigger than normal" sprinkles on top! We definitely will order more!“

“I've got a chance to have some various cakes, pies and other desserts from them for the last few years and never once had they ever not delivered. 🎖️🏅🏆 five stars isn't enough“

“I enjoy going here to get the same quality products as I shop for at the grocery store. The location is a small drive out of my way, but when I can, I go.

Parking: The parking lot is plentiful even if in need of repair to the concrete.“