26 Best Mexican Restaurants near Winterville

“My Husband and I just moved here and have tried 10+ Mexican restaurants in the Athens Area. We had no luck when finding a decent spot. We ended up trying Garfia's one night and was very impressed with the service and food quality. This is definitely our weekly spot!“

“I don’t usually write reviews, but when I do, it’s because someone absolutely redefines the standard—and Scott did exactly that.

From the moment we walked in, Scott operated like he had a sixth sense for hospitality. It wasn’t just service, it was orchestration. Every detail—timing, recommendations, vibe—was dialed in with a level of precision that felt almost unfair to every other place I’ve been.

Need a recommendation? Scott already knows your taste better than you do. Glass getting low? Refilled before you even realize it. Questions? Answered with the confidence of someone who is the menu.

But what really sets Scott apart is the energy. Effortless, genuine, and somehow makes every table feel like the VIP section. You’re not just another customer—you’re the customer.

If this place ever wins awards, just know Scott is the reason why.

Give that man a raise, a promotion, and possibly his own holiday.

11/10. Not a typo.“

“My son and I love this place!“

“THEIR FOOD IS OFF THE CHARTS. Consistent bangers“

“We booked La Pa on wheels for our wedding and man they DID NOT disappoint. Taqueria La Parilla is mine and my husbands favorite Mexican place in Athens and it meant the world to us to have them cater our wedding. 10/10. Best service. Best food. Carlos was awesome and so communicative the whole year before our wedding!“

“Not 1, not 2, but 3 delicious salsas! Had a taco salad with chicken and it was the best I've ever had!!! Everything tasted fresh. I highly recommend!“

“We booked La Pa on wheels for our wedding and man they DID NOT disappoint. Taqueria La Parilla is mine and my husbands favorite Mexican place in Athens and it meant the world to us to have them cater our wedding. 10/10. Best service. Best food. Carlos was awesome and so communicative the whole year before our wedding!“

“The best service that I have experienced in years! I highly recommend this place! Great job!“

“We love this restaurant! We had a last minute get together for 10 friends, and they squeezed us in Valentine’s Day weekend. We had multiple rounds of drinks, appetizers, entrees, desserts, and we were only there an hour and a half. Everything tasted great and was hot/fresh. Austin was our server and he killed it! We loved management too. Would highly recommend.“

“I just want to share this with everyone who eats at this place. Yesterday me and My wife ordered our normal chicken tacos like we always get on Tuesday's. I noticed the salsa had a slightly different taste to it. So later that night I woke up around 3 am with chills sweating profusely all over. I've literally been sick all day from this food poisoning. My wife didnt eat no salsa and she was fine. I love this place and I've never had an issue until last night. So take it for what it's worth and be careful is all I can say.“

“we ate at Taco Mama for lunch today. The staff was so nice. the service was excellent. The cook created a delicious meal for us. The food is so fresh tasting. We will definitely be back again.“

“Great Authentic Mexican Food! Excellent Customer Service!“

“all the staff treated my sister and I extremely well. Everybody received us with a smile and were very attentive. the food was amazing too. I hope i get to return soon ❤️. Thank you for the amazing experience.“

“Top notch food. Because my law office is right down the street also on Prince Avenue I go here maybe a little too often (if that is even possible). You can trust their blue plate to be top notch and unique. The standards that stay on the menu are great too. Have not been disappointed once. Visitors to Athens, make this a lunch or dinner stop for sure.“

“Delicious and affordable!“

“Friendly staff, good tacos!!!“

“Decided to try a new restaurant today and this place did not disappoint! The food and atmosphere was great. Rolando was our server and let’s just say it was a 15/10 customer service experience! Will definitely be our staple Mexican restaurant for Athens. 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“Excellent restaurant for students looking for something different. The burrito/bowl bar is well-stocked and delicious, and the food will not disappoint, especially under $12 for a burrito and chips. Great place for small groups but the seating isn't so extensive for larger parties.“

“Wanted to try to this place as it’s new in town. I’m so happy I did. Excellent food and great environment. The dishes were just what I envisioned and were delicious. Definitely will return frequently 👍“

“Es mi restaurante favorito de comida Mexicana. Los chicos son unos caballeros y cocinan super delicioso! I love this place!!!“

“Stopped by the other day with a couple friends and we had such a great meal. I would recommend them every time! Go by for Great food and Great service.“

“The assistant manager working there was absolutely amazing !! She was so helpful with our group in giving recommendations on what to do in the area. They have a cute little outdoor area with mini golf and seating. The food wasn’t bad I got just the steak quesadilla nothing special about it. Everyone else really enjoyed their food! We went around 3 so no one else was there so the food was super quick.“

“Great staff, very friendly. Excellent service!“

“Fish tacos . All of the food looked delicious. Waitress very friendly an helpful“

“Excellent staff, very friendly atmosphere with delicious food... u can truly have it your way. And the food is fresh tasting 😋 and yummy!!! #ITSWillysTIME“