23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Iowa City

“Basta Pizzeria Ristorante never disappoints! Every visit feels like a little getaway to Italy—from the cozy, inviting atmosphere to the consistently excellent food. The wood-fired pizza is a must (crispy crust, perfect balance of flavors), and the pastas are just as memorable—fresh, rich, and clearly made with care. Service is warm and attentive without being overbearing, and I always leave feeling full and happy. Whether it’s a casual dinner or a night out with friends, Basta hits the spot every time.“

“Roc was an absolute joy to work with. He made us feel special during our tastings and went above and beyond to help us source extras that they don’t usually provide. Our wedding guests loved the pizza. I’m sure we will always think of Maggie’s fondly and remember our happy day when we get to eat their delicious pizza.“

“What a way to have a tasty pizza! Pick your ingredients, choose your crust and there you go, exactly like you want it, If you warm up the oven before you leave, your pizza will be ready in about 10 minutes. Perfect. We like to order the large size so we can get several meals out one.“

“Very clean and organized. Friendly waitresses . Prompt food service and delicious pizza ! 8 ovens that can hold up to 9 pizzas each ! It is a very popular restaurant. They have frozen pizza for take out too.“

“Great pizza, bartenders & atmosphere!“

“I went and picked up a pizza from these folks for the first time last night. OMG! One of the best commercially produced pizzas I have ever had the pleasure to eat ! Full disclosure I usually make my own and they rock too. I had the The Wedgetable Garden with Jerk Chicken added. Honestly I felt I should have left it without the JC, because the pizza was already LOADED. Every darned thing about that pie was perfect. One of the few IC pizzas that is not too greasy (look'n at you Pags). I highly - HIGHLY recommend their pizza !“

“Ate here for the first time before attending an Iowa basketball game nearby. There were good choices on the menu. I had the spicey Italian meatball grinder with fries. It was good and very filling. Prices seemed reasonable. The place was noisy so it was hard to socialize with my friends. Otherwise, a good place to eat and would go there again if in town.“

“I wish I found this place earlier in my stay in Iowa city. this place is a great value! will definitely be trying more when in the area.“

“we love the chicago pizza alfredo and the Tuscany chicken bread“

“I dined with Gumby's for years until I left Iowa City and you can't beat them- we miss them a lot!“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“their chicken bacon ranch pizza is fantastic!“

“Amazing fun place! We had our first date at a Double Tap in Cedar Falls, IA so of course on August 16th 2022 when we got married we had to have our reception at the Double Tap in our local Iowa City, IA. Super fun drinks, great games, great pizza and super fun bartenders. Best first date and even better wedding!!!“

“we ate here for the first time on Tuesday and the service was phenomenal! your server, Kate, needs a raise or promotion because she was outstanding! very friendly and engaged. we will definitely be back!“

“10000% recommend picking up the food. Always have problems when delivered. Unfortunately they are now blacklisted by me. But i enjoy the food but cant go pick it up. I’ve been a customer for about 10+ years and highly recommend the Ben’s Other pizza. Very good! Very balanced for price, quality, and value. Just Do not get delivery. In my opinion, obviously.“

“The pizza was delicious! Generous toppings, great flavor crust and sauce, although the crust was a little tough. The small indoor seating area is just a courtesy as carryout is their main business, but it was a lovely afternoon, so we sat at their little outdoor seating area. Very friendly, speed-o-light service too.

Vegetarian options: The veggie pizza includes a diverse and generous selection of toppings.“

“Ava was incredibly helpful and informative. Also super sweet. They offer free water which is incredibly important during these summer months. The culture is inclusive, and Ava was extremely compassionate with a little girl when picking out a lolly pop. It’s the small things when interacting with customers and she was exemplary.“

“They usually get everything right. I'd give 5 stars, but I got charged twice for one order.“

“Never disappointed! Consistently great pizza!!“

“We ordered a pizza and brownie, when they arrived all the toppings had slid off the pizza and were in 1 corner of the box. I called the store, and they apologized right away and sent a replacement pizza, they even offered to throw in and extra dessert for our trouble. We declined the extra dessert, but thanked them for their excellent customer service. The replacement pizza was great. 10/10 will order from Domino's again.“

“In town for a wedding, stopped to try as we never been. Solid place to eat. Staff was great, helpful and kept the place clean. Food was solid, chicken was juicy, good cheese on the pizza bread was solid.

Definitely a good choice if you're looking for some good eats.“

“We enjoyed another visit to Flight. attractive menu choices from simple to serious entrees. Excellent value with half piracy wines on Monday and Tuesday. Prompt, engaging service and a pleasant setting. Not a problem getting a table even though they did not have my confirmed Open Table reservation. Might be a good idea to call if you think you have one.“

“Last time i was here was when it was over at old location on s riverside drive. I craved some lasagna and bread tonight. And it DID NOT DISAPPOINT. ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. BEST I have ever had there. Thank you to the cooks !! And the fabulous front end gal for her fantastic customer service“