Pizza Restaurants near West Branch

“Eating eating here the other night I have to say this is in the league of Sam and Pagliais. The cheese is legit and even though it doesn't feel like an authentic pizza house, if you're talking about quality of pizza at a great bar this place is 10 out of 10 - the aesthetic ambience feels like out of a movie from the 1950s and at the end of the day it's good local old-school West branch County.“

“Pizza is fantastic, both breadsticks are my favorite!! Little biased growing up on Paul Revere's but I have had other places and it does depend on how it is made!! Smaller locations don't carry what the bigger stores can due to what sells & what doesn't. I love the smaller pasta dishes they are perfect for my daughter & I and being able to order naked wings with whatever seasonings Randy uses (I don't like a lot of sauces). Thanks dad for running a GREAT business for OVER 30 years & cooking on my nights off!!! I don't get wings as often due to food cost going up so the price went up but NOT the owners fault they have food carriers too. Still my favorite pizza place & always will be I know how & where my food is made & is CLEAN. THANK YOU RANDY & FOR PAUL REVERE'S“

“Pizza was good. Perhaps a bit light on toppings. I paid for added onions and didn't notice many. Cheese was a bit light compared to other Papa Johns pizzas I've had as well. The delivery transaction was fantastic. My polizza came piping HOT. I would definitely give this store another try.“

“Don’t really get gas here because I heard they had water in the tanks previously, nor do I order pizza because I don’t live super close, but the customer service has always been really good! The two cashiers tonight were super sweet and helpful! Pushed new product they had while not being obnoxious about it! Decent little Casey’s!!“