40 Best Pizza Restaurants near Eldridge

“This place is consistent and delicious. I haven’t had a bad thing yet!“

“I had a bad first impression when I went about a year ago. Very understaffed and poor guy behind the counter seemed setup to fail. Tried them again after getting a raw pizza from the place across the street. Seems that they've gotten some folks hired. Very friendly, pizza is great, service is quick. complete 180 and has been consistent.“

“I’m Chicago born and raised, so yeah—I don’t play about my pizza. Deep dish, tavern-style, Sicilian… I love it all. So when my friends kept talking up Smash Pizza, we decided to try it for Mother’s Day. It’s a cute, smaller spot, so just know you might have to wait or do takeout. But the staff made it worth it—our waitress (purple ponytail, wish I caught her name!) was so warm and helpful with recommendations. We started with the bread plate, and listen…that alone was a win. Fresh bread, olive oil, butter, burrata—honestly didn’t even need the extras, it was that good. Now the pizza. I was a little skeptical because Chicago folks know—we like our crust thin with a little crunch. But we went with their Sicilian style and I’m so glad we did. That crust? Light, airy, crispy…nothing like that chain pizza pan crust. Just done right. We got the Queen, and my son tried the mushroom and fried kale. I don’t even like mushrooms, but that fried kale? So good—crispy, flavorful, perfect texture. Everything tasted fresh. Like, really fresh. Hell, even the water tasted fresh, lbs! All in all, this place is legit. I haven’t had pizza like that in a long time—it really reminded me of home. If you’re thinking about going, just go. It’s worth it.“

“I’ve stumbled across this place and it’s my new spot. breakfast is so delicious! 🤤 everyone is so friendly !“

“Seriously the best slice of cheese pizza I've ever had. And it was h u g e. And it was only five bucks. Brought a vegan pie all the way back to the Chicago suburbs and it was the best vegan pizza I've had.“

“I believe they use prefab crusts, but they are pretty good.“

“I drive 7 hrs round trip just to get your pizzas. I get 4 large,bring them home and seperate them in freezer bags. Pop a few slices in the oven when I get home from work and it is just like having it freshly baked ❤ Thanks for always being so delicious ❤“

“Tried the pizza first time about 2 months ago, it's definitely different than anyone else's and it tastes so good, a little lite on toppings but it's full of flavor and prices are reasonable. Crust and sauce have amazing taste.“

“I live out of town but when I come his way, I try to get his pizzas🍕“

“I drive 7 hrs round trip just to get your pizzas. I get 4 large,bring them home and seperate them in freezer bags. Pop a few slices in the oven when I get home from work and it is just like having it freshly baked ❤ Thanks for always being so delicious ❤“

“Our staff was friendly and kind“

“First time ordering a pizza from here and it won't be the last! The pizza tasted great, hot and fresh, and received two thumbs up from both of my kids. Looking forward to ordering again soon and trying other pizzas on the menu!“

“We order here ALL the time. You can't beat the $10 Tuesdays!I ordered an original crust pizza, they given me a thin crust. I didnt realize until I had already cooked it. (I thought the dough would rise) We called and talked to them they said bring it back and gave us a new one, also told us to pick 2 sides from the case. Great customer service.“

“This was my first time for Mediterranean food, and it was fantastic! The food, service and staff were exceptional!“

“Our 2nd home😎 Great food and the Atmosphere and employees are awesome! Before you can sit at the bar you have a drink and a water waiting. Love this place!!“

“Went to order for delivery and everything went smoothly until the uber driver my order was assigned to STOLE my pizza. I went in and spoke with the manager and he helped me turn in the driver and obtain my refund. They remade my pizza and then added in some extras! I greatly appreciated the service, and the conversation, super amazing team of guys that made my night.“

“Had a little bit of a wait for the pizza, but nothing too bad or too extreme over designated pickup time. Food turned out great when I got home for my takeout order. The atmosphere was decent, just a small group of people waiting on pizza. Likely just due to height of dinner time rush. Good experience overall.“

“We love this place. The pizza is good and the price is a bargain. We've been buying it for years. The one that was closest to us closed, and we were very disappointed. We don't get to have it as often now that we're farther away, but it's always a treat when we do. We have our favorites but tonight we branched out and tried the new Detroit style pizza and cinnamon wheel. I highly recommend both.“

“This place opens up at 2pm but must have opened on the day I visited since there were already about 20 people in the brewery when I showed up at 2pm for the FIFA World Cup semi final match. This brewery has more beers on tap than the two brewerys near it (Stompbox and Front Street). This brewery also has food but I didnt order any to comment on it. The strawberry gose was the best beer I tried. Wonderful service by the bartender and I would definitely revisit based on the service and sports viewing provided.“

“Great old fashioned food. Great service.“

“We live in North Liberty and last minute made a decision to drive an hour to the quad cities to spend Valentine’s Day. We quickly realized we may have waited too long and couldn’t find anywhere taking reservations or walk ins. We came across antonellas and waited for them to open. I’m so glad we did! I’m not sure if we would’ve enjoyed anywhere else quite as much. They were short staffed and still delivered us a perfect meal from the wine to the pasta. Friendly faces, personable service, and excellent Sicilian cuisine. Thanks for making our valentines special! We will be back!“

“One of my favorite places to eat in the Quad Cities. Love the lentil avocado bowl, the tangine. I’ve never been disappointed!“

“The food was amazing. Our waiter Jacob was the best we've ever had anywhere and the overall experience very memorable! Can't wait to come back!“

“I’ve been meaning to write this review! First, I want to say that the owners are very kind people, and I was absolutely impressed with their pizza! Best crust ever! We ordered a couple of appetizers as well and they were also quite tasty! We will definitely be back and we highly recommend this establishment for pizza! Sooooo yummy!🥰 Staff knows their menu and makes great recommendations! Our server was wonderful.“

“We used Happy Joe’s for our employee lunch. The food was ready to go when ordered and tasted great. Thanks so much for the good food!“

“Good food , great people 😀😀😀🎶“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“We order Pjs often so obvi we are fans but the delivery driver we had tonight was AMAZING. He held our 3 boxes while I brought them in one by one, so I could hold my fussy baby in the other arm. He was super nice about it too. Thank you so much!!!!“

“Food is very good and always has a home cooked taste. A very relaxing environment to talk to one or many friends at the same time depending on the occasion. We have all stopped for a drink or sandwich and it turns into a great time with friends and family, and many great memories made.“

“Shout out to Bad Boyz! I came in sons Late night hungry after working all day and the cook gave us an EXCELLENTly Fried 18 pc, 6 was inferno and it was hitting the right spice! Not too much not too little! Ranch was on point…I didn’t get the Bleu cheese because I’ve had it before and its not all that. Oh and The manager lady in red was cool too, patient with us ❤️❤️“

“This is a slam bang place for Chicago- like fare! I have never had a bad meal. Wet beefs, spaghetti and meatballs made just right, Chicago dogs.... you won't leave hungry. Service is great also. You never want for anything. Highly recommended!!!“

“Our favorite pizza! We got the Thanksgiving Special. Turkey, mashed potatoes & gravy, dressing, cranberry sauce, fried onions, mozzarella cheese. Huge and delicious. 😋“

“I really like the product but not the store on 53rd in Davenport. Iowa. The manager assured me it would take 8-9 mins to make my order and he would bring it out to my car right outside their door. I was the only order being made at 1:12 pm. I went in at 12 mins and the manager said it would be another couple mins with no explanation and he promised to bring my order out to my car. At 22 mins I went back in and no one else had placed an order in all that time. The manager would not even come out to talk to me. He made a young man in the back come out and finally give me my order. No apology or explanation given. I will drive to another location next time.“

“Ok so yeah, we had kind of a wait to get some a couple pies. Well worth it! Perfect topping ratios, cooked so excellent. Hands down best godfather slice ive ever had. The man working the counter was very polite, and even thoyvh the internet told us 95 minutes, he had out order ready in about 40. The kitchen was clean and well put together despite having a single cook with fair amount of orders. I will be back.“

“I have never had a bad experience when ordering from Wise guys! The pizza is the best in buffalo and the staff are friendly and accommodating! I can’t say enough good things about this place. I recommend ordering from wise guys to anyone! Great food!!! You won’t be disappointed 😊😊😊🍕🍕🍕“

“Huge shout out to Happy Joe's Pizza & Jungle Bungle - W. 50th took my kiddos here tonight for the first time and had a blast. Staff was off the charts helpful and entertaining. The "Jungle" is massive and the slides are crazy. My 2 and 4 year olds freaked out when they walked in. Pizzas(2 large) were fire and the cheese sticks (we got the large order as well) all the food fed 2 adults, a 9 year old and my littles with plenty of left overs for the late night snack fest. Making this a trip at least a couple times a month from now on when we wanna unwind locally. 100% recommended this for anyone with hyper kiddos.“

“Got a Webberoni (spiderman promo pizza) and I think the cashier just didn't notice it was sitting for quite some time, so I asked for one to be made fresh and someone chased me down outside 60 seconds later after I just lit a cigarette to give me a fresh hot one, absolutely amazing and perfect pizza thank you guys so much for making my night with that one! 😁😁“

“Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“Ordering here for a school dance and something went wrong with the app. Came in and had to order 10 pizzas on the spot. More people came out of nowhere to start making my large order. It was made, cut, and in my hands in 15 minutes. Fantastic customer service from Skyla. Thank you for saving my kids school dance!!!“

“I had 10 hungry guys at work that wanted pizza and we all agreed on this location. I ordered the pizza to be delivered at noon. I received an email confirmation and watched the order progress on their website. The delivery was made at noon...exactly, by a delivery guy that was actually happy. All 5 pizzas were cooked to perfection. I am not typically a Happy Joe's guy, but that may change after this. This was the best experience I have probably ever had with a pizza order.“