29 Best Ice Cream Shops near Eagle

“I love their vegan and gluten free options and their customer service is awesome!“

“So yes, the cookies are absolutely amazing. So are the staff though. After they close up one of there crew uses there own time, late at night, to deliver extras that would have been tossed to local fire houses, ERs, what ever. Good food made by good people who bring a little surprise of joy to some hard working folks. Thank you!“

“Went in for late lunch and had some issues with getting our order right. They eventually straightened everything out and gave us a coupon for our next meal. Very friendly young folks and great customer service with the corrections. We will be back.“

“Amazing customer service!! Huge scoops!! And they always have a Keto Flavor!! Their selection of classic and innovative flavors is second to none…and the fact that they have something for this 18 month Keto Warrior, where else would I go??“

“I popped into Stella’s late one afternoon on my way home from work, looking to treat myself with a pint of ice cream. I couldn’t decide between my usual go-to flavor of mint chocolate chip, or if I wanted to try something new. I wound up doing both and also got a pint of the All Nighter, a coffee-flavored ice cream. They even had peanut butter PUPsicles so I grabbed one of those for my dog. The gal at the counter (who was super helpful while I asked questions about the ice cream flavors) rang me up and I was on my way. I’m almost (but not entirely) embarrassed to admit that I didn’t make it home before I needed to try a bite of the ice cream. I was in standstill traffic, it was hot, and I had a spoon. Or so I thought. I was already committed at that point so I just took a little bite off the top of the opened pint. And another. And another. It was so good that I ate what I could reach without the use of a spoon, then I had to try the other flavor. Both were so good and creamy that I had to force myself to put the lids back on and save some for my husband. My dog is lucky I didn’t break into his pupsicle. Now to the pupsicle. I gave it to my dog as soon as I got home. His little mind was blown by the surprise treat and I sat on the floor with him, holding the pupsicle as he licked it. He didn’t stop until the ice cream was gone and once it was, he still had the cookie part to eat. He rated it 4 paws up and wants another. I will definitely be back to try all the flavors!“

“okay...I'm not sure about the "homemade" ice cream... just moved here and that was the best choice I made that night. That being, I can't recommend THE STIL for anything besides the BEST ICE CREAM I HAVE HAD ♥️“

“The ice cream is creamy and good. But after reading the ingredient list I won't go back as they use high fructose corn syrup in their ice cream.“

“Stopped in today this was the koolest candy store my dad and I have been to in a while the lady working was so nice to talk to all the kool candy’s and sodas they have worth the trip from baker to meridian for definitely will be back soon“

“The ice cream offered is of exceptional quality and flavor. For customers who are pressed for time or have a large group, a convenient drive-thru option is available. I highly recommend this establishment and rate the ice cream a perfect 10 out of 10.“

“I recommend the white chocolate mousse frozen yogurt! Best ice cream been going since I was a kid.💜😋“

“So Yummy and the owner Julie is so kind!!“

“What a great burger and fries! Grand daughter ordered chicken strips and they were delicious as well! GREAT FOOD and SEVICE! Friendly staff! Will go back again for sure!“

“Kelly is always friendly, helpful, takes great care and provides great customer service. The store is always clean, toppings full and in order, and great yogurt flavors. And Kelly makes it so much better.“

“Don’t get confuse as you reach destination as per Google Maps, the “Snake River Creamery” is inside Hills Kitchen (photo attached).

We tried most of all ice cream stores in treasure valley and I would say this is one of the best with different flavours than normal ice cream stores. We tried “Pineapple Mango Guava” ice cream and we liked it.“

“A good pick me up ! Love bringing the grandkids here“

“We just discovered this gem and had the best time tonight! The ice cream was AMAZING, and we were so excited to see that they had board games to play. We will definitely be back.“

“The food is amazing!!! Best burgers in town. The customer service top notch. 🤌🏽

Shout out to the young man who took our payment and handed us our food. It's not too often you get such great service.

The staff all deserve a round of applause 👏🏽

P.S. it's okay to tell jokes that aren't that funny. The fact that you brought a smile to a customer means more than you know. 💅“

“I go to Star, ID once a year to visit family, and we always stop to get my favorite cookies. I absolutely love the sea salt peanut butter one, and sea salt white chocolate oatmeal one. My mother-in-law comes to see us a couple of times a year. She already knows to not show up without cookies. She had to bring a bunch while I pregnant because I craved them. So these cookies are 100/10! I absolutely love them so very much!“

“A good pick me up ! Love bringing the grandkids here“

“BEST FOOD AND SERVICE LOVED THE ENVIRONMENT“

“Huckleberry filled, with cream cheese frosting on top was fantastic. Not too sweet, great consistency, except it’s a little messy to eat without a fork.

Service was friendly and prompt, even though there was a line when we first walked in.

The smell is heavenly, environment was clean and cute.“

“Always a great experience here! The customer service is top-notch everyone’s friendly and welcoming from the moment you walk in. Orders are always ready quickly, and the cookies? Always fresh, warm, and delicious. It’s the kind of place that keeps you coming back!“

“Last night (July 24, 2025), our peaceful Idaho Israel Alliance meet-up at Push & Pour Coffee on S. Latah St. was disrupted by a group of aggressive anti-Israel agitators. Though we had notified the café in advance and were simply enjoying our first monthly gathering, these individuals showed up shouting hostile slogans—including “death to Israel,” “death to the IDF,” and “you aren’t welcome in Idaho”—while repeatedly trying to provoke a confrontation. Despite our calm and respectful conduct, the café employee asked our group—not the disruptors—to leave, stating, “We don’t support your cause and you aren't welcome here.” We complied without fuss. The agitators remained until Boise Police arrived and professionally trespassed them from the property. We’re sharing this because no one should be harassed or removed from a business for meeting peacefully—or for being Jewish, which is exactly what this felt like. We thank Boise PD for their respectful handling of the situation and remain committed to civil discourse, mutual respect, and the freedom to assemble.- IIA.“

“Never frozen meat, fresh jalapeños, green leaf lettuce, great service.“

“What do I recommend? EVERYTHING! This place is so cute. The staff is always the sweetest. Everything is delicious and creative! 🩷“

“The Wisconsin chain made it to Idaho. Good too! The place is clean as a whistle, the food is fairly priced, and salads are no-cost alternatives to fries. Make sure to order a frozen custard. The staff go out of their way to be friendly and helpful too. This place is a winner in every way, except that the area's traffic is terrible.

A second visit was enlightening. I was early for a lunch date. The manager let me have a solo cup for a drink while I waited. Then I skipped the cup when my lunch date showed up and we later ordered our meals. Very nice customer service.“

“I loved the pastrami burger, it hit the spot!

This was my first time trying finger steaks, they’re decent.. I liked them best dipped in the fry sauce.

I definitely preferred the fries over tater tots.

I’d eat here again, though if I wanted a regular burger and fries, I’d probably go to in-n-out. For the pastrami burger, I’d for sure come here!“