12 Best American Restaurants in Mccall

“We avoided this place because of one cook in particular. Now that he was finally let go, We will be eating here much more often. 🩷“

“We only ordered drinks - my Chai was pretty good overall but my husband, while okay with it, wasn't too pleased with his coffee. It was also super busy during an off time, but we will probably try again.“

“I used to go there like every other week cause I love the burgers. This last time, I was a little shocked with the pricing, it has gone up. Just for a burger, tots and a drink, it cost me 20+ $. It'll be a while before I go back. But t really like this place and being run by a family, I respect and admire them.“

“My husband and I came up for his birthday weekend, and I booked a table online - easy to do and followed up with a phone call to make sure we got a table with a lake view. Cutwater delivered hugely - got table right next to the lake, had a great appetizer of potato croquettes, wonderful mains of the ribeye and halibut (slightly overcooked to my liking but nice and flaky), and the strawberry roulade for dessert. However, when I booked, I mentioned we were going for my husband's birthday, and they also surprised him with a cupcake - so sweet and thoughtful. We definitely recommend it to everyone!“

“My daughter lived in McCall for the summer and sadly we didn’t find this amazing restaurant until her last week. Their sandwiches are out of this world delicious and the bread is made fresh each day. We are eating lunch here each day this week before she leaves 😊“

“Fabulous food amazing service.A+ for John our server.“

“Far and Away the Best Dining Experience in McCall, let alone All of Idaho. The Staff was friendly beyond words, the service above and beyond, and the food was Absolutely Delicious. I Highly Recommend “The Narrows” the next time you’re in McCall, Idaho. Five Stars!“

“The food was great and service was on point.“

“McCall Brewing Company is my favorite place to eat when in McCall. You won't find a better burger in the mountains. It is family friendly and the staff is amazing. I recommend them to everyone I know that visits there. It's always a hit!“

“Visited on our anniversary on 9/10/25 6:00pm 2️⃣0️⃣! Things always work out how they are supposed to! These gringos had planned to go to the Narrows at Shore Lodge for dinner. Well, who knew you need a reservation on an off-season Wednesday??? We decided on Steamer’s because they always have good food and good service. They were slammed crazy busy. There were 3 girls working front of house and they were killing it. All we heard were words of support, love you’s, and we got this rang out countless times. I have no idea how many kitchen staff were in the back but everything came out fast & yummy! I have always been a fan but even more so now. You cannot have that kind of vibe without good leadership so compliments from the top to the bottom 🩷“

“Had lunch there today! Great food-clam chowder was excellent and the personal pizza was spot on!“

“The service, as well as food is INCREDIBLE! The cooks do an outstanding job and the girl that runs the front desk does an outstanding job! They don’t ask or require tips, all the reason more to do so!“