49 Best Pizza Restaurants near Star

“Props to the two girls and one delivery guy who were on shift the evening of Sunday 11/23. I had placed an online pickup order through their website and waited inside 5 minutes before it was ready. I am not sure if this pizza shop was understaffed but I heard one of the girls on the phone asking 3rd party and online orders to be turned off because they had an immense amount of orders coming through and were running out of supplies. They still managed to handle everything so great under pressure and pizza was the best tasting ever! Mind you, this was my first impression of the service, staff and food. The quality and the customer service was wonderful! I would definitely recommend to friends and family and will be back soon!“

“We got a thin crust, and it was literally perfect! Can’t believe I’d never tried it, and I pass it daily. 🍕“

“Outstanding gentlemen at the register! And phenomenal customer service! Food is always on point! Not to mention the restaurant is cleaner than before!“

“If I could give 10 stars I would. My husband and son came in to pick up our order tonight not only were they treated so well the employees made my toddlers night. Aside from the amazing customer service fhe pizza was cooked perfectly. Best location in the valley by far.“

“Awesome service and food was perfect. The new manager has really changed things.“

“The food was fantastic! We had the curry vegetable and the butter chicken pizzas. Definitely check this place out, you will not be disappointed.“

“We visited Margherita Pizza for the first time tonight. Seeing a wood fired oven in a pizza restaurant is a good first sign. A friendly, personable staff is the second. Tasting a fresh salad, refreshing Italian soda, and delicious pizza (in a style very similar to what we had in Italy) sealed the deal for us! They just gained two more loyal customers.“

“I have been here with my kiddos but we are from out of town, so I had to return with my entire family to make another great experience & to make great memories! Highly recommend best experience & best pizza I have ever ate.“

“We came in on Valentine's Day without a reservation. The staff were very accommodating and found us a table in the dining room. Staffing was exceptional with plenty of front end, waiters, bussers and bar help. My Wife asked for a dish that was not on the menu and after the waiter asked the chef the possibility, it was made for her. Wow! I ordered a steak and shrimp dish with broccoli. I was amazed at the tenderness and flavor, the sauce bathed the shrimp in a spicy wonderful sauce and the bocolli was cooked to perfection. Will be back. Staff were constantly attentive the entire time.“

“My Family visited Proper Pizza for the 1st time tonight. The best thin crust pizza in the valley. The man who served us was so friendly and nice. We will be back!“

“We love Longboards! Their pizza is the best in Valley in our opinion. Full Bonfire Rip Curl is worth it. Freshly made, quality ingredients, and staff is always so friendly! Greet beer selection on beer wall as well! We’ll continue to support them. ❤️“

“your pizza is so delicious, and I love the price...I highly recommend...“

“Favorite Pizza in the Valley“

“We were just expecting the ‘normal’ size pizza..but Johnny Bronx Pizza came in clutch, and said hold my beer. Delivery was fast. BEST pizza my family has had!“

“I'm a hard person to please sometimes I'm a former world champion martial arts the only one in the first one in Idaho inducted into the real black belt Hall of Fame with Chuck Norris blaze Pizza went above and beyond tonight I ordered a pizza and got hit by a car a a mile away a young man Bryce from blaze Pizza insisted to bring the pizza to me here and they went above and beyond to take care of their customer I recommend to go to blaze Pizza and that's for Bryce“

“best ranch I've tasted in my whole life. pizza is always amazing as well!“

“Idaho pizza makes the best crust! We just ordered their 'two topping' special with mushrooms and chopped garlic - awesome combo and you could really enjoy the flavors of this pizza. Try them - this was the Eagle location!“

“There was a group of 10 of us, I made a reservation online ahead of time. When we arrived, it was pretty packed! They seemed a little unorganized/not prepared, but there was a very large group of people there for a celebration of life. So I think it may have thrown them off a little bit. The drinks were really good as well as all the food. We were told that the deep dish pizza was authentic but took up to an hour to get done, which sucked to hear. We also had to ask for water, which we found odd as most places just automatically bring water for the whole table, but it wasn’t a huge deal. We got the meal for two which was a medium pizza, choice of salad or wings, and a dessert. We really appreciated how the meal for two seemed like full size plates and we didn’t leave hungry. Our server was very sweet and was busting her butt the entire time we were there. All in all, it was very good food and atmosphere, and we will likely come back.“

“Grabbed an XL pepperoni and sausage pizza to eat before the trick-or-treating shenanigans begin. I placed my order and my food was ready so quickly at the pick up window. The pizza looks great with ample toppings, and the gal that helped me was so quick and efficient and friendly!“

“Perfect choice for feeding the office. The pizza was fresh, hot, and delicious, with plenty of options for everyone. Ordering was easy, delivery was on time, and it made lunch simple and stress-free for the whole team. Always a reliable go-to when we’re feeding a group.“

“We were just expecting the ‘normal’ size pizza..but Johnny Bronx Pizza came in clutch, and said hold my beer. Delivery was fast. BEST pizza my family has had!“

“Favorite Pizza in the Valley“

“LOVE THEIR PIZZA?? The Gent that helped my Son and I great personality and eyes.“

“My family decided to call in for pizza on valentines day and I was selected to go pick up our food. The service was quick and the atmosphere was nice. The staff was highly helpful and quick to get me my order. The lovely to check me was Grace, she was very nice and friendly she even gave me candy!“

“Favorite Pizza in the Valley“

“Great place great pizza if running errands take to go a slice“

“The meatball and Italian subs were so delish… we will be back!“

“We enjoy visiting this location as the staff are friendly and helpful, the store is neat and clean, and the pizzas are made well with ample toppings that are distributed evenly. There can be a wait of 20-30mins for your pizza if ordered during busy times (Tuesday eve, Friday/Saturday eve) - therefore, I highly recommend ordering ahead on the app/web, rather than doing a walk-in order. Also, recommend a bit more in-store seating for customers who are waiting for their orders.“

“Hot honey pizza is absolutely delicious and very reasonably priced. I made a mistake on my online order and placed it at the wrong location. They made me a fresh pizza and were super nice about it, even called the other location to let them know. Fantastic customer service and great tasting affordable pizza. Not sure what more you could ask for. Will be back again for sure!“

“Best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had.“

“I want to add to my review after another year of coming here and ordering more than I would like to admit. I could go on and on on how much I love this location of idaho pizza but the main two things...We have never been disappointed by the food, we think it is by far the best pizza around. And the people that work here give top notch customer service. They are the kindest group of people Every. Single. Time. You guys rock!“

“Thank you to the most friendly, kind hearted crew at Marcos! We came in on a late Friday and had the best service form Cody and Trevor who were working hard ti keep us laughing and well fed! Thanks boys! Had the very best pizza that was served quickly and perfectly made!!!! I couldn’t be more happy with every part of out experience at your restaurant. Trust me I am not easily impressed but those two made our evening so much better! They made us feel like family! Thanks boys!!! ❤️ your favorite crazy football mom!!!-J“

“I placed my order online. I was able to add my coupon code without any issues. I went to the store on my way home and my pizzas were ready after only 15 mins. Staff greeted me and assisted in locating my order. They were very friendly. And, the pizzas were great.“

“Would not take 100 even though it came from my bank... how do you use money? I get it, have it on your card. lol. the staff was apologetic because they are told if they accept 100 bills they get in trouble. There needs to be some trust. I can't believe PM is having and overrun of 100 bill users. actually I never use them but this time I happen to had forgotten my card. I live here, I will give you my address or whatever. made to feel like a criminal for spending hard earned money.“

“Tate made my pizza perfectly!! She is so amazing!!“

“Best Detroit and Sicilian pizza ever! Staff is very friendly, Nicole is great and very knowledgeable! They have a full menu but they also have slices of several different kinds so you can try different varieties without having to buy a whole pizza! Will definitely be back, probably this week!!!“

“The pizza and monkey bread is to die for...the management and staff are even more delicious! I absolutely love this place! �“

“Their focaccia bread is to die for!! Soooo flavorful. I always get it with their oil & herb dip. I’m obsessed!! And then don’t even get me started on their chicken Alfredo…. It’s just the best. The chicken is so flavorful and it’s cooked perfectly. I wish I could just eat here every single day of my life. Best Italian restaurant we have in the state.“

“I left pics and comments regarding food. But wanted to update this. I called them and requested refund and they are sending me a gift card. They were very nice and were very apologetic. They get 5 star rating for service!!!.“

“Outstanding gentlemen at the register! And phenomenal customer service! Food is always on point! Not to mention the restaurant is cleaner than before!“

“This location is by far the best one in the Treasure Valley. The Manager, Andrew is phenomenal 👍 I recently had an issue at this location of which I won't go into the details, but long story short it was a mistake I made on my part, but Andrew was able to resolve it effectively with a superbly friendly attitude. You always feel welcome at this store and I will continue to patronize Andrew and his team for the foreseeable future. 🙂“

“Fantastic food! Our first time going there and everyone in my ground loved what they ordered. They have a pb and j burger which is my absolute favorite! Also there is a table for kids with some toys which was perfect for us.“

“Outstanding gentlemen at the register! And phenomenal customer service! Food is always on point! Not to mention the restaurant is cleaner than before!“

“My Papa Murphy Team goes above and beyond! The team of Jen, Alyssa, Liv, and Mr. Kong always treat me like a rockstar. They know me by name and always go above and beyond to make me feel like the most important customer. They truly have made my experience amazing! The Garrity Team in Nampa Idaho maybe the best customer service team I have seen anywhere!“

“Seemed like the manager, woman who was running the place tonight is the reason for this 5 star review. Shes amazing, had a mix up with DoorDash and she was so wonderful fixing it. She’s the type of person that will have people returning because of her.“

“Cleanest pizza hut in the area! Ali and Kristen have the best customer service skills. No doubt the drivers are courteous and fast. The cooks and csr's are one of a kind, especially that Sam fella. The pizzas come out of the oven looking B.E.A.- Utiful!
Can't go wrong eating here!“

“I want to know why this place is temporary closed it is a really good pizza place“

“Absolutely fantastic, every dish (including the kids' meals) was delicious, full of flavor and no one left hungry. Excellent service! 100% recommend.“

“If you want authentic Italian food straight from Italy then this is the place to go to! Original recipes from Sicily, Fresh ingredients. All of their menu items, their original garlic bread which is served like a “Pizza!” ANNND their Amazing salad dressing!!! It’s a must place to experience!!! 😃“