50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bartonville

“Dave's pizza is unmatched for freshness and consistency. Same great taste for years and always arrives quickly and steaming! In over 20 years I've only had one wrong order and they made it right straight away. This place will always be our go to pizza order“

“Their pizzas are the best around. I order one every time I’m in town. Every time.“

“Older gentleman that works there usually during the day is very nice and food is always excellent! He is very patient letting my 6 year old order his bookit pizza every month. My son is always excited to go in there and order his pizza by himself.“

“Seen this place on FB and decided to give a try when we were over that way. Customer service was excellent! My husband ordered wings and I got a quesadilla( the chicken in it had some spice and it had tomatoes, onions and jalapeños in it) both were very good! My husband ordered boneless wing and they made a mistake and gave him bone in wings, he gave him those free and then brought him his boneless ones too and thanked him for his patience. Those wings (he had the blackened bbq wings) are fantastic!! They have a little bit of a char on them and some sauce almost like the sauce is baked into them..it’s not dripping with sauce so u can’t taste anything but sauce..which I hate. If I could describe the perfect wings..these would be it! Great place , great service and great bar food..we will be back!! ty Hammer’s!!“

“Food was very good and the server was awesome!!!! Will definitely be back!!!“

“Very personable and I loved the real cheese Pizza! 🍕 One of the best Pizzas I've had in a very long time. Thank you for the great experience!“

“Being from New York I've been looking for good pizza here in the Peoria area for over 8 years. Im not one to normally leave reviews but this pizza definitely deserved it! Will be my go-to from here on out and will be vocal about Fat Jacks being the best pizza in Peoria!“

“employees are always great. very kind and friendly. even if they are super busy they keep it together and are awesome. they do an amazing job making up your pizza. every time. always make sure you get what you wanted and know how to cook everything. never had a bad experience at this store“

“Love the da Vinci delight 🍕“

“I am amazed by how well the atmosphere and the food and the drinks in the service are“

“Tenderloins are the best!“

“Ate there today with friends - service was great and friendly and everything was DELICIOUS!“

“Kimmy the bartender was unbelievably awesome talk about service with a smile.. Food was exceptional and timely great addition to downtown Peoria..RECOMMEND VISITING 😀“

“Stopped in for the taco specials on Tuesday. Tacos were great, and paired well with a nice Long Island! The pretzel poppers were excellent as well. We will definitely be stopping by in the future.“

“Thank you for your kind assistance to our students from El Vista Baptist Academy!“

“Hot food cold salad bar and great service and may seats have TVs“

“Absolutely wonderful time at Monical’s to celebrate my little girl’s birthday. It’s what she specifically requested for dinner and the staff made her feel so special! Good food, great people!“

“Had your new item a Tenderloin & Fries it was really good and you can’t beat that Grand Prairie sauce that really sets it off in fact it was so good. We went out the following week so I could get another tenderloin that’s gonna be my new go to highly recommend the food was great service was great. You gotta try the tenderloin.“

“As someone who has lived and worked in the Peoria area for many years, I truly appreciate locally owned businesses that consistently provide outstanding food and exceptional customer service. Chicago Grill is one of those special places. I have been enjoying Chicago Grill for years, and it never disappoints. The food is consistently fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. Whether you're craving authentic Chicago-style pizza, Italian beef, gyros, hot dogs, or one of their many other menu favorites, everything is prepared with care and served with pride. What really sets Chicago Grill apart is the friendly, welcoming atmosphere. The owners and staff make you feel like family and genuinely appreciate every customer who walks through the door. It's refreshing to find a restaurant that takes such pride in both the quality of its food and the experience it provides. If you're looking for authentic Chicago-style food, generous portions, and genuine hospitality in Peoria, I highly recommend Chicago Grill. It has earned my business for years, and I always look forward to my next visit.“

“Hidden gem! Great energy and excellent food selections with rotating specials. Taco Tuesdays, of course followed by meatloaf and mashed potatoes on Wednesday and homemade tenderloins on Thursday are the staple repeating specials but Monday and Friday rotate and are always good. Excellent Smashburger and some really creative appetizers and desserts round out the menu. The owner, Rebecca has excellent energy.“

“I definitely recommend the food is great! The staff however is constantly rude. The last 3 times we’ve been there we’ve had terrible experiences with the staff.“

“Great food and always nice servers“

“Lemon blueberry pizza with hot honey was really yummy! My daughter had the bbq pork Mac and cheese was also very yummy and well balanced. I paired mine with pear hard cider and it was to die for. If we were not from another state we would be back more often. Gluten free cauliflower crust was best I have had in a long time“

“wonderful pizza 🍕 and great service!“

“had a pizza when they came to Labor Day weekend in Toluca. pizza was fantastic. even though they were busy they still were respectful and never rude when i was in line ordering and waiting for my order. Definitely recommend“

“We have eaten in or we have preordered for carry out at least 2-3 times a month. Never had a bad pizza since they opened about 8 years ago(2015) at Peoria North location. The Pizza is always HOT! You pick up your pizza from the bar, and if you get there and your pizza is not ready from a call in, they offer you a drink from the bar as a complementary, wait. 5 stars any way you ask!!“

“RONNIE!!! Ronnie was my server tonight and he was the absolute best. I recommend coming to Monical’s on Knoxville, if you do ask for Ronnie, he’s the DUDE!“

“My 8 year old son wanted pizza and ice-cream so we visited Hucks establishment. The service with the lady in the kitchen was one of a kind. She was patient and willing. She didn't have an attitude and she helped us get what we wanted. As the pizza was approaching to be ready, the lady in the kitchen found me over the counter to ask which pizza I wanted and how I wanted it presented. With an awesome smile, she handed us our pizza and we went on our way to get ice-cream and leave. The attendant at the counter was also helpful with checking us out. We had a great experience. Thank you.“

“So yesterday I was close to this location and I had a BBQ Chicken take out. I totally forgot about the pizza when I came home so it had been at least an hour, I re heated in the oven and I thought I had ruined it but it was still delicious. That does not happen often with other pizzas. Have not dined in yet.“

“Great customer service and their food was good. Burger with jalapeños and the fixings. Fries are great.“

“Hoops has a filling salad and GREAT pizza!“

“We're sitting here in Pizza 150 right now waiting on our appetizers and food. We've been waiting for almost a hour, absolutely ridiculous. We use to come here and the service was great, don't know what happened but I don't think we'll be coming back. Sad that this use to be a fantastic place with great service but this sucks!!!! Got the food and it all sucked too 😭“

“The lady in the back this morning who was running the food area was severely rude. This was MONDAY SEPTEMBER 22ND AT 8:40 AM , AND KEEP IN MIND THIS HAPPENED WITHIN THE 3 MINUTES WE WERE IN THERE - a sweet old lady trying to get a coffee was asking about lids and she was super rude to her telling her all the lids are one size so they will fit while giving her a rude look and a customer ended up helping her instead of HER AN EMPLOYEE, she wasn’t even making food back there in her area but she was nonstop slamming all the doors in the back food area being super loud just giving off a bad vibe, overall she gave everyone in that place a bad rep for that location. I’m normally not the person to make a review but when you know someone needs addressed over the way they act at their job I felt obligated to say something. She might act completely different around a manager but when she’s there with no one around I’m sure she’s the way she acted today, RUDE AS HELL.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“fantastic pizza 🍕🍕🍕. We order the all meat and it is wonderful 😊“

“Godfather's Pizza is located in a Huck's gas station. We ordered a large pizza with sausage, onions and green peppers in advance. The pizza was ready on time. It had a lot of the toppings and a lot of cheese (which we like.) It had excellent taste and was one of the best pizzas we've had in a long time. Our bill was $18.25.“

“Haven’t been disappointed!! 2nd time ordering from this location. First time we had a small hiccup in our delivery but the manager was nice and changed what was messed up. Second time, great service. My order was taken by Brandon and my delivery driver was Alex both very nice and attentive. This makes ordering, eating and calling these restaurants much easier! Thank you Pizza Hut!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“newly own, by friendly people. this will be a great upcoming family place if supported! stop and give it a try!“

“great food“

“I ordered from Dominos omg I called to make sure they said yes ,short story got to wait to get my money bck, PIZZA HUT IS THE BEST CHEAPER,FAST,AND TASTE SO MUCH BETTER 💯I'M GOING TO PIZZA HUT 4 NOW ON“

“One of the best pizzas I've had. try the fresh fried mushrooms too.“

“Definitely going back! Food was amazing, and the service was even better! First time there, and it was wonderful!“

“Love this place but there has been lack of Habinero sauce on the sub so it is basically bland chicken thus cannot order my favorite anymore 😕 & is difficult to talk to an automated system rather than person. Love the people who have worked here but it has sadly become less good over time but very much will always have a special place for this business in my heart.“

“excellent service, flawless food, and welcoming vibe“

“We arrived around 6:00 p.m. on a Friday night. There were only 10 people in the restaurant. We were seated and got our drinks right way. We sat for 20 minutes before anyone took our order. We got two different waitresses. The first waitress gave us poor service. The other one at least tried. It took 1 half hours just to get served and paid. I usually leave a decent tip but after this experience I left $2.00. Our food was watery and had poor flavor. We will not be returning which is sad because we usually love the food and always had good service.“

“Incredible pizza. Never had anything like it. Ordered it to go.“