13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Benton

“Great pizza and great service. My daughter says our cute Catholic waiter was her favorite part!“

“I think Casey’s pizzas are the best around southern Illinois for the price! I love the point system and it has came in very handy when I needed it. I had over 100$ that came from the point system which is very useful when running low on cash and you need gas or something to eat! I find that the majority of the workers at the East Main Store in Benton are friendly and very helpful! It’s honestly hard to get good service in a lot of places these days! I highly recommend Casey’s for gas, food, snacks and friendly service!“

“ordered 2 large supreme pizzas today. picked them up and got home and they were still hot and delicious! Good job pizza hut. Actually the only pizza I like!“

“We stopped by this Dominoes on our way home. I’m glad we did! We ordered a veggie pizza and an extra cheese pizza. They were both cooked very well! The crust was fantastic even if they forgot to use the roller on the dough to prevent bubbles. It tasted great! Looked great, smelled great and tasted fantastic! I was too hungry and it tasted too good to remember pictures.“

“We love Webb's pizza!!!! Perfect crust,perfect sauce, and always tastes the same..... AWESOME!!!!! Super lucky to live 4 blocks away!!! keep up the good work!!! 6 stars out of 5!!!“

“Had such a great lunch today. We enjoyed the pizza and salad bar. Everything was fresh and tasty! Our server was amazing. She kept up with our table and our refills. I wish I would have caught her name but she had short curly hair. This was our first time here and we will definitely be back!“

“Wonderful pizza. The crust is amazingly good, the place smells so good of pizza just pulling up in the parking lot. Friendly staff. Very clean.

Vegetarian options: If you want a vegan pizza they are happy to make you the vegan type of pizza VEGITABLES you want. Very nice staff“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“We moved from the area, live in a town with almost 200,000, and DiMaggio's pizza is unmatched! The guy's are so kind and friendly! But his sauce, allot of toppings... These are sooo good! Please add this place, in Christopher, to your pizza hunt!“

“Highly Recommended! If you're looking for mouthwatering food, great portions, and warm-hearted service, look no further than Home Run Grill! Every bite feels like a home run — from their juicy burgers and cheesy pizzas to their delicious daily specials that always hit the spot. 🍔🍕🔥 What makes this place truly special is the friendly atmosphere and welcoming staff who go out of their way to make you feel like family. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a meal with friends, you’ll leave with a full stomach and a big smile! Support local, eat well, and treat yourself — you deserve it. Home Run Grill is a gem you don’t want to miss! 🙌❤️“

“We decided to order pizza Tuesday night. Upon pick up it smelled so good we had to try a pice. It was delicious! We regretted not ordering the parmesan garlic bread bites. We pulled over and placed an order and went back for them. They were fresh, hot, and melted in your mouth like butter! Our best Domino’s experience ever was found in West Frankfort, Illinois on a Tuesday night!“

“Just stopped in here tonite for some original pizzas on the go. They made us fresh pizzas fast and it was the BEST Little Caesars pizza we have ever had! We travel and have tried the pizza at many different locations all over the US. This is by far the best location we have visited. Thank you for the delicious pizza guys!“