5 Best Coffee Shops in Geneseo

“Pegasus is truly a wonderful asset to downtown Geneseo. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, the selection of items is thoughtfully curated, and the homemade fudge is a must-try. We’re fortunate to have such a charming shop in our small town!“

“Great atmosphere. Super nice staff. Helped me find my new favorite drink!!“

“tried for the time today and I got the "barista choice" and got a pink Starburst and my husband got the #2 and we also got a raisan cinnamon bagel with cinnamon cream cheese and he got the red velvet muffin and they are absolutely AMAZING“

“I frequent Scooter’s Coffee for my late afternoon pick-me-ups—especially their Red Bull infusions! They’re always delicious and give me just the right boost to get through the rest of my day. When I’m in the mood for a coffee drink, I love that Scooter’s doesn’t charge extra for nut milk options. The service is always outstanding, and every visit feels friendly and consistent. Their app is convenient and super easy to use, which makes ordering ahead a breeze. Highly recommend!“

“My experience was amazing. I was on a trip with a large group of people. All of the employees were very accommodating to or large amount of people. I would like to thank the employees. One of the busses we took broke down. The employees were very helpful.“