7 Best Italian Restaurants near Herrin

“Best place to get a hot sandwich in Southern Illinois. Reminds me of the Italian groceries my dad loved up along the east coast.“

“Joe's Pizza is a local treasure. Always good food and service. Special mention for Emily, though I don't know her last name. She is always smiling, and makes me look forward to my next visit.“

“All around one of the best places with tasty pizzas and much more with big selections if your hungry for something other than pizzas I strongly suggest T-Moe’s pizza with other options to eat delicious pizzas burgers fries and nachos and fried mushrooms and fried ravioli and fried pickles and salad and much more to try including pasta and much more and the service is amazing and great staff and amazing prices“

“My husband and I both had the crispy chicken ranch salad. It was very good and the breadsticks were hot and fresh. Staff was very friendly 👍👍“

“Date night with the husband was one of the best. We had amazing service. The server was attentive, quick to approach, offered and suggested appetizers. Other employees saw empty plates as they walked by and took them away. It was great teamwork by the entire staff. The hosts were friendly and quick to greet and get us seated. Food tasted amazing as it always does.“

“We had the chicken spice pizza & the BEST hot Italian beef sandwich! Will for sure be coming back!“

“Follow up was invited back to try again. Want to Thank the Management for the improvements made . Return meal was awesome
Management was not aware of who I was when I returned , so it wasn't special treatment. Was very happy with the food, atmosphere and customer service. Will be back for sure ! Thank Dale 02-13-2026

2nd review. Food was horrible , didn't receive appetizer until after main course. Had the shrimp, peppers and onions ,oil in the fryer was burnt and old ! Never received any response from management no apologies from them at all....“