4.5
Superb
168 Reviews
527 Auburn Drive, Island Lake · 7.06 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Classic Thin Crust Hot Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- Original Stuffed Nana's Special Pizza
- Classic Thin Crust BBQ Chicken Pizza
- 18 Family Classic Thin Crust
“⭐ Neighbor Proof Review for Nancy’s Pizza – Island Lake Nancy’s Pizza in Island Lake has been part of my life for years, and they’ve never missed. The food is always hot, consistent, and made by people who actually care about the neighborhood. Every time I walk in, they know me, they know my family, and they treat everyone like regulars. This is the kind of local spot that defines a town — honest, reliable, and always solid. If you want real Island Lake pizza, this is it.”